Disney ToysAll Toys & Games0-12 Months12+ Years12-24 Months2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAction Figure AccessoriesAction FiguresAction Figures and PlaysetsAll Play VehiclesAll Stacking GamesAll Stuffed Animals & PlushAll VehiclesArts & Crafts for KidsAstronomy Toys for KidsBaby & Toddler ToysBatman ToysBiology Toys for KidsBoard GamesBuilding Sets for BoysBuilding Toys Ages 12+Cars & SUV ToysCars, RC, Drones & TrainsChristmas SquishmallowsChristmas Stuffed AnimalsClassic GamesCollectible Action FiguresCostumes For KidsDinosaur and Animal ToysDragon ToysEaster SquishmallowsEaster ToysElectronic PetsElectronic Pets, Robots & ToysElectronic ToysEngineering ToysFeatured Collectible BrandsFidget ToysFunko Pop Vinyl FiguresGames by AgeGiant Stuffed AnimalsHalloween SquishmallowHalloween Stuffed AnimalsHarry Potter PlushHarry Potter ToysHello Kitty ToysKids Craft KitsKids InstrumentsKids STEAM KitsKids' Drawing & ColoringKids' Paint and Paint SuppliesKitchens, Playfood & HousekeepingLearning ToysLEGOMontessori ToysNovelty ToysPhysics ToysPlay Compounds and Sensory ToysPlay Home & GardenPlay Vehicles & Toy CarsPreschool Toys backupPretend PlayPuzzlesRobot ToysRobotic ToysScience & EducationScience ToysSensory ToysSqueeze ToysSquishiesSquishmallows Stuffed AnimalsStitch ToysStrategy GamesStuff Animals for BoysStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsTablets for KidsThe Nightmare Before Christmas ToysToddler Activity ToysToddler Girl ToysToy Fire TrucksToy Garbage TrucksToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 2 to 4 YearsToys for Kids 5 to 7 YearsToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsValentine's Day PlushValentine's Day SquishmallowsValentine's Day Stuffed AnimalsVinyl FiguresVinyl Figures and Bobble Heads
Sort by|
Disney ToysAll Toys & Games0-12 Months12+ Years12-24 Months2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAction Figure AccessoriesAction FiguresAction Figures and PlaysetsAll Play VehiclesAll Stacking GamesAll Stuffed Animals & PlushAll VehiclesArts & Crafts for KidsAstronomy Toys for KidsBaby & Toddler ToysBatman ToysBiology Toys for KidsBoard GamesBuilding Sets for BoysBuilding Toys Ages 12+Cars & SUV ToysCars, RC, Drones & TrainsChristmas SquishmallowsChristmas Stuffed AnimalsClassic GamesCollectible Action FiguresCostumes For KidsDinosaur and Animal ToysDragon ToysEaster SquishmallowsEaster ToysElectronic PetsElectronic Pets, Robots & ToysElectronic ToysEngineering ToysFeatured Collectible BrandsFidget ToysFunko Pop Vinyl FiguresGames by AgeGiant Stuffed AnimalsHalloween SquishmallowHalloween Stuffed AnimalsHarry Potter PlushHarry Potter ToysHello Kitty ToysKids Craft KitsKids InstrumentsKids STEAM KitsKids' Drawing & ColoringKids' Paint and Paint SuppliesKitchens, Playfood & HousekeepingLearning ToysLEGOMontessori ToysNovelty ToysPhysics ToysPlay Compounds and Sensory ToysPlay Home & GardenPlay Vehicles & Toy CarsPreschool Toys backupPretend PlayPuzzlesRobot ToysRobotic ToysScience & EducationScience ToysSensory ToysSqueeze ToysSquishiesSquishmallows Stuffed AnimalsStitch ToysStrategy GamesStuff Animals for BoysStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsTablets for KidsThe Nightmare Before Christmas ToysToddler Activity ToysToddler Girl ToysToy Fire TrucksToy Garbage TrucksToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 2 to 4 YearsToys for Kids 5 to 7 YearsToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsValentine's Day PlushValentine's Day SquishmallowsValentine's Day Stuffed AnimalsVinyl FiguresVinyl Figures and Bobble Heads

Nightmare Cat

Uses item details. Price when purchased online

50 Pieces Puzzles For Adults Halloween Black Cat Horror Nightmare Lonely Wolf Forest Party Holidays Funny Wall Art Gift Jigsaw Puzzle From $12.98

