Holiday baked goodsShop All BakingShop All Bread and BakeryShop All BreakfastShop All CandyShop All FrozenAll Food GiftsBakery CookiesBakery SweetsBaking IngredientsBreakfast IdeasBrittle, Caramel & ToffeeBulk CandyCakesCandy BarsChilled Snacks & BeveragesChipsChocolateCoffeeCoffee AdditivesCookiesCreate Your Charcuterie BoardDried FruitsEuropean & MediterraneanEveryday baking essentialsFreshness Guaranteed BakeryFreshness Guaranteed FoodFrom our brands bakeryFrozen DessertsFruit Flavored & Sour CandyFruit SnacksGluten Free Meals and moreGluten-Free SnacksGreat Value Snack CakesGumGum & mintsGummy & Chewy CandyHard Candy & LollipopsHealth-inspired SnacksHerbs, spices & seasoning mixesHoliday Meal & Entertaining EssentialsHoliday sprinklesIce Cream & NoveltiesInternational foodsKids Lunches & SnacksMarketsideMarketside BakeryMarketside FoodMediterranean DietMintsMore bakingNuts, Trail Mix & SeedsOatmeal & GritsPancake and Waffle ToppingsPantry EssentialsPantry meal essentialsParty Food ShopShop all BakeryShop all Bakery & BreadShop All Gluten FreeShop All SnacksSnack BarsSnacks and Beverages $1Snacks Food GiftsSoda ShopSpecialty Cheese & CharcuterieSprinklesSweet TreatsTortillas
Sort by|
Holiday baked goodsShop All BakingShop All Bread and BakeryShop All BreakfastShop All CandyShop All FrozenAll Food GiftsBakery CookiesBakery SweetsBaking IngredientsBreakfast IdeasBrittle, Caramel & ToffeeBulk CandyCakesCandy BarsChilled Snacks & BeveragesChipsChocolateCoffeeCoffee AdditivesCookiesCreate Your Charcuterie BoardDried FruitsEuropean & MediterraneanEveryday baking essentialsFreshness Guaranteed BakeryFreshness Guaranteed FoodFrom our brands bakeryFrozen DessertsFruit Flavored & Sour CandyFruit SnacksGluten Free Meals and moreGluten-Free SnacksGreat Value Snack CakesGumGum & mintsGummy & Chewy CandyHard Candy & LollipopsHealth-inspired SnacksHerbs, spices & seasoning mixesHoliday Meal & Entertaining EssentialsHoliday sprinklesIce Cream & NoveltiesInternational foodsKids Lunches & SnacksMarketsideMarketside BakeryMarketside FoodMediterranean DietMintsMore bakingNuts, Trail Mix & SeedsOatmeal & GritsPancake and Waffle ToppingsPantry EssentialsPantry meal essentialsParty Food ShopShop all BakeryShop all Bakery & BreadShop All Gluten FreeShop All SnacksSnack BarsSnacks and Beverages $1Snacks Food GiftsSoda ShopSpecialty Cheese & CharcuterieSprinklesSweet TreatsTortillas
Ny Sweets(393)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Chewy Fruit Slices Candy - 3 Pound - Fruit Slice Jelly Candy - Soft Chewy Assorted Fruit Flavored Sweets $29.99

Sponsored
$2999
current price $29.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Chewy Fruit Slices Candy - 3 Pound - Fruit Slice Jelly Candy - Soft Chewy Assorted Fruit Flavored Sweets
3.7 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Black & Red Berries Candy - 08 Ounce $5.99

Sponsored
$599
current price $5.99NY SPICE SHOP Black & Red Berries Candy - 08 Ounce
4.3 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Grapes Fruit Filled Gummy - 1 Pound - Grapes Burst Juice Jelly Candy - Filled Grape Gummies - Grape Jelly Gummies - Juicy Grape Sweets Candy $15.99

Sponsored
$1599
current price $15.99NY SPICE SHOP Grapes Fruit Filled Gummy - 1 Pound - Grapes Burst Juice Jelly Candy - Filled Grape Gummies - Grape Jelly Gummies - Juicy Grape Sweets Candy
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Starlights Candy - 1 Pound - Fruit Swirl Candy Discs - Individually Wrapped Classic Starlight Hard Candy - Traditional Starlight Candy - Fruit Swirl Hard Candy $12.99

