Maybelline New York Line Express Eyeliner, Soft Black

This is by far my most favorite eye liner! I have been using this for many years without any issues. I have super sensitive eyes, and this is the only product that works for me. I thought this was discontinued awhile ago, and have tried other products without success. I finally found more of these at a local store and couldn't be happier to have it back! I hope Maybelline keeps this eye pencil around for years to come.

I've used this product for years because its a great product. However, I'm quite disappointed for three reasons. One, because there's not one single store that carries this pencil eyeliner and is only available for purchase online. Which, is advertised at one price, but when you get to the check out the price appears to be three dollars extra (without tax/shipping). Two, the eyeliner casing (online version) keeps breaking when the pencil is sharpened; the core formula seems to be the same and it does the job. Three, the eyeliner now comes wrapped in a really tight wrap paper with an inside sticker barcode that leaves the pencil and fingers very sticky and gooey. Other than that, I still love this eyeliner and will continue to use for as long as its available. Maybelline, please return to the old manufacturing material for the casing and start distributing to the stores. Thanks!