More like 3 and 1/2 stars IMO. It's sensible, fun bike to ride. I like the design of it. Brakes are the weakest component - braking power is really weak. Probably needs replacement. Shifters are one-by, so potentially less maintenance, but gear ratio is limited. Components seem budget level. I haven't had it long enough to say how long bike will last.

I changed up from a 26” Mongoose 21 speed bike I bought at least 25 years ago. I'd always had problems with my hands and neck falling asleep due to the riding position I was forced to assume because of my height. Those issues were mostly resolved by upgrading to this 27.5” bike. I've found I've had to adjust to the new gearing with this only being a seven speed. I also bought aftermarket grips for greater hand comfort as well as an extension for the stemless head to bring the handlebars up higher. I think the bike is good and worth the initial investment, especially at its price point.