Starfish Cake(1)
Hawaiian Beach Ocean Cake Topper - 21PCS Tropical Decorations for Summer Party Supplies $13.99

Hawaiian Beach Ocean Cake Topper - 21PCS Tropical Decorations for Summer Party Supplies
Other options to consider(121)
Gone Fishing Cake Decoration Fish Cake Topper Catching the Big One Cake Supplies Fisherman Themed Birthday Cake Topper Sea Bass Figurines for Man Kids Boy Fisherman Gone Fishing $11.99

Gone Fishing Cake Decoration Fish Cake Topper Catching the Big One Cake Supplies Fisherman Themed Birthday Cake Topper Sea Bass Figurines for Man Kids Boy Fisherman Gone Fishing
Fishing Cake Topper Fishing Cake Decoraions, Fishing Brithday Party Decorations Gone Fishing Cake with Bass Reed , Fish Birthday Party Decorations $11.99

Fishing Cake Topper Fishing Cake Decoraions, Fishing Brithday Party Decorations Gone Fishing Cake with Bass Reed , Fish Birthday Party Decorations
Baby Shark Round Cake $14.98

Baby Shark Round Cake
Oasis Supply Seashells and Starfish Sugar Decorations, 12 Count $9.95

Oasis Supply Seashells and Starfish Sugar Decorations, 12 Count
Under the Sea Cake Toppers Set - Colorful 3D Ocean Creatures & Plants for Themed Party Decor $14.99

Under the Sea Cake Toppers Set - Colorful 3D Ocean Creatures & Plants for Themed Party Decor
HHNOU Mermaid Cake Topper for Mermaid under the Sea Cake Decor|Big Mermaid Tails Seaweed Bubbles Shells and Golden Ginkgo Leaves Cake Set Mermaid Cake Decorations $12.61

HHNOU Mermaid Cake Topper for Mermaid under the Sea Cake Decor|Big Mermaid Tails Seaweed Bubbles Shells and Golden Ginkgo Leaves Cake Set Mermaid Cake Decorations
20 Pcs Fishing Cake Toppers, Mini Fish Pole Decoration, 6.3 in / 16 cm Cake Insert, Fishing Themed Party Favors, Little One Interactive Toys, Birthday, Party Decorations $12.99

20 Pcs Fishing Cake Toppers, Mini Fish Pole Decoration, 6.3 in / 16 cm Cake Insert, Fishing Themed Party Favors, Little One Interactive Toys, Birthday, Party Decorations
Mermaid Cake Toppers Under the Sea Mermaid Tail Cake Decorations for Birthday Baby Shower Party Supplies $12.99

Mermaid Cake Toppers Under the Sea Mermaid Tail Cake Decorations for Birthday Baby Shower Party Supplies
Birthday Decorations, 24Pcs 2 Side Fish Cupcake Toppers Fishing for Fish Theme Party Baby Shower Tropical Party Cake Picks Under The Sea Decoration Supplies (20 pcs) $9.99

Birthday Decorations, 24Pcs 2 Side Fish Cupcake Toppers Fishing for Fish Theme Party Baby Shower Tropical Party Cake Picks Under The Sea Decoration Supplies (20 pcs)
Hawaiian Beach Ocean Cake Topper - 21PCS Tropical Decorations for Summer Party Supplies $13.99

Hawaiian Beach Ocean Cake Topper - 21PCS Tropical Decorations for Summer Party Supplies
Purple Mermaid Cake Toppers - Under the Sea Cake Decoration Set with Seashells, Mermaid Tail, Sea Star Toppers $14.99

Purple Mermaid Cake Toppers - Under the Sea Cake Decoration Set with Seashells, Mermaid Tail, Sea Star Toppers
What's Funnier Than 24? 25! Funny 25th Birthday Cake Topper, Yellow Sponge Style Cake Decor, Glitter Cardstock Acrylic Stick Party Supplies for Adults $13.99

What's Funnier Than 24? 25! Funny 25th Birthday Cake Topper, Yellow Sponge Style Cake Decor, Glitter Cardstock Acrylic Stick Party Supplies for Adults
Ocean Creature Coral Cake Topper Underwater Styling For Adult Summer Birthday Party Dessert Display $14.99

Ocean Creature Coral Cake Topper Underwater Styling For Adult Summer Birthday Party Dessert Display
Summer Beach Theme Cake Decorations - 19-Piece Scene-Setting Kit for Party Decor & Cake Toppers $13.99

