Lp Generic Loreal True Match Naturale Eyeliner

This pencil is pretty good if you want to be natural and use mineral products but don't have time to put on the powder mineral eyeliner which can be messy (black powder flakes on my cheeks!) I bought the cocoa and the color is nice shade of chocolate brown. The only problem I have with the pencil is that it doesn't glide on very easily and you need to warm it up otherwise it tugs on the eyelid as the pencil itself isn't that soft. Didn't smear and seemed to stay put. Overall fairly good.