Rare Magic Cards

Uses item details. Price when purchased online

TCG Force Graded Card Mystery Pack – 1 PSA or CGC Slab + 1 Booster Pack $34.99

TCG Force Graded Card Mystery Pack – 1 PSA or CGC Slab + 1 Booster Pack
Sponsored
current price $34.99

TCG Force Graded Card Mystery Pack – 1 PSA or CGC Slab + 1 Booster Pack

Deal, 2026 Hit Kings Pokemon Edition – 1 Graded Card or Ungraded Card $99.99 Was $124.99

Deal
2026 Hit Kings Pokemon Edition – 1 Graded Card or Ungraded Card
Sponsored
current price Now $99.99, Was $124.99

2026 Hit Kings Pokemon Edition – 1 Graded Card or Ungraded Card

4.3 out of 5 stars
4.3 out of 5 Stars. 27 reviews

Deal, Top Class Cards Mega Box | 100 Cards | 3 Guaranteed Ultra Rares | 7 Holo Cards | Compatible with Pokemon Cards $21.59

Deal
Top Class Cards Mega Box | 100 Cards | 3 Guaranteed Ultra Rares | 7 Holo Cards | Compatible with Pokemon Cards
Sponsored
current price $21.59

Top Class Cards Mega Box | 100 Cards | 3 Guaranteed Ultra Rares | 7 Holo Cards | Compatible with Pokemon Cards

3.6 out of 5 stars
3.6 out of 5 Stars. 393 reviews

Deal, 2026 Slab Kings Plus Pokemon Edition – 1 Graded Card + 1 Sealed Pack + 1 Bonus Card $35.99 Was $39.99

Deal
2026 Slab Kings Plus Pokemon Edition – 1 Graded Card + 1 Sealed Pack + 1 Bonus Card
Sponsored
current price Now $35.99, Was $39.99

2026 Slab Kings Plus Pokemon Edition – 1 Graded Card + 1 Sealed Pack + 1 Bonus Card

2.9 out of 5 stars
2.9 out of 5 Stars. 35 reviews

Magic the Gathering 100 Cards Includes 25+ Rares/Uncommons MTG Cards Collection Foils & mythics possible! $8.43

Magic the Gathering 100 Cards Includes 25+ Rares/Uncommons MTG Cards Collection Foils & mythics possible!
current price $8.43

Magic the Gathering 100 Cards Includes 25+ Rares/Uncommons MTG Cards Collection Foils & mythics possible!

3.1 out of 5 stars
3.1 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews

MTG 25 Random Rare Cards Foils/Mythics/Planeswalkers $8.96

MTG 25 Random Rare Cards Foils/Mythics/Planeswalkers
current price $8.96

MTG 25 Random Rare Cards Foils/Mythics/Planeswalkers

Magic: The Gathering Commander 2019 Idol of Oblivion #55 Rare Trading Card $11.46

Magic: The Gathering Commander 2019 Idol of Oblivion #55 Rare Trading Card
current price $11.46

Magic: The Gathering Commander 2019 Idol of Oblivion #55 Rare Trading Card

Deal, Magic The Gathering Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster Box with 504 Magic Rare and Foil Cards (36-Packs) $287.10

Deal
Magic The Gathering Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster Box with 504 Magic Rare and Foil Cards (36-Packs)
current price $287.10

Magic The Gathering Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster Box with 504 Magic Rare and Foil Cards (36-Packs)

3.9 out of 5 stars
3.9 out of 5 Stars. 11 reviews

Star City Games 100 Assorted Magic: The Gathering Rares $29.99

Star City Games 100 Assorted Magic: The Gathering Rares
current price $29.99

Star City Games 100 Assorted Magic: The Gathering Rares

4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6 out of 5 Stars. 5 reviews

Dungeons & Dragons: Magic Items: Rare & Very Rare Reference Cards $29.39

Dungeons & Dragons: Magic Items: Rare & Very Rare Reference Cards
current price $29.39

Dungeons & Dragons: Magic Items: Rare & Very Rare Reference Cards

Weiss Schwarz Premium Lycoris Recoil (Booster Box) $36.00

Weiss Schwarz Premium Lycoris Recoil (Booster Box)
Sponsored
current price $36.00

Weiss Schwarz Premium Lycoris Recoil (Booster Box)

Magic: The Gathering Wrath of the Skies Modern Horizons 3 Rare Borderless Non-Foil English Trading Card $18.19

Magic: The Gathering Wrath of the Skies Modern Horizons 3 Rare Borderless Non-Foil English Trading Card
current price $18.19

Magic: The Gathering Wrath of the Skies Modern Horizons 3 Rare Borderless Non-Foil English Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Unglued Blacker Lotus Rare #70 Trading Card Regular $39.58

Magic: The Gathering Unglued Blacker Lotus Rare #70 Trading Card Regular
current price $39.58

