Featured ShopsAppliances Parts & AccessoriesBohemianCandles & Home FragranceClocksCloset OrganizersClothing SteamersCuisinartDining & EntertainingFall DecorGarment Closet LaundryHayneedleIrons, Steamers & AccessoriesKitchen AppliancesKitchen OutletKitchen Storage & OrganizationLaundry Storage & OrganizationLighting & Light FixturesMajor AppliancesSavings on Favorite Kitchen BrandsShop All DecorShop all Kitchen & DiningShop all Storage & OrganizationTools & GadgetsWashers & Dryers
Sort by|
Featured ShopsAppliances Parts & AccessoriesBohemianCandles & Home FragranceClocksCloset OrganizersClothing SteamersCuisinartDining & EntertainingFall DecorGarment Closet LaundryHayneedleIrons, Steamers & AccessoriesKitchen AppliancesKitchen OutletKitchen Storage & OrganizationLaundry Storage & OrganizationLighting & Light FixturesMajor AppliancesSavings on Favorite Kitchen BrandsShop All DecorShop all Kitchen & DiningShop all Storage & OrganizationTools & GadgetsWashers & Dryers
Toaster Handle(63)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
Toastmaster 2-Slice Multi-Function Toaster - Sage Green with Lever and Dial Controls, Extra Wide Slots, High Rise Toast Lift and Gluten Free Setting, 900W From $30.97

Sponsored
From$3097
Toastmaster 2-Slice Multi-Function Toaster - Sage Green with Lever and Dial Controls, Extra Wide Slots, High Rise Toast Lift and Gluten Free Setting, 900W
4.3 out of 5 stars
Flash Deal, Mecity Easy Touch Screen Toaster 2 Slice – Retro Wide Slot Stainless Steel Toaster with Large Display, 6 Browning Levels, Bagel, Defrost & Reheat, Removable Crumb Tray, Cream Color From $44.99
Flash Deal

Sponsored
From$4499
Mecity Easy Touch Screen Toaster 2 Slice – Retro Wide Slot Stainless Steel Toaster with Large Display, 6 Browning Levels, Bagel, Defrost & Reheat, Removable Crumb Tray, Cream Color
4.7 out of 5 stars
J&V TEXTILES Cool Touch Toaster with 6 Temperature Settings & Extra Wide 1.25" Slots for Bagels, Waffles, Specialty Breads, Puff Pastry, Snacks, ETL Certified, 2 Slices Black From $21.99

Sponsored
From$2199
J&V TEXTILES Cool Touch Toaster with 6 Temperature Settings & Extra Wide 1.25" Slots for Bagels, Waffles, Specialty Breads, Puff Pastry, Snacks, ETL Certified, 2 Slices Black
3 out of 5 stars
Vollrath CT4-120450 Conveyor Toaster, 10.5" Wide Conveyor, 120v $1,525.85

Sponsored
$1,52585
current price $1,525.85Vollrath CT4-120450 Conveyor Toaster, 10.5" Wide Conveyor, 120v
Practical Easy Installation Replacement Levers Knob Set Plastic Texture for Electric Toasters Suitable for Various Models

Practical Easy Installation Replacement Levers Knob Set Plastic Texture for Electric Toasters Suitable for Various Models
Unique Bargains Refrigerator Oven Toaster Door Release Pull Handle Latch Knob 10cm $14.29

$1429
current price $14.29Unique Bargains Refrigerator Oven Toaster Door Release Pull Handle Latch Knob 10cm
Kitchen Hot Clamp for Microwave Toaster Oven - Non-Heating Lever Assisted Grip Tool with Silicone Pads - Heat Resistant Dish Handling Accessory for Plates Bowls - Multi-Angle Kitchen Gripper $6.61
$661
current price $6.61Kitchen Hot Clamp for Microwave Toaster Oven - Non-Heating Lever Assisted Grip Tool with Silicone Pads - Heat Resistant Dish Handling Accessory for Plates Bowls - Multi-Angle Kitchen Gripper
Clearance, DEEPCRAFF 3-Piece Bread Maker Toaster Lever Accessories, Black Plastic Replacement Handles for Responsive Appliance Control $11.29 Was $12.69
Clearance

Now$1129
current price Now $11.29, Was $12.69$12.69
DEEPCRAFF 3-Piece Bread Maker Toaster Lever Accessories, Black Plastic Replacement Handles for Responsive Appliance Control
Replacement Toaster Levers Knob, Black Plastic, 0.98 x 1.18 x 0.59 Inch