Sponsored
$1299
current price $12.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Starlights Candy - 1 Pound - Fruit Swirl Candy Discs - Individually Wrapped Classic Starlight Hard Candy - Traditional Starlight Candy - Fruit Swirl Hard Candy
4.1 out of 5 stars
1K+ bought since yesterday, Marketside New York Style Cheesecake, 16 oz, 8 Slices (Refrigerated) $6.72 42.0 ¢/oz
1K+ bought since yesterday

$672
current price $6.7242.0 ¢/oz
Marketside New York Style Cheesecake, 16 oz, 8 Slices (Refrigerated)
4.3 out of 5 stars
Marketside New York Style Cheesecake Slice, 8 oz (Refrigerated) $3.98 49.8 ¢/oz

$398
current price $3.9849.8 ¢/oz
Marketside New York Style Cheesecake Slice, 8 oz (Refrigerated)
4.3 out of 5 stars
Marketside New York Style Full Cheesecake, 40 oz, 12 Count (Refrigerated) $13.92 34.8 ¢/oz

$1392
current price $13.9234.8 ¢/oz
Marketside New York Style Full Cheesecake, 40 oz, 12 Count (Refrigerated)
4.4 out of 5 stars
York Thins Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties, Candy Share Pack, 7.2 oz $5.97 82.9 ¢/oz

$597
current price $5.9782.9 ¢/oz
York Thins Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties, Candy Share Pack, 7.2 oz
4.7 out of 5 stars
Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | All Natural, Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Tray of 10 Cookies | 10 oz Sterns Bakery $20.99

$2099
current price $20.99Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | All Natural, Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Tray of 10 Cookies | 10 oz Sterns Bakery
3.6 out of 5 stars
Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Office Snack | Coffee Snack | Sterns Bakery (18 Count Black & White Cookies) $29.99

$2999
current price $29.99Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Office Snack | Coffee Snack | Sterns Bakery (18 Count Black & White Cookies)
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Sour Chewy Gummy Cubes - 08 Ounce $7.99

Sponsored
$799
current price $7.99NY SPICE SHOP Sour Chewy Gummy Cubes - 08 Ounce
4 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Green with Pistachios - 1 Pound - Turkish Delight Nougat Green - Pistachio Nougat - Arabic Nougat - Mediterranean Nougat $14.99

Sponsored
$1499
current price $14.99NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Green with Pistachios - 1 Pound - Turkish Delight Nougat Green - Pistachio Nougat - Arabic Nougat - Mediterranean Nougat
4.5 out of 5 stars
Best seller, York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Candy, Family Pack 17.3 oz $21.50 $1.24/oz
Best seller

$2150
current price $21.50$1.24/oz
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Candy, Family Pack 17.3 oz
4.8 out of 5 stars
1K+ bought since yesterday, York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Candy, Share Pack, 9.1 oz $5.97 65.6 ¢/oz
1K+ bought since yesterday

$597
current price $5.9765.6 ¢/oz
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Candy, Share Pack, 9.1 oz
4.8 out of 5 stars
Black & White Cookies Gift Basket 12 Individually Wrapped Cookies NY Style Black and White Cookies 2-3 Day Delivery Christmas, Hanukkah, Thanksgiving Men & Women Sterns Bakery $28.99

$2899
current price $28.99Black & White Cookies Gift Basket 12 Individually Wrapped Cookies NY Style Black and White Cookies 2-3 Day Delivery Christmas, Hanukkah, Thanksgiving Men & Women Sterns Bakery
4.6 out of 5 stars
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Pumpkins Fall Candy, Bag 8.6 oz $13.00 $1.51/oz

$1300
current price $13.00$1.51/oz
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Pumpkins Fall Candy, Bag 8.6 oz
4.7 out of 5 stars
NY Spice Shop Mixed Fruit Burst Jelly Candy - 5 Pound - Mixed Fruit Burst Sweets - Stuffed Fruit Chews - Fruit Explosion Candies - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies $49.99

$4999
current price $49.99NY Spice Shop Mixed Fruit Burst Jelly Candy - 5 Pound - Mixed Fruit Burst Sweets - Stuffed Fruit Chews - Fruit Explosion Candies - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies
Best seller, York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Candy, Share Pack 10.1 oz $17.95 $1.78/oz
Best seller

$1795
current price $17.95$1.78/oz
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Candy, Share Pack 10.1 oz
4.8 out of 5 stars
NY Spice Shop Assorted Gummies Snack Tray - 2 Pound $23.99