50 Pieces Puzzles For Adults Halloween Black Cat Horror Nightmare Lonely Wolf Forest Party Holidays Funny Wall Art Gift Jigsaw Puzzle
50PCS (very easy), variant on 50 Pieces Puzzles For Adults Halloween Black Cat Horror Nightmare Lonely Wolf Forest Party Holidays Funny Wall Art Gift Jigsaw Puzzle
100PCS (easy), variant on 50 Pieces Puzzles For Adults Halloween Black Cat Horror Nightmare Lonely Wolf Forest Party Holidays Funny Wall Art Gift Jigsaw Puzzle
Options
From$1298

50 Pieces Puzzles For Adults Halloween Black Cat Horror Nightmare Lonely Wolf Forest Party Holidays Funny Wall Art Gift Jigsaw Puzzle

99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Doll Super Soft Cat Stuffed Toy Perfect Gifts for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts $11.18 Was $16.18

99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Doll Super Soft Cat Stuffed Toy Perfect Gifts for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts
current price Now $11.18, Was $16.18

99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Doll Super Soft Cat Stuffed Toy Perfect Gifts for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts

W0s Halloween Ghost Cat Plush Toy $28.80

W0s Halloween Ghost Cat Plush Toy
current price $28.80

W0s Halloween Ghost Cat Plush Toy

99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Fans Collection Black Cat Stuffed Animals for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts From $10.99

99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Fans Collection Black Cat Stuffed Animals for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts
1 PCS, variant on 99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Fans Collection Black Cat Stuffed Animals for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts
2 PCS, variant on 99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Fans Collection Black Cat Stuffed Animals for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts
Options
From$1099

99 Nights In The Forest Black Cat Plush Fans Collection Black Cat Stuffed Animals for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Sally with Cat - Nightmare Before Christmas - Official Jazwares Disney Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys $19.99

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Sally with Cat - Nightmare Before Christmas - Official Jazwares Disney Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
current price $19.99

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Sally with Cat - Nightmare Before Christmas - Official Jazwares Disney Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

4.6 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviews

Handmade Black Cat Plush from 99 Nights In The Forest 11.4" Game Character The Cat Stuffed Animals, Fans Collection for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts $11.99 Was $16.99

Handmade Black Cat Plush from 99 Nights In The Forest 11.4" Game Character The Cat Stuffed Animals, Fans Collection for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts
current price Now $11.99, Was $16.99

Handmade Black Cat Plush from 99 Nights In The Forest 11.4" Game Character The Cat Stuffed Animals, Fans Collection for Horror Game Lovers, Home Decors, Birthday Halloween Gifts

Annalee Dolls 2019 Halloween 8in Hocus Pocus Black Cat Plush New with Tag $31.99

Annalee Dolls 2019 Halloween 8in Hocus Pocus Black Cat Plush New with Tag
current price $31.99

Annalee Dolls 2019 Halloween 8in Hocus Pocus Black Cat Plush New with Tag

Made By Aliens Spooky Halloween Witch Cat Stuffed Animal - Adorable & Cuddly Plush Toy - Perfect Halloween Decor & Gift - Limited Edition Collectible 7 inch Orange Witch $13.99

Made By Aliens Spooky Halloween Witch Cat Stuffed Animal - Adorable & Cuddly Plush Toy - Perfect Halloween Decor & Gift - Limited Edition Collectible 7 inch Orange Witch
current price $13.99

Made By Aliens Spooky Halloween Witch Cat Stuffed Animal - Adorable & Cuddly Plush Toy - Perfect Halloween Decor & Gift - Limited Edition Collectible 7 inch Orange Witch

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Ty Beanie Boos - Witchie the Cat Glitter Eyes Halloween - Stuffed Animal $31.89

Ty Beanie Boos - Witchie the Cat Glitter Eyes Halloween - Stuffed Animal
current price $31.89

Ty Beanie Boos - Witchie the Cat Glitter Eyes Halloween - Stuffed Animal

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Lab Cat Two Headed Cat Mask $73.80

Lab Cat Two Headed Cat Mask
current price $73.80

Lab Cat Two Headed Cat Mask

Funko Nightmare Before Christmas POP! Disney Sally (Seated) with Cat Vinyl Figure (Glow-in-the-Dark, Flocked) $63.58

Funko Nightmare Before Christmas POP! Disney Sally (Seated) with Cat Vinyl Figure (Glow-in-the-Dark, Flocked)
current price $63.58

Funko Nightmare Before Christmas POP! Disney Sally (Seated) with Cat Vinyl Figure (Glow-in-the-Dark, Flocked)

The Nightmare Before Christmas Funko POP! Disney Sally (Seated) with Cat Vinyl Figure $27.99

The Nightmare Before Christmas Funko POP! Disney Sally (Seated) with Cat Vinyl Figure
current price $27.99

The Nightmare Before Christmas Funko POP! Disney Sally (Seated) with Cat Vinyl Figure

Funko POP! Train: The Nightmare Before Christmas - Sally in Cat Cart $16.99

Funko POP! Train: The Nightmare Before Christmas - Sally in Cat Cart
current price $16.99