Replacement Toaster Levers Knob, Black Plastic, 0.98 x 1.18 x 0.59 Inch
Replacement Lever Handles for Cuisinart Custom Select Toaster, Control Knob Repair Parts for Kitchen Appliance Operation and Maintenance, 2PCS $19.90

$1990
current price $19.90Replacement Lever Handles for Cuisinart Custom Select Toaster, Control Knob Repair Parts for Kitchen Appliance Operation and Maintenance, 2PCS
Best seller, Nostalgia 2-Slot Retro Pop-Up Bun and Hot Dog Toaster with Removable Hot Dog Cage and Mini Tongs, Red From $29.99
Best seller

Sponsored
From$2999
Nostalgia 2-Slot Retro Pop-Up Bun and Hot Dog Toaster with Removable Hot Dog Cage and Mini Tongs, Red
4.2 out of 5 stars
Deal, 2 Slice Slim Toaster, Long Extra Wide Slots for Bagels Waffles, 7 Shade Settings, Removable Crumb Tray, Compact Small Kitchen Dorm RV, 750W, Red From $21.84 Was $34.99
Deal

Sponsored
From$2184
$34.99
2 Slice Slim Toaster, Long Extra Wide Slots for Bagels Waffles, 7 Shade Settings, Removable Crumb Tray, Compact Small Kitchen Dorm RV, 750W, Red
4.9 out of 5 stars
Waring - 027171 - Toaster Knob, Right Side $22.46

$2246
current price $22.46Waring - 027171 - Toaster Knob, Right Side
Toaster Lever Handle Replacement Compatible with Cuisinart, Fit for RBT-775 RBT-775BKPC RBT-775WPC 4-Slice Models, Easy Snap-On Repair Handle $24.00

$2400
current price $24.00Toaster Lever Handle Replacement Compatible with Cuisinart, Fit for RBT-775 RBT-775BKPC RBT-775WPC 4-Slice Models, Easy Snap-On Repair Handle
SWETRACE Toaster Tongs, Khaki Ergonomic Serving Clamp for Bread, Bagels, Toast, Home Kitchen Cooking Tool, Easy Grip Handle $7.50 Was $9.87

Now$750
current price Now $7.50, Was $9.87$9.87
SWETRACE Toaster Tongs, Khaki Ergonomic Serving Clamp for Bread, Bagels, Toast, Home Kitchen Cooking Tool, Easy Grip Handle
Star 2R-2100062 Knob, Toaster Control $61.10

$6110
current price $61.10Star 2R-2100062 Knob, Toaster Control
Mavrik Conveyor Toaster Knob w/ Pointer $38.55

$3855
current price $38.55Mavrik Conveyor Toaster Knob w/ Pointer
CTIRCHIU Modern Metal Appliance Handle, Plated Silver, Extended Bar, Seamless Design for Kitchens $13.43 Was $15.09

Now$1343
current price Now $13.43, Was $15.09$15.09
CTIRCHIU Modern Metal Appliance Handle, Plated Silver, Extended Bar, Seamless Design for Kitchens
Mobutofu 2Pcs Oven Toaster Accessories Black Stainless Steel Reinforced Handle Easy Hanging for Holiday Baking $12.18

$1218
current price $12.18Mobutofu 2Pcs Oven Toaster Accessories Black Stainless Steel Reinforced Handle Easy Hanging for Holiday Baking
HINTRMENT Toaster Tongs, 1 Pc Beige Beech Wood Easy Grip Handle for Cooking and Baking $9.88

$988
current price $9.88HINTRMENT Toaster Tongs, 1 Pc Beige Beech Wood Easy Grip Handle for Cooking and Baking
Deal, 【Ultra-Slim Space-Saving】4-Slice Long Slot Toaster, Dual 10-Inch Slots, 6 Shade Settings with Cancel/Reheat/Defrost, Removable Crumb Tray, Easy to Store Vertically From $24.99 Was $29.99
Deal

Sponsored
From$2499
$29.99
【Ultra-Slim Space-Saving】4-Slice Long Slot Toaster, Dual 10-Inch Slots, 6 Shade Settings with Cancel/Reheat/Defrost, Removable Crumb Tray, Easy to Store Vertically
3.9 out of 5 stars
Deal, Yabano Toaster 4 Slice, Extra Wide Slots, Stainless Steel with High Lift Lever From $24.99
Deal

Sponsored
From$2499
Yabano Toaster 4 Slice, Extra Wide Slots, Stainless Steel with High Lift Lever
4.5 out of 5 stars
FOMIYES Toaster Tongs with Ergonomic Khaki Handle, Non-Scratch Kitchen Serving Tongs for Toast, Bread and Everyday Snacks $7.49 Was $9.85