Summer Beach Theme Cake Decorations - 19-Piece Scene-Setting Kit for Party Decor & Cake Toppers
Beach Chair Umbrella Cake Decoration, 24 Pieces Palm Tree Summer Ocean Cake Toppers, Tropical Hawaiian Theme Decorations for Birthday Baby Shower Cake Topper Wedding Pool Party Decorations Supplies $10.00 Was $14.83

Beach Chair Umbrella Cake Decoration, 24 Pieces Palm Tree Summer Ocean Cake Toppers, Tropical Hawaiian Theme Decorations for Birthday Baby Shower Cake Topper Wedding Pool Party Decorations Supplies
Mermaid Cake Topper Under The Sea Cake Decors Seashell Cake topper Mermaid Tail Cake Decoration Mermaid Birthday Cake Toppers Baby Shower $16.99

Mermaid Cake Topper Under The Sea Cake Decors Seashell Cake topper Mermaid Tail Cake Decoration Mermaid Birthday Cake Toppers Baby Shower
Whimsical Practicality's Bass Fish Jumping Edible Icing Image Cake Topper-1/4 Sheet or Larger $14.54

Whimsical Practicality's Bass Fish Jumping Edible Icing Image Cake Topper-1/4 Sheet or Larger
Under the Sea Cake Topper 13-Piece Set - Beach Wedding Summer Pool Party Decorations $16.99

Under the Sea Cake Topper 13-Piece Set - Beach Wedding Summer Pool Party Decorations
Ocean Sprinkles for Cupcakes, 3.35oz Edible Sea Shell Seahorse Starfish Fish & Pearl Sugar Decorations, Cake Decorating Sprinkle Mix for Cookies Ice Cream Desserts, Birthday Party Baking Supplies $8.99

Ocean Sprinkles for Cupcakes, 3.35oz Edible Sea Shell Seahorse Starfish Fish & Pearl Sugar Decorations, Cake Decorating Sprinkle Mix for Cookies Ice Cream Desserts, Birthday Party Baking Supplies
FacoFaco Pack of 48 Mermaid Cake Toppers for Mermaid Theme Party $8.99

FacoFaco Pack of 48 Mermaid Cake Toppers for Mermaid Theme Party
ELAYARD Set of 3 Decorative Resin Cake Toppers with Ocean Theme and Sea Star Design for Dessert Table Decor $10.56

ELAYARD Set of 3 Decorative Resin Cake Toppers with Ocean Theme and Sea Star Design for Dessert Table Decor
Hawaii Beach Ocean Cake Decorations 13-Piece Set - Tropical Party Cake Topper with Shell, Starfish & Flowers $15.99

Hawaii Beach Ocean Cake Decorations 13-Piece Set - Tropical Party Cake Topper with Shell, Starfish & Flowers
20Pcs Fishing Theme Fish Cupcake Toppers Fishing for Fish Party Baby Shower Cake Picks Under The Sea Decoration Supplies two-sided $5.99

20Pcs Fishing Theme Fish Cupcake Toppers Fishing for Fish Party Baby Shower Cake Picks Under The Sea Decoration Supplies two-sided
COOPHYA 3Pcs Resin Cake Topper Sea Star Decoration for Birthday Cake Ocean Style Accent $10.42 Was $14.89

COOPHYA 3Pcs Resin Cake Topper Sea Star Decoration for Birthday Cake Ocean Style Accent
Bass Fish Jumping Edible Image Icing Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by Tnct. $14.99

Bass Fish Jumping Edible Image Icing Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by Tnct.
The Big One Fish Cake Topper, Fish Cake Topper For Fish Cake Decorations $5.99

The Big One Fish Cake Topper, Fish Cake Topper For Fish Cake Decorations
SASABAXI 3Pcs Ocean Theme Resin Cake Toppers Sea Star Decor for Birthday Cake Display $10.42

SASABAXI 3Pcs Ocean Theme Resin Cake Toppers Sea Star Decor for Birthday Cake Display
Anglesit Pre-Cut Ocean Animals Edible Rice Wafer Paper Under the Sea Cupcake Toppers Cake Decorations Birthday Baby Shower Party $30.17

Anglesit Pre-Cut Ocean Animals Edible Rice Wafer Paper Under the Sea Cupcake Toppers Cake Decorations Birthday Baby Shower Party
Under the Sea Cake Topper 13-Piece Set - Beach Wedding Summer Pool Party Decorations $14.99

Under the Sea Cake Topper 13-Piece Set - Beach Wedding Summer Pool Party Decorations
Luxshiny 3-Piece Ocean Theme Resin Cake Toppers with Sea Star Design, Reusable Party Decorations $9.45

