Anniversary Greeting CardsBirthday Greeting CardsBirthday Party FavorsBirthday Party SuppliesBoys BirthdayBridal Shower Party SuppliesBulk Party FavorsCharacter CardsCharacter Party FavorsCharacter Party SuppliesChristmas Favors & BagsChristmas Greeting CardsChristmas Party SuppliesEngagement Party SuppliesFun ExpressGraduation Gift Wrap & Greeting CardsGraduation Party SuppliesGreeting Card PacksGreeting CardsHalloween Favors & WearHalloween Party SuppliesParty DecorationsParty FavorsParty TablewareParty Wear & AccessoriesPinatasPower Rangers CardsSt. Patrick's Day Gift Wrap & Greeting CardsSt. Patrick's Day Party SuppliesThemed Greeting & Thank You CardsToys and NoveltyValentine's Day Greeting CardsValentine's Day Party FavorsWedding Party Supplies
Sort by|
Anniversary Greeting CardsBirthday Greeting CardsBirthday Party FavorsBirthday Party SuppliesBoys BirthdayBridal Shower Party SuppliesBulk Party FavorsCharacter CardsCharacter Party FavorsCharacter Party SuppliesChristmas Favors & BagsChristmas Greeting CardsChristmas Party SuppliesEngagement Party SuppliesFun ExpressGraduation Gift Wrap & Greeting CardsGraduation Party SuppliesGreeting Card PacksGreeting CardsHalloween Favors & WearHalloween Party SuppliesParty DecorationsParty FavorsParty TablewareParty Wear & AccessoriesPinatasPower Rangers CardsSt. Patrick's Day Gift Wrap & Greeting CardsSt. Patrick's Day Party SuppliesThemed Greeting & Thank You CardsToys and NoveltyValentine's Day Greeting CardsValentine's Day Party FavorsWedding Party Supplies
Pencil Candy(1)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
Pencil Bites Gummy Candy Mix | 2-Pound Pack | Assorted Fruit Flavors $13.99
$1399
current price $13.99Pencil Bites Gummy Candy Mix | 2-Pound Pack | Assorted Fruit Flavors
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Other options to consider(68)
Jesus Saves Me Sweet Creams Candy, 108 Pieces, Easter Novelty Candy $11.58
$1158
current price $11.58Jesus Saves Me Sweet Creams Candy, 108 Pieces, Easter Novelty Candy
Clearance Four Candies Metal Mechanical Pencil Set, 6PCS Artist Metal Pencil 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 2mm, Refills, Kneaded Eraser, Sharpener, Combo Set From $8.99
3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsFrom$899
Four Candies Metal Mechanical Pencil Set, 6PCS Artist Metal Pencil 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 2mm, Refills, Kneaded Eraser, Sharpener, Combo Set
3234.7 out of 5 Stars. 323 reviews
Save with
Sweetheart Candy Hearts Valentine's Day Holiday Theme Party Favor Pencils $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99Sweetheart Candy Hearts Valentine's Day Holiday Theme Party Favor Pencils
Halloween Hard Candy Sticks, 80 Pieces, Individually Wrapped, Candy Buffet $11.21
$1121
current price $11.21Halloween Hard Candy Sticks, 80 Pieces, Individually Wrapped, Candy Buffet
Save with
48-Count Bulk Candy Bracelets - Individually Wrapped Novelty Candy Bracelet - Party Favor Candy, Goody Bag Candy, Candies for Candy Buffet, Nostalgic Vintage Candy for Retro-Themed Party
2 options
Available in additional 2 options48-Count Bulk Candy Bracelets - Individually Wrapped Novelty Candy Bracelet - Party Favor Candy, Goody Bag Candy, Candies for Candy Buffet, Nostalgic Vintage Candy for Retro-Themed Party
25 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Save with
Edible Paper and Pen, 4 PACK Individually Wrapped Pen Paper TikTok Trend Items,Christmas Candy Bulk $25.99
$2599
current price $25.99Edible Paper and Pen, 4 PACK Individually Wrapped Pen Paper TikTok Trend Items,Christmas Candy Bulk
11 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Save with