Now$749
current price Now $7.49, Was $9.85$9.85
FOMIYES Toaster Tongs with Ergonomic Khaki Handle, Non-Scratch Kitchen Serving Tongs for Toast, Bread and Everyday Snacks
BESTYASH Toaster Tongs with Ergonomic Khaki Handle, Kitchen Bread Toast Serving Clip for Daily Home Use $7.49 Was $9.85

Now$749
current price Now $7.49, Was $9.85$9.85
BESTYASH Toaster Tongs with Ergonomic Khaki Handle, Kitchen Bread Toast Serving Clip for Daily Home Use
Compatible Plastic Levers Knob Universally Fit Replacement Part for Toaster Easy Installation for Kitchen Appliances From $8.95
From$895
Compatible Plastic Levers Knob Universally Fit Replacement Part for Toaster Easy Installation for Kitchen Appliances
Star Knob, Toaster Control 2R-2100062 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part $37.84

$3784
current price $37.84Star Knob, Toaster Control 2R-2100062 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
1 Pcs Wooden Oven Rack Puller, Shelf Puller Long Handle Oven Puller Pusher Stick, Premium Beech Wood Oven Rack Puller, Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories for Toaster Oven Air Fryer 11"

1 Pcs Wooden Oven Rack Puller, Shelf Puller Long Handle Oven Puller Pusher Stick, Premium Beech Wood Oven Rack Puller, Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories for Toaster Oven Air Fryer 11"
1 out of 5 stars
Grill Basket,Multi Purpose Mesh Stainless Steel Folding Toast Tongs,Long Handle Campfire Kitchen Bread Toaster Tongs,Suitable for Bread,Toast and Sandwich $10.99

$1099
current price $10.99Grill Basket,Multi Purpose Mesh Stainless Steel Folding Toast Tongs,Long Handle Campfire Kitchen Bread Toaster Tongs,Suitable for Bread,Toast and Sandwich
DRAFIDEEP Home Use Bamboo Toaster Kitchen Tongs with Comfortable Ergonomic Handle in Khaki $11.08

$1108
current price $11.08DRAFIDEEP Home Use Bamboo Toaster Kitchen Tongs with Comfortable Ergonomic Handle in Khaki
ForeverPRO W10334178 Lever for Whirlpool Toaster 1877589 AH3489697 EA3489697 PS3489697 $22.62

$2262
current price $22.62ForeverPRO W10334178 Lever for Whirlpool Toaster 1877589 AH3489697 EA3489697 PS3489697
In 200+ people's carts, Suodoka 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster, Digital Touch Control with 6 Shade Settings, 5 Functions & 9.84" Extra-Wide Slots $40.49 Was $189.99
In 200+ people's carts

Sponsored
Now$4049
current price Now $40.49, Was $189.99$189.99
Suodoka 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster, Digital Touch Control with 6 Shade Settings, 5 Functions & 9.84" Extra-Wide Slots
4.2 out of 5 stars
Mecity 2-Slice Toaster with Extra Wide Slots, Bagel Function, 6 Browning Settings, Metallic Grey From $35.98

Sponsored
From$3598
Mecity 2-Slice Toaster with Extra Wide Slots, Bagel Function, 6 Browning Settings, Metallic Grey
4.6 out of 5 stars
WEAVILUX 2Pcs Stainless Steel Oven Door Handle Replacement for Breakfast Service Area, Heat Resistant, Durable $13.68

$1368
current price $13.68WEAVILUX 2Pcs Stainless Steel Oven Door Handle Replacement for Breakfast Service Area, Heat Resistant, Durable
Oven Rack Puller - Push Pull Tool, Prevent Scalding, Pull Out Hot Racks Safely, Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories, Suitable For Kitchen, Air Fryer $19.98

$1998
current price $19.98Oven Rack Puller - Push Pull Tool, Prevent Scalding, Pull Out Hot Racks Safely, Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories, Suitable For Kitchen, Air Fryer
Oven Rack Puller,1.54x11.02 Inches Wood Oven Rack Push Pull Tool,Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories for Kitchen Oven Air Fryer Etc Users to Prevent Scalding,Khaki From $4.19
From$419
Oven Rack Puller,1.54x11.02 Inches Wood Oven Rack Push Pull Tool,Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories for Kitchen Oven Air Fryer Etc Users to Prevent Scalding,Khaki
BRIGHTFUFU Toaster Tongs, 1 Count, Handle Toast Tongs for Bread, Bagels, Cooking, BBQ, Lightweight Kitchen Tool $8.18 Was $9.19