$2399
current price $23.99NY Spice Shop Assorted Gummies Snack Tray - 2 Pound
5 out of 5 stars
Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | Natural, Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Office Snack | Coffee Snack - (Pack of 18 Individually Wrapped Cookies) | Sterns Bakery $29.99

$2999
current price $29.99Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | Natural, Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Office Snack | Coffee Snack - (Pack of 18 Individually Wrapped Cookies) | Sterns Bakery
3.4 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Mini Dark Chocolate Mini Nonpareils with Rainbow Seeds - 1 Pound $16.99

Sponsored
$1699
current price $16.99NY SPICE SHOP Mini Dark Chocolate Mini Nonpareils with Rainbow Seeds - 1 Pound
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Sour Peach Jelly Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy $34.99

$3499
current price $34.99NY SPICE SHOP Sour Peach Jelly Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy
3.8 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Blue Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 5 Pound - Blue Raspberry Candy Puffs - Blue Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Blue & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets $54.99

$5499
current price $54.99NY SPICE SHOP Blue Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 5 Pound - Blue Raspberry Candy Puffs - Blue Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Blue & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets
Best seller, York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Candy, Family Pack, 15.4 oz $9.84 63.9 ¢/oz
Best seller

$984
current price $9.8463.9 ¢/oz
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Candy, Family Pack, 15.4 oz
4.8 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Watermelon Gummy Candy - 3 Pound - Soft Chewy Watermelon Gummy Candies - Watermelon Chews - Watermelon Jelly Candy - Watermelon Soft Candy $22.99

$2299
current price $22.99NY SPICE SHOP Watermelon Gummy Candy - 3 Pound - Soft Chewy Watermelon Gummy Candies - Watermelon Chews - Watermelon Jelly Candy - Watermelon Soft Candy
NY Spice Shop 3D Gummies Assortment Tray - 2 Pound $23.99

$2399
current price $23.99NY Spice Shop 3D Gummies Assortment Tray - 2 Pound
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Sanded Fruit Drops - 3 Pound - Old Fashioned Sanded Drops - Fresh Delicious Bulk Candy - Sanded Hard Candy - Sour Drops Candy - Tangy and Sweet Healthy Snacks $34.99

$3499
current price $34.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Sanded Fruit Drops - 3 Pound - Old Fashioned Sanded Drops - Fresh Delicious Bulk Candy - Sanded Hard Candy - Sour Drops Candy - Tangy and Sweet Healthy Snacks
4.3 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Christmas Assorted Spice Drops - 3 Pound - Classic Chewy Candy Mix Gumdrops - Old-Fashioned Christmas Spice Candy for Holiday Snacking, Parties & Decorating $19.99

$1999
current price $19.99NY SPICE SHOP Christmas Assorted Spice Drops - 3 Pound - Classic Chewy Candy Mix Gumdrops - Old-Fashioned Christmas Spice Candy for Holiday Snacking, Parties & Decorating
4.3 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 3 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight $34.99

$3499
current price $34.99NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 3 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight
4.5 out of 5 stars
NY Spice Sweat Pear Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Fruit Slices Candy - Candy Fruit Slices $35.99

$3599
current price $35.99NY Spice Sweat Pear Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Fruit Slices Candy - Candy Fruit Slices
3.8 out of 5 stars
From You Flowers Sugar-Free New York Cheesecake $94.98

$9498
current price $94.98From You Flowers Sugar-Free New York Cheesecake
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Lemon Jelly Fruit Slices Candy Chewy Lemon-Flavored Gummies, Lemon Gummy Candy, Citrus Fruit Slice Candy for Snacking - 5 Pound $59.99

$5999
current price $59.99NY SPICE SHOP Lemon Jelly Fruit Slices Candy Chewy Lemon-Flavored Gummies, Lemon Gummy Candy, Citrus Fruit Slice Candy for Snacking - 5 Pound
3.8 out of 5 stars
NY Spice Shop Assorted Sour Balls Tray - 2 Pound $23.99

$2399
current price $23.99NY Spice Shop Assorted Sour Balls Tray - 2 Pound
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Licorice Allsorts Candy - Assorted Black Licorice Sweets - Colorful Licorice Bites - Classic Candy Mix for Snacking - 5 Pound $46.99

$4699
current price $46.99NY SPICE SHOP Licorice Allsorts Candy - Assorted Black Licorice Sweets - Colorful Licorice Bites - Classic Candy Mix for Snacking - 5 Pound
4.3 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 5 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight $54.99