Magic: The Gathering Unglued Blacker Lotus Rare #70 Trading Card Regular

1000 Assorted Magic: The Gathering Cards with C/U, Rares, and Foils! Includes CoolStuffInc Tokens! $29.99

1000 Assorted Magic: The Gathering Cards with C/U, Rares, and Foils! Includes CoolStuffInc Tokens!
current price $29.99

1000 Assorted Magic: The Gathering Cards with C/U, Rares, and Foils! Includes CoolStuffInc Tokens!

Legendary & Mythical Ultra Rare Battle Bundle | 100+ Pokmon Cards | 1x Ultra Rare Legendary/Mythical Guaranteed | Holos & Rares Included! | Perfect Gift for Kids & Collectors! $17.09 Was $18.99

Legendary & Mythical Ultra Rare Battle Bundle | 100+ Pokmon Cards | 1x Ultra Rare Legendary/Mythical Guaranteed | Holos & Rares Included! | Perfect Gift for Kids & Collectors!
current price Now $17.09, Was $18.99

Legendary & Mythical Ultra Rare Battle Bundle | 100+ Pokmon Cards | 1x Ultra Rare Legendary/Mythical Guaranteed | Holos & Rares Included! | Perfect Gift for Kids & Collectors!

3.6 out of 5 stars
3.6 out of 5 Stars. 60 reviews

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Prerelease Kit $29.93

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Prerelease Kit
current price $29.93

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Prerelease Kit

Magic: The Gathering Most Decrepit Old Bird The Hobbit Showcase Foil #221 Rare Trading Card $9.38

Magic: The Gathering Most Decrepit Old Bird The Hobbit Showcase Foil #221 Rare Trading Card
current price $9.38

Magic: The Gathering Most Decrepit Old Bird The Hobbit Showcase Foil #221 Rare Trading Card

Reality Fracture Magic The Gathering Prerelease Box $33.94 Was $40.00

Reality Fracture Magic The Gathering Prerelease Box
current price Now $33.94, Was $40.00

Reality Fracture Magic The Gathering Prerelease Box

2024 Magic: The Gathering Foundations Nine-Lives Familiar Borderless #321 Non-Foil Rare Trading Card $16.17

2024 Magic: The Gathering Foundations Nine-Lives Familiar Borderless #321 Non-Foil Rare Trading Card
current price $16.17

2024 Magic: The Gathering Foundations Nine-Lives Familiar Borderless #321 Non-Foil Rare Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Smaug, Wicked Worm The Hobbit #245 Rare Borderless Foil Trading Card $18.75

Magic: The Gathering Smaug, Wicked Worm The Hobbit #245 Rare Borderless Foil Trading Card
current price $18.75

Magic: The Gathering Smaug, Wicked Worm The Hobbit #245 Rare Borderless Foil Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering The Hobbit Collector Booster Box $554.98

Magic: The Gathering The Hobbit Collector Booster Box
current price $554.98

Magic: The Gathering The Hobbit Collector Booster Box

1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Magic: The Gathering The Hobbit Bundle $59.95 Was $70.00

Magic: The Gathering The Hobbit Bundle
current price Now $59.95, Was $70.00

Magic: The Gathering The Hobbit Bundle

4.2 out of 5 stars
4.2 out of 5 Stars. 5 reviews

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Commander Deck - Multiverse Reforged $48.79 Was $59.99

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Commander Deck - Multiverse Reforged
current price Now $48.79, Was $59.99

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Commander Deck - Multiverse Reforged

5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Magic: The Gathering Fear Of Missing Out Showcase Rare Duskmourn 0316 Graded 7.5 $19.97

Magic: The Gathering Fear Of Missing Out Showcase Rare Duskmourn 0316 Graded 7.5
current price $19.97

Magic: The Gathering Fear Of Missing Out Showcase Rare Duskmourn 0316 Graded 7.5

Magic: The Gathering Marvel's Spider-Man Spider-Man #206 Rare Borderless Regular English Trading Card $17.70

Magic: The Gathering Marvel's Spider-Man Spider-Man #206 Rare Borderless Regular English Trading Card
current price $17.70

Magic: The Gathering Marvel's Spider-Man Spider-Man #206 Rare Borderless Regular English Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Bundle $42.95

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Bundle
current price $42.95

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Bundle

Magic: The Gathering Artist's Talent Prerelease Cards #124 Rare Foil English Trading Card $30.85

Magic: The Gathering Artist's Talent Prerelease Cards #124 Rare Foil English Trading Card
current price $30.85

Magic: The Gathering Artist's Talent Prerelease Cards #124 Rare Foil English Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Scrawling Crawler Duskmourn: House of Horror Rare Trading Card 2024 $22.59

Magic: The Gathering Scrawling Crawler Duskmourn: House of Horror Rare Trading Card 2024
current price $22.59

Magic: The Gathering Scrawling Crawler Duskmourn: House of Horror Rare Trading Card 2024

Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Summon: Leviathan Borderless Rare Nonfoil #0361 Trading Card $14.21

Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Summon: Leviathan Borderless Rare Nonfoil #0361 Trading Card
current price $14.21

Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Summon: Leviathan Borderless Rare Nonfoil #0361 Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering- Planeswalker Deck- Core Set 2021 (M21) Basri- 60 Card Deck | 1 Rare of Mythic Rare | Legendary Creature $29.99

