Crazy Aarons Putty

Uses item details. Price when purchased online

Overall pick Information, Crazy Aarons Treasure Reveal Thinking Putty for Kids and Collectors $3.98 $8.65/oz

Overall pick
Crazy Aarons Treasure Reveal Thinking Putty for Kids and Collectors
current price $3.98
$8.65/oz

Crazy Aarons Treasure Reveal Thinking Putty for Kids and Collectors

3.9 out of 5 stars
3.9 out of 5 Stars. 184 reviews

In 200+ people's carts, Scoopberry mini tin $3.97 $8.63/oz

In 200+ people's carts
Scoopberry mini tin
current price $3.97
$8.63/oz

Scoopberry mini tin

4.4 out of 5 stars
4.4 out of 5 Stars. 234 reviews

Scentsory Peach Ring $7.98 $72.55/ea

Scentsory Peach Ring
current price $7.98
$72.55/ea

Scentsory Peach Ring

4.4 out of 5 stars
4.4 out of 5 Stars. 45 reviews

In 100+ people's carts, Crazy Aaron's DIY Mac N Cheese Thinking Putty for Kids $9.98 $4.75/oz

In 100+ people's carts
Crazy Aaron's DIY Mac N Cheese Thinking Putty for Kids
current price $9.98
$4.75/oz

Crazy Aaron's DIY Mac N Cheese Thinking Putty for Kids

4.7 out of 5 stars
4.7 out of 5 Stars. 90 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty $26.52

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty
current price $26.52

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty

4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6 out of 5 Stars. 19 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Buttery Smooth 1.4 oz $21.89

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Buttery Smooth 1.4 oz
current price $21.89

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Buttery Smooth 1.4 oz

4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6 out of 5 Stars. 28 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty, 2.1 oz $9.99

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty, 2.1 oz
current price $9.99

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty, 2.1 oz

Crazy Aaron's Eggcellent Thinking Putty (3.2 ounce) $34.95

Crazy Aaron's Eggcellent Thinking Putty (3.2 ounce)
current price $34.95

Crazy Aaron's Eggcellent Thinking Putty (3.2 ounce)

Crazy Aaron's Gingerbread Thinking Putty For Series (2.6 oz),1,Style 1 From $11.99

Crazy Aaron's Gingerbread Thinking Putty For Series (2.6 oz),1,Style 1
Available in additional 2 options
From$1199

Crazy Aaron's Gingerbread Thinking Putty For Series (2.6 oz),1,Style 1

Crazy Aaron's Delightful Dumpling Color Change Thinking Putty 3.2 oz $34.95

Crazy Aaron's Delightful Dumpling Color Change Thinking Putty 3.2 oz
current price $34.95

Crazy Aaron's Delightful Dumpling Color Change Thinking Putty 3.2 oz

Crazy Aaron's ScentSory Putty Strawberry Scented 2.1 OZ (60g) $39.99

Crazy Aaron's ScentSory Putty Strawberry Scented 2.1 OZ (60g)
current price $39.99

Crazy Aaron's ScentSory Putty Strawberry Scented 2.1 OZ (60g)

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mini Christmas Fidget 3 Pack $39.95

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mini Christmas Fidget 3 Pack
current price $39.95

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mini Christmas Fidget 3 Pack

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Berry Thinking Putty (2.1 oz) $39.95

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Berry Thinking Putty (2.1 oz)
current price $39.95

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Berry Thinking Putty (2.1 oz)

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty $17.98 Was $21.60

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty
current price Now $17.98, Was $21.60

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty

4.7 out of 5 stars
4.7 out of 5 Stars. 54 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Enchanting Unicorn Thinking Putty, Glows Pink In The Dark, 2.1 oz $22.99

Crazy Aaron's Enchanting Unicorn Thinking Putty, Glows Pink In The Dark, 2.1 oz
current price $22.99

Crazy Aaron's Enchanting Unicorn Thinking Putty, Glows Pink In The Dark, 2.1 oz

5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty Was $30.99

Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty
Style1, variant on Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty
Style2, variant on Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty
Style3, variant on Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty
Style4, variant on Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty

Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty

Crazy Aarons Cookie Cutter Thinking Putty (3.2 oz),1,Cookie Cutter Was $13.99

Crazy Aarons Cookie Cutter Thinking Putty (3.2 oz),1,Cookie Cutter
Available in additional 2 options

Crazy Aarons Cookie Cutter Thinking Putty (3.2 oz),1,Cookie Cutter

Rollback, Crazy Aaron's Gingerbread Thinking Putty,GINGERBREAD $11.69 Was $12.99

Rollback
Crazy Aaron's Gingerbread Thinking Putty,GINGERBREAD
current price Now $11.69, Was $12.99

Crazy Aaron's Gingerbread Thinking Putty,GINGERBREAD

Best seller, Crazy Aaron's Winter Wonderland Thinking Putty Advent Calendar 2026, 24-Day Christmas Countdown with Holiday Putty, Charms, Sensory Fidget Toy Gift for Kids From $24.98

