e.l.f. Waterproof Eyeliner Pen, Coffee

This is the first time I've tried liquid eyeliner. I'm still getting used to it, but it goes on much easier than the "crayon" version (non-Elf brand) I was using before. I'd prefer the brown color to be more brown. It's still a bit too black for my fair skin.

this was smudge on your upper eyelid and lower eyelid if you wear it to bed. especially down the cheek from the end of your eye sockets the side of them closest to your ear. ive woken up twice this way since I bought the makeup. so i know. oily. elf makeup is alright but seems to he a brand a woman needs to reapply more than once a day if using. the eyemakeup.