L'Oreal Paris Infallible Smokissime Powder Eyeliner Pen, Black Smoke

Love it and love the color

At first I thought the fat applicator would be tricky, but if I go slowly with just the tip, I get exactly the right line. Often, I use a fine angle brush to extend and blend a little further, and use what the brush picked up to smudge my bottom lashes. I didn't have problems with crumbling. A primer helps make it last, and for extra insurance I sometimes go over it with my darkest powder eye shadow and an angled brush before the gel "sets"--so as I do when using and blending fine line liquid. This makes the smokey eye so easy!