Candy Stick - Black - Edibles - 80 Pieces $24.62
$2462
current price $24.62Candy Stick - Black - Edibles - 80 Pieces
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Clearance Four Candies 0.5 mm Mechanical Pencil Set - 6PCS Cute Pencils with 360PCS HB & 2B Lead Refills, 3PCS Pastel Erasers and 9PCS Eraser Refills, Aesthetic Supplies for Writing Drawing Drafting
2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFour Candies 0.5 mm Mechanical Pencil Set - 6PCS Cute Pencils with 360PCS HB & 2B Lead Refills, 3PCS Pastel Erasers and 9PCS Eraser Refills, Aesthetic Supplies for Writing Drawing Drafting
Save with
Nsxcdh School Season Pencils Candy Boxes Popcorn Party Gifts Teachers Classroom $6.99
$699
current price $6.99Nsxcdh School Season Pencils Candy Boxes Popcorn Party Gifts Teachers Classroom
20pcs Pencil Shaped Candy Boxes $25.99
$2599
current price $25.9920pcs Pencil Shaped Candy Boxes
Halloween Favor Pencils, 12ct $7.52
$752
current price $7.52Halloween Favor Pencils, 12ct
Disney Tsum Tsum Scented Pencils 4 Colored Pencils $19.99
$1999
current price $19.99Disney Tsum Tsum Scented Pencils 4 Colored Pencils
Four Candies Mechanical Pencils, 0.5mm HB & 2B Leads, Pastel Eraser Set with Refills, 16-Count for Writing & Drawing From $7.59
3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsFrom$759
Four Candies Mechanical Pencils, 0.5mm HB & 2B Leads, Pastel Eraser Set with Refills, 16-Count for Writing & Drawing
914.8 out of 5 Stars. 91 reviews
Save with
Halloween Pencil Assortment - Stationery - 144 Pieces $37.78
$3778
current price $37.78Halloween Pencil Assortment - Stationery - 144 Pieces
Best seller Four Candies 39 PCS Aesthetic Supplies, 12 Pastel Highlighters, 5 Black Ink Gel Pens, 6 Mechanical Pencils Set 0.5 & 0.7mm for Stationary College Essentials (Blue) From $19.94
From$1994
Four Candies 39 PCS Aesthetic Supplies, 12 Pastel Highlighters, 5 Black Ink Gel Pens, 6 Mechanical Pencils Set 0.5 & 0.7mm for Stationary College Essentials (Blue)
2654.6 out of 5 Stars. 265 reviews
Save with
Garbage Critters Pencil Toppers - 24 Pieces $9.01
$901
current price $9.01Garbage Critters Pencil Toppers - 24 Pieces
TINYMILLS 24 Pcs Day of the Dead Halloween Multi Point Stackable Push Pencil Assortment with Eraser for Halloween Party Favor Prize Carnival Goodie Bag Stuffers Classroom Rewards Pinata Fillers $14.99
$1499
current price $14.99TINYMILLS 24 Pcs Day of the Dead Halloween Multi Point Stackable Push Pencil Assortment with Eraser for Halloween Party Favor Prize Carnival Goodie Bag Stuffers Classroom Rewards Pinata Fillers
Save with
Best seller Four Candies 36PCS Aesthetic Supplies, Mechanical Pencil Set 0.5mm, 0.7mm, 0.9mm & 2.0mm with 624 Lead Refills, for Writing & Drawing, Ideal Stationary Set Gift (Purple
Four Candies 36PCS Aesthetic Supplies, Mechanical Pencil Set 0.5mm, 0.7mm, 0.9mm & 2.0mm with 624 Lead Refills, for Writing & Drawing, Ideal Stationary Set Gift (Purple
1294.7 out of 5 Stars. 129 reviews
Save with
50+ bought since yesterday 8 Count, Multicolor, Googly Eye Finger Puppets, Party Favors, by Way To Celebrate From $1.24
2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$124
8 Count, Multicolor, Googly Eye Finger Puppets, Party Favors, by Way To Celebrate
1944.7 out of 5 Stars. 194 reviews
Save with
Stackable Pencils,Fun Pencils,Cute Pencils,10pcs Cute Splicing Bear-Free Pencil,Stackable Plastic Bear Pencils,5 In 1 Colored Party Favors For Birthday Party Goodie Bag Filler School Fun Equipment. $6.99
$699
current price $6.99Stackable Pencils,Fun Pencils,Cute Pencils,10pcs Cute Splicing Bear-Free Pencil,Stackable Plastic Bear Pencils,5 In 1 Colored Party Favors For Birthday Party Goodie Bag Filler School Fun Equipment.