Now$818
current price Now $8.18, Was $9.19$9.19
BRIGHTFUFU Toaster Tongs, 1 Count, Handle Toast Tongs for Bread, Bagels, Cooking, BBQ, Lightweight Kitchen Tool
WEUVEB 3Pcs Black Plastic Toaster Control Knobs, Replacement Appliance Parts for Responsive Toaster Heat Setting Control $11.30 Was $12.70

Now$1130
current price Now $11.30, Was $12.70$12.70
WEUVEB 3Pcs Black Plastic Toaster Control Knobs, Replacement Appliance Parts for Responsive Toaster Heat Setting Control
Vadktai Oven Rack Puller, Wood Oven Rack Push Pull Tool, Prevent Scalding, Pull out Hot Racks Safely, Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories, Suitable For Kitchen Oven, Air fryer $5.99

$599
current price $5.99Vadktai Oven Rack Puller, Wood Oven Rack Push Pull Tool, Prevent Scalding, Pull out Hot Racks Safely, Long Handle Toaster Oven Accessories, Suitable For Kitchen Oven, Air fryer
Bakers Pride Handle, C Shapped Oval Large 312617 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part $67.70

$6770
current price $67.70Bakers Pride Handle, C Shapped Oval Large 312617 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
Wooden Oven Rack Puller Stick, Push Pull Tool with Longer Handle Ideal for Kitchen Oven, Toaster Oven, Air Fryer, Convection Oven and Small Kitchen Appliances, Pull Out the Slot, Tray $10.99

$1099
current price $10.99Wooden Oven Rack Puller Stick, Push Pull Tool with Longer Handle Ideal for Kitchen Oven, Toaster Oven, Air Fryer, Convection Oven and Small Kitchen Appliances, Pull Out the Slot, Tray
Milisten Kitchen Toaster Tongs Bread Clip with Ergonomic Khaki Handle Nonstick Cookware Tool for Home Use $7.49 Was $9.85

Now$749
current price Now $7.49, Was $9.85$9.85
Milisten Kitchen Toaster Tongs Bread Clip with Ergonomic Khaki Handle Nonstick Cookware Tool for Home Use
Kitandove Kitchen Toaster Tong with Easy Grip Handle for Toasting and Grilling Food $7.70 Was $10.85

Now$770
current price Now $7.70, Was $10.85$10.85
Kitandove Kitchen Toaster Tong with Easy Grip Handle for Toasting and Grilling Food
Refrigerator Oven Toaster Door Release Pull Handle Latch Knob 10cm Length $29.80

$2980
current price $29.80Refrigerator Oven Toaster Door Release Pull Handle Latch Knob 10cm Length
Oven Tray Grabber Tool,Safe Clip with Heat-Resistant Handle for Hot Baking Sheets,Grill Grates,Air Fryer Baskets & Toaster Oven Trays,1pack $9.99

$999
current price $9.99Oven Tray Grabber Tool,Safe Clip with Heat-Resistant Handle for Hot Baking Sheets,Grill Grates,Air Fryer Baskets & Toaster Oven Trays,1pack
NICEXMAS 2-Pack Stainless Steel Grill Handle Tools with Plastic Grip for Toaster Oven Use $19.58

$1958
current price $19.58NICEXMAS 2-Pack Stainless Steel Grill Handle Tools with Plastic Grip for Toaster Oven Use
HAMPPLIES Universal Handle for Kitchen Muffin Machine Wooden Light Yellow 1Pack $15.47

$1547
current price $15.47HAMPPLIES Universal Handle for Kitchen Muffin Machine Wooden Light Yellow 1Pack
Toaster Oven Handle Support Compatible With Delonghi Model Numbers AS670, XA34BL, XU400, XU31LD, XU32D, XU16 $24.99 $8.33/oz

$2499
current price $24.99$8.33/oz
Toaster Oven Handle Support Compatible With Delonghi Model Numbers AS670, XA34BL, XU400, XU31LD, XU32D, XU16
COMPUKAS Toaster Tongs with Ergonomic Handle for Safe Cooking, Grilling, and Serving $6.69 Was $9.83

Now$669
current price Now $6.69, Was $9.83$9.83
COMPUKAS Toaster Tongs with Ergonomic Handle for Safe Cooking, Grilling, and Serving
CIMAXIC 10 Pack Toast Tongs with Heat Insulating Handle, Toaster Tongs and Kitchen Serving Clips for Home Kitchen $10.34

