NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen - Lil Toasty, Lil Toasty, 0.03 fl oz

I've tried a lot of eyeliners. Other than mascara, it's all I really use for the entirety of my makeup. NYX's Epic Ink Waterproof Eyeliner in Black is my go-to every single time. It doesn't smudge, which is why it's my favorite. My eyes water a lot, and every other eyeliner, including waterproof ones, smudges. This one does not. The tip of the marker is easy to get thin, crisp lines. I've been able to create small, tiny bats for example on my cheekbones and people thought it was a stamp because of how precise I'm able to get with this eyeliner. My only qualm with this eyeliner is that it randomly bubbles up, losing quite a bit of eyeliner each time. I've seen others talk about this problem too, so maybe it's something NYX might want to fix. Other than that, though, I highly recommend this eyeliner for most eyeliner needs.

I've been wearing eyeliner since middle school, back in the day. It was a pencil and that's all we used, I've always loved makeup so I always experimented, I have hooded eyes so getting a desired liner effect with a nice wing is close to impossible without transferring on the upper lid or the black kind of just fading throughout the day and not looking as good, but this is by far the best eyeliner that I have ever used for my upper lid and I haven't gone to anything else since finding it, applying is super easy it's super pigmented, if you let it dry it's smudge proof just make sure your lids aren't too oily so maybe use some powder before hand, it stays all day honestly whenever I have a good eyeliner day, I hate taking it off because I wish I could just stay there. I love this stuff.