Fall Stacking Point Pencils - 24 Pieces $22.04
$2204
current price $22.04Fall Stacking Point Pencils - 24 Pieces
Flash Deal Four Candies 56 PCS Aesthetic Supplies with Pencil Case, 6 Multicolor Pen, 12 Pastel Highlighters, 5 Gel Pens Black Ink, 9 Mechanical Pencils for Stationary Set Preppy Stuff (Green) From $23.29
From$2329
Four Candies 56 PCS Aesthetic Supplies with Pencil Case, 6 Multicolor Pen, 12 Pastel Highlighters, 5 Gel Pens Black Ink, 9 Mechanical Pencils for Stationary Set Preppy Stuff (Green)
694.7 out of 5 Stars. 69 reviews
Save with
Duslogis 10 Pcs Wand Pencils Party Favors and 10 Pcs Witch Broom Pencils Bulk, Halloween Wizard Party Supplies Birthday Theme Goody Bag Filler Favors for Teen Tween Boys Girls Rewards From $16.99
2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$1699
Duslogis 10 Pcs Wand Pencils Party Favors and 10 Pcs Witch Broom Pencils Bulk, Halloween Wizard Party Supplies Birthday Theme Goody Bag Filler Favors for Teen Tween Boys Girls Rewards
Bulk Christian Pumpkin Pencil Assortment, Stationery, Halloween, 96 Pieces $27.46
$2746
current price $27.46Bulk Christian Pumpkin Pencil Assortment, Stationery, Halloween, 96 Pieces
30 Pieces Wand Pencils Halloween Wizard Party Supplies, Wizard Wand Pencils Theme Birthday Halloween Goody Bag Filler Favors for Teen School Rewards $27.00
$2700
current price $27.0030 Pieces Wand Pencils Halloween Wizard Party Supplies, Wizard Wand Pencils Theme Birthday Halloween Goody Bag Filler Favors for Teen School Rewards
Christian Pumpkin Pencils - Stationery - 24 Pieces $13.78
$1378
current price $13.78Christian Pumpkin Pencils - Stationery - 24 Pieces
LanSuare 12 Pack Witch Brooms Pencils, Party Favors Set for Teens and Adults - Halloween Decor, Themed Events, Gift Bags $5.07
$507
current price $5.07LanSuare 12 Pack Witch Brooms Pencils, Party Favors Set for Teens and Adults - Halloween Decor, Themed Events, Gift Bags
Fun Express Spooky Eyes & Jack-O-Lantern Pencils with Black Cat Halloween Card Assortments May Vary $10.33
$1033
current price $10.33Fun Express Spooky Eyes & Jack-O-Lantern Pencils with Black Cat Halloween Card Assortments May Vary
Fun Express 72 Piece Bumble Bee Party Favors Pencils & Toys Handout Kit for 24 $28.25
$2825
current price $28.25Fun Express 72 Piece Bumble Bee Party Favors Pencils & Toys Handout Kit for 24
CCWADH 12 Pack Witch Party Favors - Fun Witch Broom Pencils for Festive Celebrations & Daily Use - Perfect for Adults & Halloween Events
CCWADH 12 Pack Witch Party Favors - Fun Witch Broom Pencils for Festive Celebrations & Daily Use - Perfect for Adults & Halloween Events
Halloween Pencils with Eraser Halloween Themed Pencil Ghost Pumpkin Skeleton Bat Spider Wooden Pencils for Party Favor Supplies, 12 Style
Halloween Pencils with Eraser Halloween Themed Pencil Ghost Pumpkin Skeleton Bat Spider Wooden Pencils for Party Favor Supplies, 12 Style
YZHMYR Bear Stackable Colored Pencils Holographic Splicing Pencils Non-Food Valentine's Day Gift For Classroom Exchange School Party Favors DIY Message Heart Cards Desk Stationery Supplies