Funko POP! Train: The Nightmare Before Christmas - Sally in Cat Cart

4.7 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Everyone

Squishmallows Official Kellytoys Plush 8 Inch Angry Jack Skellington and Sally with Cat Set Bundle Disney Nightmare Before Christmas 2024 Edition Plush Stuffed Toys $32.00

Squishmallows Official Kellytoys Plush 8 Inch Angry Jack Skellington and Sally with Cat Set Bundle Disney Nightmare Before Christmas 2024 Edition Plush Stuffed Toys
current price $32.00

Squishmallows Official Kellytoys Plush 8 Inch Angry Jack Skellington and Sally with Cat Set Bundle Disney Nightmare Before Christmas 2024 Edition Plush Stuffed Toys

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 22 reviews

Squishmallows Original Sally with Cat Nightmare Before Christmas Plush 11-Inch

Squishmallows Original Sally with Cat Nightmare Before Christmas Plush 11-Inch

Squishmallows Original Sally with Cat Nightmare Before Christmas Plush 11-Inch

Other options to consider

Just Toys Intl - Among Us Halloween Cat 7-inch Plush - Stuffed Animal & Plush Toy $14.99

Just Toys Intl - Among Us Halloween Cat 7-inch Plush - Stuffed Animal & Plush Toy
current price $14.99

Just Toys Intl - Among Us Halloween Cat 7-inch Plush - Stuffed Animal & Plush Toy

KOYPTL Black Cat Stuffed Animals Toy for 3 4 5 6 7 8 Year Old Girls Boys, Cat Stuffed Toys Doll Soft Stuffed Cat Plush Toys for Kids, Halloween Decorations, Birthday Christmas Gifts for Kids $8.99

KOYPTL Black Cat Stuffed Animals Toy for 3 4 5 6 7 8 Year Old Girls Boys, Cat Stuffed Toys Doll Soft Stuffed Cat Plush Toys for Kids, Halloween Decorations, Birthday Christmas Gifts for Kids
current price $8.99

KOYPTL Black Cat Stuffed Animals Toy for 3 4 5 6 7 8 Year Old Girls Boys, Cat Stuffed Toys Doll Soft Stuffed Cat Plush Toys for Kids, Halloween Decorations, Birthday Christmas Gifts for Kids

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

In 25+ people's carts Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Wide Eyed Cat), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU $9.97 $9.97/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Wide Eyed Cat), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU
current price $9.97
$9.97/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Wide Eyed Cat), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU

4.7 out of 5 Stars. 86 reviews

webkinz halloween black cat limited edition $49.95

webkinz halloween black cat limited edition
current price $49.95

webkinz halloween black cat limited edition

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Squishmallows 7.5" Halloween Eponine the Cat $34.90

Squishmallows 7.5" Halloween Eponine the Cat
current price $34.90

Squishmallows 7.5" Halloween Eponine the Cat

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Squishmallows 8" Eponine the Black Cat Plush Halloween $31.04

Squishmallows 8" Eponine the Black Cat Plush Halloween
current price $31.04

Squishmallows 8" Eponine the Black Cat Plush Halloween

5 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews

Long Arm Stuffed Cats, Toys, Halloween, 12 Pieces $20.48

Long Arm Stuffed Cats, Toys, Halloween, 12 Pieces
current price $20.48

Long Arm Stuffed Cats, Toys, Halloween, 12 Pieces

In 50+ people's carts Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch Wrinkle McStinkles), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU $9.97 Was $50.00 $9.97/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch Wrinkle McStinkles), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU
current price Now $9.97, Was $50.00
$9.97/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch Wrinkle McStinkles), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU

4.6 out of 5 Stars. 193 reviews

Ganz Webkinz - Halloween Black Cat 8" Plush Limited Edition HM135 (No Webkinz Code)(BONUS 1 FUN CHOPS & 1 ZIPPER BRACELET) $39.99

Ganz Webkinz - Halloween Black Cat 8" Plush Limited Edition HM135 (No Webkinz Code)(BONUS 1 FUN CHOPS & 1 ZIPPER BRACELET)
current price $39.99

Ganz Webkinz - Halloween Black Cat 8" Plush Limited Edition HM135 (No Webkinz Code)(BONUS 1 FUN CHOPS & 1 ZIPPER BRACELET)

TY Halloweenie: Merlin the Cat | Stuffed Animal | MWMT $11.22

TY Halloweenie: Merlin the Cat | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
current price $11.22

TY Halloweenie: Merlin the Cat | Stuffed Animal | MWMT

Disney - Disney Nbc Small Plush.

Disney - Disney Nbc Small Plush.
Available in additional 2 options
Options

Disney - Disney Nbc Small Plush.