Luxshiny 3-Piece Ocean Theme Resin Cake Toppers with Sea Star Design, Reusable Party Decorations
Scuttle Seagull & Flounder Fish PVC Cake Topper Figure Figurine Little Mermaid New $14.25

Scuttle Seagull & Flounder Fish PVC Cake Topper Figure Figurine Little Mermaid New
FOMIYES 3-Piece Resin Sea Star Birthday Cake Toppers, Ocean Theme Ornaments, Reusable Party Decorations for Beach Party $10.40 Was $14.45

FOMIYES 3-Piece Resin Sea Star Birthday Cake Toppers, Ocean Theme Ornaments, Reusable Party Decorations for Beach Party
12 PCS First Holy Communion Cupcake Topper Baptism Cake Decorations, Communion Baby Shower Wooden Fish Decorations, Christening Cake Topper for Birthday Boys and Girls (Fish Golden) $33.10

12 PCS First Holy Communion Cupcake Topper Baptism Cake Decorations, Communion Baby Shower Wooden Fish Decorations, Christening Cake Topper for Birthday Boys and Girls (Fish Golden)
Wilton Dab-N-Hold Edible Adhesive for Cake Decorating Clear 2 fl. oz.

Wilton Dab-N-Hold Edible Adhesive for Cake Decorating Clear 2 fl. oz.
Scuba Diving Scuba Divers Star Fish Ocean Edible Cake Topper Image $14.47

Scuba Diving Scuba Divers Star Fish Ocean Edible Cake Topper Image
Fishing Theme Cupcake Toppers Set, 60 Mini Rods and 60 Colorful Fish Decorations for Cake and Cupcake Decor $63.96

Fishing Theme Cupcake Toppers Set, 60 Mini Rods and 60 Colorful Fish Decorations for Cake and Cupcake Decor
Big Dot of Happiness Mermaid Dessert Cupcake Cake Toppers, Mermaids, Starfish, and Seashell Cutout Birthday Decor with Clear Treat Picks - Set of 24 $13.99

Big Dot of Happiness Mermaid Dessert Cupcake Cake Toppers, Mermaids, Starfish, and Seashell Cutout Birthday Decor with Clear Treat Picks - Set of 24
2pcs Mermaid Tail Cake Topper Shining Shell Sea Star Cake Dessert Decor for Girl Birthday Party Gathering Festival $5.58

2pcs Mermaid Tail Cake Topper Shining Shell Sea Star Cake Dessert Decor for Girl Birthday Party Gathering Festival
Mermaid Tail 100g Edible Sprinkles Mermaid Cupcake Toppers Edible, Edible Cake Decorations, Sugar Balls for Cupcake Cakes Sprinkle On Birthday Wedding Party (Ocean Themed) $31.99

Mermaid Tail 100g Edible Sprinkles Mermaid Cupcake Toppers Edible, Edible Cake Decorations, Sugar Balls for Cupcake Cakes Sprinkle On Birthday Wedding Party (Ocean Themed)
Ocean Style Cake Decor Set Mermaid Tail Shell Starfish Cake Toppers Seaweed Bubble Dessert Picks For Themed Gathering $14.99