Best seller
Crazy Aaron's Winter Wonderland Thinking Putty Advent Calendar 2026, 24-Day Christmas Countdown with Holiday Putty, Charms, Sensory Fidget Toy Gift for Kids
Available in additional 2 options
From$2498

Crazy Aaron's Winter Wonderland Thinking Putty Advent Calendar 2026, 24-Day Christmas Countdown with Holiday Putty, Charms, Sensory Fidget Toy Gift for Kids

Crazy Aaron's Super Scarab Thinking Putty Slime $22.99 $10.95/oz

Crazy Aaron's Super Scarab Thinking Putty Slime
current price $22.99
$10.95/oz

Crazy Aaron's Super Scarab Thinking Putty Slime

4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6 out of 5 Stars. 163 reviews

Crazy Aaron's GingerbreadThinking Putty (2.6 oz) $39.92

Crazy Aaron's GingerbreadThinking Putty (2.6 oz)
current price $39.92

Crazy Aaron's GingerbreadThinking Putty (2.6 oz)

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Christmas Bundle, Gingerbread, 3oz $9.99

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Christmas Bundle, Gingerbread, 3oz
current price $9.99

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Christmas Bundle, Gingerbread, 3oz

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Happy Hedgehog Multi-Color Sensory Putty $34.95

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Happy Hedgehog Multi-Color Sensory Putty
current price $34.95

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Happy Hedgehog Multi-Color Sensory Putty

Crazy Aaron's Series Thinking Putty Stress Toys,Yellow-Better Butter From $13.99

Crazy Aaron's Series Thinking Putty Stress Toys,Yellow-Better Butter
Available in additional 14 options
From$1399

Crazy Aaron's Series Thinking Putty Stress Toys,Yellow-Better Butter

EGGCELENT 4" THINKING PUTTY $34.85

EGGCELENT 4" THINKING PUTTY
current price $34.85

EGGCELENT 4" THINKING PUTTY

3.4 out of 5 stars
3.4 out of 5 Stars. 20 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Gingerbread Man 2.6 oz $31.50

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Gingerbread Man 2.6 oz
current price $31.50

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Gingerbread Man 2.6 oz

Set of 3 Crazy Aaron Better Butter Butter Putty-Better Butter (Yellow), Very Berry( Purple), and Butter Cream (Blue) $94.99

Set of 3 Crazy Aaron Better Butter Butter Putty-Better Butter (Yellow), Very Berry( Purple), and Butter Cream (Blue)
current price $94.99

Set of 3 Crazy Aaron Better Butter Butter Putty-Better Butter (Yellow), Very Berry( Purple), and Butter Cream (Blue)

5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews

Crazy Aaron Mini Thinking Putty Holiday Set, Color Change, Glow, 3-Pack, 0.46 oz Each $29.99

Crazy Aaron Mini Thinking Putty Holiday Set, Color Change, Glow, 3-Pack, 0.46 oz Each
current price $29.99

Crazy Aaron Mini Thinking Putty Holiday Set, Color Change, Glow, 3-Pack, 0.46 oz Each

Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Zombie Party and Skeleton .46 oz (13.3 g) 2-Pack $22.99

Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Zombie Party and Skeleton .46 oz (13.3 g) 2-Pack
current price $22.99

Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Zombie Party and Skeleton .46 oz (13.3 g) 2-Pack

Best seller, Crazy Aaron's 2026 Santa's Reindeer Advent Calendar, 24-Day Surpries of Gifts Christmas Countdown Box $19.99 Was $25.99

Best seller
Crazy Aaron's 2026 Santa's Reindeer Advent Calendar, 24-Day Surpries of Gifts Christmas Countdown Box
current price Now $19.99, Was $25.99

Crazy Aaron's 2026 Santa's Reindeer Advent Calendar, 24-Day Surpries of Gifts Christmas Countdown Box

Crazy Aaron's 2026 Santa's ReindeerAdvent Calendar 2026, Reindeer Christmas Putty Advent Calendar, 24 Days Countdown $15.99 Was $23.40

Crazy Aaron's 2026 Santa's ReindeerAdvent Calendar 2026, Reindeer Christmas Putty Advent Calendar, 24 Days Countdown
current price Now $15.99, Was $23.40

Crazy Aaron's 2026 Santa's ReindeerAdvent Calendar 2026, Reindeer Christmas Putty Advent Calendar, 24 Days Countdown

Crazy Aaron's Enchanting Ube Mochi Thinking Putty, Limited Edition Mega Tin, 13.3oz 1 lb tin $129.95

Crazy Aaron's Enchanting Ube Mochi Thinking Putty, Limited Edition Mega Tin, 13.3oz 1 lb tin
current price $129.95

Crazy Aaron's Enchanting Ube Mochi Thinking Putty, Limited Edition Mega Tin, 13.3oz 1 lb tin

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Buttery Smooth 2.1 oz,1PCS From $11.89

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Buttery Smooth 2.1 oz,1PCS
Available in additional 2 options
From$1189