Magic: The Gathering- Planeswalker Deck- Core Set 2021 (M21) Basri- 60 Card Deck | 1 Rare of Mythic Rare | Legendary Creature
current price $29.99

Magic: The Gathering- Planeswalker Deck- Core Set 2021 (M21) Basri- 60 Card Deck | 1 Rare of Mythic Rare | Legendary Creature

2024 Magic The Gathering Goblin Charbelcher Future Sight Foil Rare #221 MB2 English $22.04

2024 Magic The Gathering Goblin Charbelcher Future Sight Foil Rare #221 MB2 English
current price $22.04

2024 Magic The Gathering Goblin Charbelcher Future Sight Foil Rare #221 MB2 English

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Secret Lair Bundle $109.69

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Secret Lair Bundle
current price $109.69

Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture Secret Lair Bundle

4.2 out of 5 stars
4.2 out of 5 Stars. 5 reviews

Magic: The Gathering Anim Pakal, Thousandth Moon The Lost Caverns of Ixalan #0223 Rare Nonfoil Trading Card $14.21

Magic: The Gathering Anim Pakal, Thousandth Moon The Lost Caverns of Ixalan #0223 Rare Nonfoil Trading Card
current price $14.21

Magic: The Gathering Anim Pakal, Thousandth Moon The Lost Caverns of Ixalan #0223 Rare Nonfoil Trading Card

2024 Magic: The Gathering Codsworth, Handy Helper #14 Universes Beyond: Fallout Rare Nonfoil Trading Card $25.96

2024 Magic: The Gathering Codsworth, Handy Helper #14 Universes Beyond: Fallout Rare Nonfoil Trading Card
current price $25.96

2024 Magic: The Gathering Codsworth, Handy Helper #14 Universes Beyond: Fallout Rare Nonfoil Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Play Booster Box $109.00 Was $124.99

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Play Booster Box
current price Now $109.00, Was $124.99

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Play Booster Box

Magic: The Gathering Kozilek's Command Foil Rare #11 Modern Horizons 3 Trading Card $19.10

Magic: The Gathering Kozilek's Command Foil Rare #11 Modern Horizons 3 Trading Card
current price $19.10

Magic: The Gathering Kozilek's Command Foil Rare #11 Modern Horizons 3 Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Through the Ages Darkness of Eternity - Dark Ritual Showcase #8 Non-Foil Rare Trading $20.15

Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Through the Ages Darkness of Eternity - Dark Ritual Showcase #8 Non-Foil Rare Trading
current price $20.15

Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Through the Ages Darkness of Eternity - Dark Ritual Showcase #8 Non-Foil Rare Trading

2001 Neo Discovery Kabutops Holo Rare #6/75 Pokemon English Wizards of the Coast Trading Card $100.10

2001 Neo Discovery Kabutops Holo Rare #6/75 Pokemon English Wizards of the Coast Trading Card
current price $100.10

2001 Neo Discovery Kabutops Holo Rare #6/75 Pokemon English Wizards of the Coast Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Collector Booster Box - 12 Packs $404.87 Was $539.64

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Collector Booster Box - 12 Packs
current price Now $404.87, Was $539.64

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Collector Booster Box - 12 Packs

1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Collector Booster Omega $44.97

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Collector Booster Omega
current price $44.97

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Collector Booster Omega

Wizards of The Coast - Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Collector Booster $64.70

Wizards of The Coast - Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Collector Booster
current price $64.70

Wizards of The Coast - Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Collector Booster

5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews

2024 Magic The Gathering Universes Beyond Fallout MacCready Lamplight Mayor #108 Rare Non-Foil Trading Card $16.17

2024 Magic The Gathering Universes Beyond Fallout MacCready Lamplight Mayor #108 Rare Non-Foil Trading Card
current price $16.17

2024 Magic The Gathering Universes Beyond Fallout MacCready Lamplight Mayor #108 Rare Non-Foil Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering Secret Lair x MSCHF: The Zeta Set Booster Pack 7 Randomized Trading Cards English Sealed $34.49

Magic: The Gathering Secret Lair x MSCHF: The Zeta Set Booster Pack  7 Randomized Trading Cards  English  Sealed
current price $34.49

Magic: The Gathering Secret Lair x MSCHF: The Zeta Set Booster Pack 7 Randomized Trading Cards English Sealed

Magic: The Gathering Reiterate Rare #182 Time Spiral Remastered Non-Foil Trading Card $28.90

Magic: The Gathering Reiterate Rare #182 Time Spiral Remastered Non-Foil Trading Card
current price $28.90

Magic: The Gathering Reiterate Rare #182 Time Spiral Remastered Non-Foil Trading Card

Magic: The Gathering 1999 Urza's Legacy Multani, Maro-Sorcerer Summon Legend Trading Card $26.26

Magic: The Gathering 1999 Urza's Legacy Multani, Maro-Sorcerer Summon Legend Trading Card
current price $26.26

Magic: The Gathering 1999 Urza's Legacy Multani, Maro-Sorcerer Summon Legend Trading Card

Highly rated by customers

Related Products