I actually own this in long sleeve in 3 colors and it is one of my favorite tops. I didn't realize it came in short sleeve until I found it here. I've had really good luck with Pretty Garden, I usually wear a Medium in most brands and their medium fits me perfect so I would say this top is true to size. The fabric is ribbed and very stretchy. I'm 5'2", busty and weigh around 145lbs. The buttons are functional and I think it looks nice buttoned or with a few buttons undone as well. The color is a very nice, saturated black. The sleeves hit nicely on the arm. The short length hits about where the belt line of a mid rise pant would sit. The length is perfect for tucking into a high waist pant, skirt etc. I can definitely see myself buying this in more colors.

I really like this top! The material is soft, stretchy, and very comfortable to wear all day. The ribbed fabric looks nice, and the buttons in the front add a cute touch. It fits well and keeps its shape after washing. Perfect for casual outfits or layering. Great quality for the price!

This is such a soft Henley. It is fitted and stretchy! I love the buttons so you can adjust the fit. The range of colors are amazing. This was perfect to wear even on an 8 hr flight- I looked nice but felt comfortable!

Super cute! Can go under any jacket or you can wear alone! Perfect fit!

Great Henley I like this shorter length and cute buttoned front. I ordered just 1 to try it out. Then ordered 4 more. Lots of colors to choose from. Looks nice with shorts and jeans. I usually wear small but went with medium. I recommend sizing up. Washes and dries with no wrinkles and doesn't shrink.

I ordered the dark blue and the blue grey. Well made nice Henley. I usually buy a small but ordered these in medium and they are a perfect fit. I suggest you size up.

This shirt is soft and comfortable. I usually wear a small, but glad I purchased this in a medium. It fits well because it is more of a snug fit. Love it! The color is awesome too great with jeans!!

Fast shipping. The top looks exactly as pictured in the royal blue color. Nice quality fabric. I am a size 6 or medium and the top I ordered was a medium. It fits perfectly. I am going to buy another top like this. The perfect summer top.

Nice Henley. It is very comfortable moves with you. Washed well. The color I got was supposed to be a shade of red but it's more of a rust color.

my only complaint is that it's short on the waist. I think with enough wear, and washing it will shrink up and not be practical anymore. I like the color and the bottons are real. my review is based on first-time try on. 5'5", 190.