e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Charcoal

I wound up trying most of elf eyeliners..so Pros and Cons Pro: easy to put on, goes on smooth, and lasts all day Pro: it's smooth and creamy more like a crayon than a pencil Pro: retracts nice and easy so easy to travel with Con: thick more like a pencil than liquid. Overall it's an in between of the pencil and liquid so you can get it too fine I'm wearing the charcoal in the picture.

This was the first time I'd tried an eyeliner. This product was easy to open and apply. The eyeliner is retractable, so it's easy to keep your eyeliner shape fresh. I tested the eyeliner before my initial wearand i'm glad I did. The eyeliner applies evenly. It was a bit stiff and waxy since it was new. I was able to apply it without any real issue. But a few minutes after applying it, my eyelid began to tingle and feel itchy. It turns out I had a reaction to the eyeliner. I wore it for a few hours, and by the time I removed the liner, I noticed my eyelid had swollen a bit. I don't know if it was a reaction to something in the eyeliner itself or if it was a sensitivity to the waterproof element.