$1034
current price $10.34CIMAXIC 10 Pack Toast Tongs with Heat Insulating Handle, Toaster Tongs and Kitchen Serving Clips for Home Kitchen
WEUVEB Toaster Tongs Made of Natural Beech Wood, Easy to Handle, Kitchen Tool, 1 Piece $8.94

$894
current price $8.94WEUVEB Toaster Tongs Made of Natural Beech Wood, Easy to Handle, Kitchen Tool, 1 Piece
Other options to consider(264)
FAQ
How do I know if a toaster handle will fit my model?
To check if a replacement toaster handle fits your model, look for the model number on your toaster—usually found on the bottom or back. Then, match it with the compatibility details listed on the replacement handle’s packaging or online description.
- If the handle mentions your toaster’s brand and model, it’s likely a match.
- Some handles list dimensions or part numbers for reference.
- If unsure, bring your old handle or photos to compare shape and size before purchasing.
What's the easiest way to replace a broken toaster handle?
Replacing a toaster handle can be quick with these steps:
- Unplug the toaster for safety.
- Remove the broken handle gently, often by unscrewing or unclipping it depending on your model.
- Line up the new handle, making sure it’s positioned like the original.
- Secure it using the clips or screws provided—don’t overtighten.
Are all toaster handles the same size?
No, toaster handles come in different shapes and sizes depending on the brand and model.
- Some handles are designed for specific lever mechanisms, while others are more generic replacements.
- It’s important to compare the length, width, and connection type to your existing handle.
Can I clean toaster handles in the dishwasher?
Most toaster handles are made from plastic or metal and are usually not meant for dishwasher cleaning.
- Exposure to high heat or water pressure could warp or damage the handle.
- Instead, wipe the handle with a damp cloth and mild soap, then dry thoroughly before reattaching to your toaster.
Where can I find replacement handles for my toaster?
You can find a variety of replacement toaster handles right here at Walmart—both online and in-store.
- Search for “toaster handle” using your toaster’s brand and model for better matches.
- Many listings show compatibility details or measurements, helping you pick the right part.
Popular in Toaster Handle Replacements and Parts for Home
Related Products
Replacement Knob for Rotary Switch, 1-3/32" Stem, Fits Select Utility Series Fan Models
Replacement Knob for Rotary Switch, 1-3/32" Stem, Fits Select Utility Series Fan Models$14.10current price $14.10Genuine Frigidaire 3.50 In. Oven Door Handle 316545301
Genuine Frigidaire 3.50 In. Oven Door Handle 316545301$78.64current price $78.64Garland Knob Assembly-X-Oven Sit F 4525442 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
Garland Knob Assembly-X-Oven Sit F 4525442 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part$121.05current price $121.05GENUINE Frigidaire 316442512 Knob Range/Stove/Oven
GENUINE Frigidaire 316442512 Knob Range/Stove/Oven$27.44current price $27.44Star Knob Toastr Control (Pop Up) 2R-39382 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
Star Knob Toastr Control (Pop Up) 2R-39382 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part$21.53current price $21.53HIORUOITO 4Pcs Metal Gas Stove Knobs for Embedded Gas Stoves Plated Silver Corrosion Resistant
HIORUOITO 4Pcs Metal Gas Stove Knobs for Embedded Gas Stoves Plated Silver Corrosion Resistant$6.93current price $6.93DIAL PLATE G03250-1 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
DIAL PLATE G03250-1 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part$21.37current price $21.37Anets P8902-80 Knob, W/Cover Sst-Stat
Anets P8902-80 Knob, W/Cover Sst-Stat$77.94current price $77.94DIAL 2-1/2 D, 300-650 for Blodgett 10392
DIAL 2-1/2 D, 300-650 for Blodgett 10392$29.22current price $29.22Bakers Pride 2R-Z24554- Genuine OEM Replacement Part
Bakers Pride 2R-Z24554- Genuine OEM Replacement Part$19.97current price $19.97Ultrasource Cover Knob 490326 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
Ultrasource Cover Knob 490326 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part$100.23current price $100.23WASHWEPE 1-Pack White Plastic Round Microwave Oven Temperature Control Knob, Replacement Repair Dial, 1.81 x 1.69 x 0.98 in
WASHWEPE 1-Pack White Plastic Round Microwave Oven Temperature Control Knob, Replacement Repair Dial, 1.81 x 1.69 x 0.98 in$5.95current price $5.95KNOB 8217910 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
KNOB 8217910 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part$45.09current price $45.09Bki Knob, S/S Strat T0075 K0040 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part
Bki Knob, S/S Strat T0075 K0040 - Genuine OEM Replacement Part$35.09current price $35.09






