Skip to Main Content
Walmart
All Departments
All Services
Customer ratings and reviews for
Maybelline Super Stay Teddy Tint, Long Lasting Matte Lip Stain, Skinnydip, 0.17 fl oz
4.2 out of 5 stars
stars
1,758 ratings785 reviews
  1. 5 stars65% (1,146)
  2. 4 stars14% (244)
  3. 3 stars8% (148)
  4. 2 stars4% (78)
  5. 1 star8% (142)
How item rating is calculated

Reviews summary

Pros

  • : Provides a delicate, natural pink color.
  • : Has a subtle, warm pink hue.
  • : Has a fruity or sweet aroma.
  • : Provides smooth, comfortable application with a beautiful wash of color.
  • : Colors are wide-ranging and long-lasting.

Neutral

  • : Can be strong, but inconsistent across surfaces.
Generated by AI

Customer photos

  • +617 images
Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 785 reviews
Feb 26, 2026
Lisa
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 20 Mascara Tear
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Maybelline Super Stay

Maybelline Super Stay Matte Lip Stain. ... This is my favorite color, but I must say I own 6 colors. These are the only lip stains I use. They are very long lasting and they literally are the best I have ever used. I want every color and I plan on purchasing more. My hubby told me they made my lips look bigger. That is a plus as well.

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Mar 28, 2026
Sephardi
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 15 Skinny Dip
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

impressive

Pretty. This sticks on the lips beautifully. Insignificant feathering in the inside of lips after 18 plus hours of normal wear with eating as well. No transfer whatsoever. I am impressed. Pretty colors. It is way better than a vinyl style from Revlon years ago. I like this a lot. Jesus loves you and your soul is priceless!

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Mar 31, 2026
MarieS
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

My Favourite - Teddy Tint Soft Lip Gloss

I really like Maybelline's Teddy Tint Soft Lip Gloss. It doesn't dry my lips, isn't sticky, doesn't transfer, and lasts all day. I finally found the right shade for my light to medium complexion and salt/pepper coloured hair. Petalcore is the perfect shade of pink that brightens my mood and appearance. I will definitely buy this lip gloss again.

International review
Review from walmart.ca
Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Apr 19, 2026
Walmart customer
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 120 Endgame
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Outstanding tint highly recommended

I am unable to wear regular lipstick.And this is great stain.First time i've tried a stain.But exactly what it says in their description is exactly what it is.You can layer it and and megan is light or as dark as you want.The light one is perfect if you just want a little color and not overdo it.I highly recommend this item. it does not come off like normal lipsticks.Do and get all over glasses?Your clothing and everything this product doesn't

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Jun 8, 2026
JA
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 45 Pinky Promise
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

The color was just what I wanted. I use one coat it lasts for hours. It does dry your lips out though so I use lip balm with it. Also I layered a little bit of a less expensive lip stick (wet and wild) that was shinier over it and the combination lasted longer than just the less expensive lip stick by itself. The bottle is so pretty you can leave it out.

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Feb 5, 2026
Walmart customer
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 55 Knee High
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Unbeatable Staying Power!!

I am genuinely impressed with the Maybelline Teddy Tint. I wore the shade 'Kneehigh' through a full 12-hour day, including multiple meals and drinks, and the color didn't budge. In fact, it was still visible the next morning! It has a comfortable matte finish that doesn't feel overly drying. If you're looking for a low-maintenance lip stain that actually lasts, this is it. Knee-high is a lovely mauve shade!

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Jun 26, 2026
Amy
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 10 Current Mood
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Sticky!

I actually ordered L'Oréal in my usual shade but my shopper substituted this product before I could disapprove. The color is more of a gloss and hard to even notice. The applicator is good but the product is super sticky and remains that way rather than drying flat. My lips kept sticking together when I talked and it was annoying. I do not recommend the product based on the tacky consistency.

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
reply from MaybellineConsumerCare

Hey! Thank you for sharing your thoughts on our Super Stay Teddy Tint. We are so sorry to hear about the mix-up with your pickup order and that the formula did not meet your expectations. While this long-lasting matte lip stain is designed to deliver a comfortable, blurred, and lightweight finish with a soft wash of color, we are sorry to hear that the consistency felt tacky and kept your lips sticking together. For a comfortable, weightless feel, we suggest applying a very thin layer and allowing it to dry completely without pressing your lips together too soon. Since your purchase was made through Walmart, we suggest contacting their customer support team directly for assistance with returns or exchanges so you can get the exact product and shade you wanted. We also invite you to explore our other lip options to help you discover a formula and finish you truly love! XO

Jun 1, 2026
Kalani
Top Reviewer
Item details
Color: 20 Mascara Tear
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Disappointed

I wanna start by saying that I ordered a completely different brand for delivery and I got this item as a substitution now the color was quite pretty. It went on smooth and easy no complaints there. What I do wanna say is that it does not act as a lip stain. It is not a mat lipstick because it makes your lips so tacky. They just keep sticking together repeatedly to a point where you need to wipe it off however, when you go to wipe it off, it literally is like that sticker on the bottom of a mug that just will not come off it'll come off and little sheets and leave patches everywhere I had to physically scrub my mouth using a lip oil and a T-shirt to get it to come off because washing it it would not come off. I will 100% be returning this item to the store oh and I did give it a chance to stain my lips. I left it on for 25 minutes and did not eat or drink anything. My lips are burning from scrubbing rn and pale as ever i'm hoping my photos do a good job at showing just how much it hurt my lips to scrub that hard and how patchy it is

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
reply from MaybellineConsumerCare

Hello! We're so sorry to hear about the experience you had with our Super Stay Teddy Tint. We'd like to speak with you directly. Please call us at 800-944-0730 and provide the case number 46790364. Our customer service representatives are available Monday through Friday, 9:00 am to 5:30 pm ET. We look forward to speaking with you soon!

Feb 22, 2026
cate
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed

I was excited to try it, but it felt like the bottle wasn't full. I had to get more product from the bottle multiple times just to cover my whole lip. I do agree that the consistentcy of the product does feel soft when first applied, but it dried out my lips.

International review
Review from walmart.ca
Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
Dec 23, 2025
Joyce
Item details
Color: 30 Coquettish
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Unfortunately; this product was a total disappointment as well as wasted money. It was sticky, and color was ugly. It's hard to remove and tacky feeling on lips, not matt but sticky. I threw it away but liked their other lipsticks. I do not recommend.

Helpful?62NXDBO3JBOH8876216141
reply from MaybellineConsumerCare

Hello Joyce! We're truly sorry to hear our Super Stay Teddy Tint Long Lasting Matte Lip Stain wasn't the right fit for you. Our Super Stay line is crafted for exceptional longevity, which can sometimes result in a unique feel, and we understand that individual preferences for shades and finishes vary widely. We appreciate you sharing your experience, and it's wonderful to know you've found other Maybelline lipsticks you love.