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Buttery Smooth 2.1 oz,1PCS

Crazy Aaron's Slime Charmers Strawberry Shortcake $25.98 $6.50/oz

Crazy Aaron's Slime Charmers Strawberry Shortcake
current price $25.98
$6.50/oz

Crazy Aaron's Slime Charmers Strawberry Shortcake

2.3 out of 5 stars
2.3 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews

Crazy Aarons Rainbow Reveal Thinking Putty, Large Tin $39.95

Crazy Aarons Rainbow Reveal Thinking Putty, Large Tin
current price $39.95

Crazy Aarons Rainbow Reveal Thinking Putty, Large Tin

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty, Ugly Sweater, Cookie Cutter, Gingerbread Man, 3-Pack, 3.2 oz $149.99

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty, Ugly Sweater, Cookie Cutter, Gingerbread Man, 3-Pack, 3.2 oz
current price $149.99

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty, Ugly Sweater, Cookie Cutter, Gingerbread Man, 3-Pack, 3.2 oz

Crazy Aaron's Hide Inside! Sweet Surprise Thinking Putty $25.94

Crazy Aaron's Hide Inside! Sweet Surprise Thinking Putty
current price $25.94

Crazy Aaron's Hide Inside! Sweet Surprise Thinking Putty

4.7 out of 5 stars
4.7 out of 5 Stars. 31 reviews

Thinking Putty Scented Scentsory Flower Power Putty $21.94

Thinking Putty Scented Scentsory Flower Power Putty
current price $21.94

Thinking Putty Scented Scentsory Flower Power Putty

5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews

Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Elf, Jack Frost, Secret Santa, 3 Pack, .46 oz Each $39.99

Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Elf, Jack Frost, Secret Santa, 3 Pack, .46 oz Each
current price $39.99

Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Elf, Jack Frost, Secret Santa, 3 Pack, .46 oz Each

STARFISH 2' TIN

STARFISH 2' TIN
Amber, variant on STARFISH 2' TIN
Easter Bloom, variant on STARFISH 2' TIN
Fairy Sprinkles, variant on STARFISH 2' TIN
Gray, variant on STARFISH 2' TIN

STARFISH 2' TIN

4.3 out of 5 stars
4.3 out of 5 Stars. 218 reviews

Explore related products

View all

FAQ

How long does Crazy Aaron's putty last?

With regular play and good care, thinking putty can be enjoyed for a long time. Longevity depends on how it’s used and stored.

  • Store it sealed: Place it back in its tin with the lid on when you’re done.
  • Keep it clean: Use clean, dry hands and a smooth surface to minimize dust and lint.
  • Avoid heat: Keep out of hot cars and direct sunlight, which can make putty feel extra soft.
  • Expect normal changes: Scents may fade over time, and glow effects need bright light to recharge.
  • Tweak the feel: Warm hands can soften firmer putty; cooling it briefly can reduce extra softness.

Results vary based on environment and frequency of use.

Which thinking putty should I get?

Pick based on texture, effects, theme, and size—there’s no single “best,” just what suits you.

  • Texture: Ultra-soft, butter-like putty spreads smoothly; classic styles stretch and snap.
  • Special effects: Options include glow-in-the-dark, color-changing, or illusion/iridescent finishes.
  • Theme/play pattern: Seek-and-find tins, treasure reveals, and character or nature themes add built-in activities.
  • Scent: Fruit and seasonal scents offer a fun sensory layer.
  • Size: Mini tins are great on the go; full-size (often 4-inch) tins offer more putty for shaping and tricks; bundles are handy for gifts.

Check age guidance (many items note 3+), and choose the combo that matches the interests of the person playing.

Can I customize or mix my own putty?

Yes—this page includes mix-your-own kits and sets with add-ins so you can personalize your putty.

  • What’s typically included: A base putty plus color concentrates, glitter, confetti, or themed charms (varies by kit).
  • How to mix: Start with a small amount of add-ins and knead slowly, adding more until you like the look and feel.
  • Scent add-ins: If provided, use sparingly and mix thoroughly.
  • Storage: Place your custom creation back in its tin to keep it fresh; labeling your tin can help.
  • Supervision: Adult guidance is recommended for younger kids.

Kit contents and directions differ, so review the product description and follow the included instructions.

What sizes do these tins come in?

You’ll find a few convenient sizes across this selection.

  • Mini tins: Pocket-friendly and great for travel, party favors, or quick sensory breaks.
  • Full-size tins: Commonly listed as 4-inch tins, offering more putty for bigger stretches, tricks, and group play.
  • Bundles and kits: Some listings include multiple mini tins or a mix of components for varied play.
  • Check details: Exact sizes or ounces are shown in each product title or description.

Availability can vary online and by store. At checkout, you can choose pickup or delivery when options are offered in your area.

How do I find limited or seasonal tins?

Availability for themed or seasonal tins can change throughout the year.

  • Browse regularly: Check this category page often and filter for items that are currently in stock.
  • Scan titles: Look for keywords like glow-in-the-dark, color-changing, treasure reveal, or seasonal vibes in product names.
  • Consider bundles: Multi-packs or gift sets sometimes include unique combinations.
  • Check local options: Enter your ZIP code to see whether pickup from nearby stores is available; selection varies by location.
  • Stay flexible: If one theme is sold out, similar effects or styles may be listed on the same page.

Stock moves quickly during peak seasons, so checking back can help.

Related Products