(3 pack) NYX Professional Makeup Slim Eye Pencil, Creamy longwear eyeliner, Black

I love the eye liners and the way the glide on, they last all day and the colors are perfect. However, I have noticed the last couple of times that they are hard to sharpen. They sharpen more on one side or the tips break off causing you to have to sharpen it more. I thought maybe my sharpener was getting dull, so I bought a new, same thing. I don't know if they are being made out of the same material or if I just received some older ones. I will say that it happened with both of the colors that I ordered so I can't say that it was one or the other. I do love them and will continue to purchase them because other than the sharpening issue, they are amazing!

I need a dark blue eyeliner, usually I purchase the Epic liners but thought I would try this one, I am pleased to say the least, the staying power is unbelievable. With that being said, it is a bit difficult to remove, even after my shower and cleansing routine there is still liner. I have to then take a Kleenex and run my finger along my eye to remove it completely.