Ocean Style Cake Decor Set Mermaid Tail Shell Starfish Cake Toppers Seaweed Bubble Dessert Picks For Themed Gathering
FAQ
How do I decorate a starfish cake?
Decorating a starfish cake is a fun way to channel a beach or ocean theme. You can use silicone molds to create starfish and seashell shapes out of fondant, chocolate, or candy. Arrange these decorations on the cake's surface, and add edible pearls, seaweed, or coral accents with colored icing or pre-made cake toppers. Try placing themed fondant pieces or cake toppers from sets available at Walmart to build an eye-catching scene. Always handle decorations carefully to avoid breaking delicate pieces, and refrigerate cakes with perishable toppings as needed.
Can I use fishing cake toppers for a starfish cake?
Absolutely, fishing cake toppers can add extra flair to a starfish cake, especially for ocean or beach-themed celebrations. You might combine fish-shaped toppers, reeds, and starfish molds to bring together the underwater vibe. Mixing different toppers allows you to create a unique look, and it's easy to find compatible decorations in party sets or individual toppers at Walmart. Just make sure the toppers are food-safe and remove any non-edible items before serving.
What’s the best way to make starfish shapes for cakes?
One of the easiest ways to create starfish shapes for cakes is using flexible silicone molds designed for baking and candy-making. Simply press fondant, chocolate, or edible dough into the mold, then gently release the shapes after they're set. You can also use starfish-shaped cutters for thicker icing or marzipan. For extra detail, dust with edible shimmer or add colored accents to highlight the starfish features. Always follow safety instructions when using molds and ensure materials are food-grade.
Do I need to refrigerate cakes with starfish decorations?
It depends on the type of decorations and cake you’re using. Cakes with perishable fillings or decorations made from ingredients like whipped cream, dairy, or chocolate should be refrigerated to maintain freshness and prevent melting. Fondant or hard candy decorations generally don’t require refrigeration unless the overall cake contains perishable items. If unsure, check storage instructions for each ingredient and decoration for best results. Storing cakes in a cool, dry place is usually ideal for presentation.
What’s included in ocean-themed cake decoration sets?
Ocean-themed cake decoration sets often include a mix of items like starfish fondant molds, fish and seashell toppers, decorative seaweed, and coral pieces. Some sets come with scene-building props to create full beach or underwater displays. You’ll also find edible and non-edible pieces, so check the product details before buying. These sets are great for parties or special occasions, as they allow you to customize your cake with creative accents easily sourced from Walmart’s selection.
Popular in Shop Starfish Cake Decorations and Toppers Online
Related Products
29 PCS Under the Sea Cake Toppers Ocean Animal Cupcake Toppers Under the Sea Party Decorations Ocean Sea Theme Baby Shower Birthday Party Cake
29 PCS Under the Sea Cake Toppers Ocean Animal Cupcake Toppers Under the Sea Party Decorations Ocean Sea Theme Baby Shower Birthday Party Cake$13.99current price $13.99Fishing Wedding Cake Topper Funny Cute Wedding Party Decorations Best Catch Ever Cake Topper for Anniversary Bridal Shower Party Supplies
Fishing Wedding Cake Topper Funny Cute Wedding Party Decorations Best Catch Ever Cake Topper for Anniversary Bridal Shower Party Supplies$9.99current price $9.99Flamingo Tropical Edible Image Icing Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by Tnct.
Flamingo Tropical Edible Image Icing Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by Tnct.$14.99current price $14.99A 1/4 Sheet Tropical Edible Cake Topper, Flamingo Theme
A 1/4 Sheet Tropical Edible Cake Topper, Flamingo Theme$17.00current price $17.00Acrylic Leaping Dolphin Ocean Light Cake Topper Party Decoration for Wedding Anniversary Birthday Graduation
Acrylic Leaping Dolphin Ocean Light Cake Topper Party Decoration for Wedding Anniversary Birthday Graduation$9.99current price $9.99Tropical Flamingo Birthday Edible Icing Image Cake Topper, by Tnct.
Tropical Flamingo Birthday Edible Icing Image Cake Topper, by Tnct.$14.99current price $14.99Dolphin Under the Sea Edible Image Icing Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by Tnct.
Dolphin Under the Sea Edible Image Icing Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by Tnct.$14.99current price $14.996" Pre-Cut Round Blue and White Stripes with Nautical Anchor and Rope Edible Image Cake Topper, by TNCT. (1 Count)
6" Pre-Cut Round Blue and White Stripes with Nautical Anchor and Rope Edible Image Cake Topper, by TNCT. (1 Count)$14.99current price $14.99Swimming ~ Edible Icing Image Cake Topper
Swimming ~ Edible Icing Image Cake Topper$14.99current price $14.99Hawaiian Sea Turtle Family Edible Icing Image Cake Topper, by Tnct.
Hawaiian Sea Turtle Family Edible Icing Image Cake Topper, by Tnct.$14.99current price $14.99Dolphin Under the Sea Edible Cake Topper Image Cupcakes Ocean BaBy Shower Edible
Dolphin Under the Sea Edible Cake Topper Image Cupcakes Ocean BaBy Shower Edible$14.99current price $14.998" x 10.5" Dolphins Swimming Edible Image Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by TNCT. (1 Count)
8" x 10.5" Dolphins Swimming Edible Image Cake Topper for Quarter Sheet Cake, by TNCT. (1 Count)$14.99current price $14.99Blue & White Strip Nautical Theme Rope & Anchor Edible Icing Image Cake Topper, by Tnct.
Blue & White Strip Nautical Theme Rope & Anchor Edible Icing Image Cake Topper, by Tnct.$16.99current price $16.99Pod of Dolphins Painting Image ~ Edible Cake Topper Sheet
Pod of Dolphins Painting Image ~ Edible Cake Topper Sheet$17.00current price $17.00Ocean Life Dolphin Turtle Coral Variety of Fish Edible Cake Topper, by TNCT
Ocean Life Dolphin Turtle Coral Variety of Fish Edible Cake Topper, by TNCT$14.99current price $14.99