YZHMYR Bear Stackable Colored Pencils Holographic Splicing Pencils Non-Food Valentine's Day Gift For Classroom Exchange School Party Favors DIY Message Heart Cards Desk Stationery Supplies
Quaqdae 24 Pcs Wand Pencils and Glasses Wizard Party Favors, Wizard Party Supplies Theme Birthday Supplies for Teen Kids $16.37
$1637
current price $16.37Quaqdae 24 Pcs Wand Pencils and Glasses Wizard Party Favors, Wizard Party Supplies Theme Birthday Supplies for Teen Kids
14 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Bulk Pumpkin Eraser Pencil Toppers, Halloween, Stationery, 144 Pieces $12.90
$1290
current price $12.90Bulk Pumpkin Eraser Pencil Toppers, Halloween, Stationery, 144 Pieces
CCOCC 2026 New 12 Pcs Pencils,Witch Broomstick Decorations Witches Broom Halloween Wizard Wand Party Favors for Fun Goodie Bag Fillers Classroom Rewards and Theme Party Supplies $9.62
$962
current price $9.62CCOCC 2026 New 12 Pcs Pencils,Witch Broomstick Decorations Witches Broom Halloween Wizard Wand Party Favors for Fun Goodie Bag Fillers Classroom Rewards and Theme Party Supplies
Duslogis 10 Pcs Wand Pencils and 10 Pcs Witch Broom Pencils Wizard Party Favors for Teen Birthday Gifts Classroom Prizes Goodie Bag Fillers From $16.99
2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$1699
Duslogis 10 Pcs Wand Pencils and 10 Pcs Witch Broom Pencils Wizard Party Favors for Teen Birthday Gifts Classroom Prizes Goodie Bag Fillers
Oriental Trading Company Emoji Erasers Multi-color Halloween Party Favors, 144 Count $16.77
$1677
current price $16.77Oriental Trading Company Emoji Erasers Multi-color Halloween Party Favors, 144 Count
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Halloween Pencil Top Erasers - Party Favors - 144 Pieces $18.83
$1883
current price $18.83Halloween Pencil Top Erasers - Party Favors - 144 Pieces
Popular in Pencil Candy
Related Products
Tootsie Roll® Fruit Rolls® Candy, 48 Pieces, Halloween, Easter, Valentine's Day Candy
Tootsie Roll® Fruit Rolls® Candy, 48 Pieces, Halloween, Easter, Valentine's Day Candy$15.51current price $15.51Trolli Peg Bag Sour Brite Eggs 12 Count - 4 oz
Trolli Peg Bag Sour Brite Eggs 12 Count - 4 oz$32.64current price $32.64SWEDISH FISH Soft & Chewy Valentines Day Candy Hearts, 10 oz Bag
SWEDISH FISH Soft & Chewy Valentines Day Candy Hearts, 10 oz Bag$8.99current price $8.99Trolli Sour Brite Eggs Gummi Candy, 4 oz - Case of 12
Trolli Sour Brite Eggs Gummi Candy, 4 oz - Case of 12$32.75current price $32.75PSLLC SOUR PATCH KIDS Easter Bunnies for Baskets and Easter Egg Hunts Sour then Sweet Chewy Candy – 3.1 oz Movie Theatre Box (4 Boxes)
PSLLC SOUR PATCH KIDS Easter Bunnies for Baskets and Easter Egg Hunts Sour then Sweet Chewy Candy – 3.1 oz Movie Theatre Box (4 Boxes)$19.97current price $19.97Sour Patch Kids Watermelon 2 oz Bag (Pack of 16)
Sour Patch Kids Watermelon 2 oz Bag (Pack of 16)$39.82current price $39.82