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 24 reviews

Squishmallows 4" Halloween Clip-On Eponine the Cat $19.98

Squishmallows 4" Halloween Clip-On Eponine the Cat
current price $19.98

Squishmallows 4" Halloween Clip-On Eponine the Cat

Pusheen Cat Plushie, Blind Box Series #4: Halloween, Washable $19.95

Pusheen Cat Plushie, Blind Box Series #4: Halloween, Washable
current price $19.95

Pusheen Cat Plushie, Blind Box Series #4: Halloween, Washable

1 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Deal MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy From $26.99

MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy
Beige-Seal, variant on MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy
Black-Cat, variant on MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy
Gray-Seal, variant on MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy
Green Frog, variant on MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy
Options
From$2699

MaoGoLan 5Pcs Black Cat Plush with 4 Babies Kitties inside 20" Big Black Cat Stuffed Animals Plush Toy

4.4 out of 5 Stars. 349 reviews

Squishmallow 12" Cam Winking Cat with Witch Hat and Brooms Plush Halloween 2023 $70.32

Squishmallow 12" Cam Winking Cat with Witch Hat and Brooms Plush Halloween 2023
current price $70.32

Squishmallow 12" Cam Winking Cat with Witch Hat and Brooms Plush Halloween 2023

TY Beanie Boos - LUNA the Halloween Black Cat [Regular Size - 6 inch] $23.84

TY Beanie Boos - LUNA the Halloween Black Cat [Regular Size - 6 inch]
current price $23.84

TY Beanie Boos - LUNA the Halloween Black Cat [Regular Size - 6 inch]

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Squishmallow Kellytoy Plush Halloween 2023 Zazzie the Cat 12" Inch $57.90

Squishmallow Kellytoy Plush Halloween 2023 Zazzie the Cat 12" Inch
current price $57.90

Squishmallow Kellytoy Plush Halloween 2023 Zazzie the Cat 12" Inch

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

APHMAU Child Cat Exclusive Halloween Plush Set, Fabric Multicolor, 0.22 lb, 6.26" x 3.90" $47.99

APHMAU Child Cat Exclusive Halloween Plush Set, Fabric Multicolor, 0.22 lb, 6.26" x 3.90"
current price $47.99

APHMAU Child Cat Exclusive Halloween Plush Set, Fabric Multicolor, 0.22 lb, 6.26" x 3.90"

4.8 out of 5 Stars. 12 reviews

Ty Beanie Babies Moonlight the Cat Halloween Plush 2005 $17.89 Was $19.89

Ty Beanie Babies Moonlight the Cat Halloween Plush 2005
current price Now $17.89, Was $19.89

Ty Beanie Babies Moonlight the Cat Halloween Plush 2005

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Best seller Fuggler Butt Ugly Pets 9 inch (Reek-O - Black Cat), Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU $24.25 Was $30.00 $24.25/count

Fuggler Butt Ugly Pets 9 inch (Reek-O - Black Cat), Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU
current price Now $24.25, Was $30.00
$24.25/count

Fuggler Butt Ugly Pets 9 inch (Reek-O - Black Cat), Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU

4.4 out of 5 Stars. 283 reviews

Best seller Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Stinkface), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU $9.97 $9.97/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Stinkface), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU
current price $9.97
$9.97/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Stinkface), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU

4.6 out of 5 Stars. 113 reviews

Deal MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside From $27.99

MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside
Deer-4 PCS Brown, variant on MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside
Frog-4 PCS Green, variant on MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside
Axolotl-5 PCS Purple, variant on MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside
Cat-5 PCS Black, variant on MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside
Options
From$2799

MaoGoLan 6 Pcs Duck Stuffed Animals 15.7'' Duck with 5 Baby Ducks Plush Toy Inside

4.8 out of 5 Stars. 20 reviews

Sanrio Hello Kitty Halloween Black Cat Side Stepper 12" Plush Greeter Rare $39.98

Sanrio Hello Kitty Halloween Black Cat Side Stepper 12" Plush Greeter Rare
current price $39.98

Sanrio Hello Kitty Halloween Black Cat Side Stepper 12" Plush Greeter Rare

Best seller Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Yawper), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU $19.25 $19.25/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Yawper), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU
current price $19.25
$19.25/count

Fuggler Alley Cats 9 inch (Yawper), Funny Ugly Monster Stuffed Animal Toy by ZURU

4.7 out of 5 Stars. 71 reviews

KidRobot Phunny Plush - Coraline and the Cat $25.88

KidRobot Phunny Plush - Coraline and the Cat
current price $25.88

KidRobot Phunny Plush - Coraline and the Cat

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 20 reviews

Highly rated by customers

Popular in Nightmare Cat

Related Products