$5499
current price $54.99NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 5 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight
4.5 out of 5 stars
York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties, Halloween Candy Bag, 11.4 oz

York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties, Halloween Candy Bag, 11.4 oz
4.7 out of 5 stars
NY Spice Shop Assorted Mix Gummies Snack Tray - 2 Pound $21.85

$2185
current price $21.85NY Spice Shop Assorted Mix Gummies Snack Tray - 2 Pound
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Watermelon Jelly Fruit Slices - 5 Pound - Jelly Fruit Slices - Jelly Slices Candy $59.99

$5999
current price $59.99NY SPICE SHOP Watermelon Jelly Fruit Slices - 5 Pound - Jelly Fruit Slices - Jelly Slices Candy
3.8 out of 5 stars
Black & White Cookies | 90 Individually Wrapped Cookies | NY Style Black and White Cookies | Cookies Snack Packs | Lunchbox Snacks | Office Snacks | Kosher, Dairy & Nut Free | Sterns Bakery $84.99

$8499
current price $84.99Black & White Cookies | 90 Individually Wrapped Cookies | NY Style Black and White Cookies | Cookies Snack Packs | Lunchbox Snacks | Office Snacks | Kosher, Dairy & Nut Free | Sterns Bakery
1 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Peach Gummy Fruit Jelly Rings Candy - 3 Pound - Peach Jelly Rings - Peach Gummy Rings - Peach Flavored Jelly Rings - Peach Candy Rings - Peach Fruit Rings $20.95

$2095
current price $20.95NY SPICE SHOP Peach Gummy Fruit Jelly Rings Candy - 3 Pound - Peach Jelly Rings - Peach Gummy Rings - Peach Flavored Jelly Rings - Peach Candy Rings - Peach Fruit Rings
4.3 out of 5 stars
YORK Minis Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Candy, 7.6 oz, 4 Pack $50.19

$5019
current price $50.19YORK Minis Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Candy, 7.6 oz, 4 Pack
5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Halloween Gumballs - 3 Pound - Halloween Candy - Halloween Candy Bulk - Halloween Gummy Candy $24.99

$2499
current price $24.99NY SPICE SHOP Halloween Gumballs - 3 Pound - Halloween Candy - Halloween Candy Bulk - Halloween Gummy Candy
4.3 out of 5 stars
York Peppermint Patties Mini -2 LB Bulk Candy- Individually Wrapped $23.99

$2399
current price $23.99York Peppermint Patties Mini -2 LB Bulk Candy- Individually Wrapped
3.9 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy - Fruit Candy $37.99

$3799
current price $37.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy - Fruit Candy
3.8 out of 5 stars
NY Spice Shop Assorted Lemon Fruit Slices & Gummies Tray - 2 Pound $23.99

$2399
current price $23.99NY Spice Shop Assorted Lemon Fruit Slices & Gummies Tray - 2 Pound
5 out of 5 stars
York Peppermint Sugar Free Candy by Hershey's - 2 Pack $21.69

$2169
current price $21.69York Peppermint Sugar Free Candy by Hershey's - 2 Pack
4.5 out of 5 stars
NY SPICE SHOP Cherry Cordials - 1 Pound $19.99

$1999
current price $19.99NY SPICE SHOP Cherry Cordials - 1 Pound
Other options to consider(137)
Popular in Ny Sweets
Related Products
Trolli Peachie O's Sour Gummy Rings Candy, 4.25 Ounce, [Pack of 12]
Trolli Peachie O's Sour Gummy Rings Candy, 4.25 Ounce, [Pack of 12]$31.55current price $31.55Trolli Peachie O's Sour Gummy Rings Candy, 4.25 Ounce, [1-Bag]
Trolli Peachie O's Sour Gummy Rings Candy, 4.25 Ounce, [1-Bag]$9.64current price $9.64Blue Raspberry Sour Patch Kids Original Soft & Chewy Candy - 7 oz.
Blue Raspberry Sour Patch Kids Original Soft & Chewy Candy - 7 oz.$8.95current price $8.95Strawberry Starburst Individually Wrapped Fruit Chews - 1 Full Pound | Pink ChewyTaffy Candy| Edible Gift Ideas for Baby, Bridal Shower, Birthday | Candy Buffet Bar
Strawberry Starburst Individually Wrapped Fruit Chews - 1 Full Pound | Pink ChewyTaffy Candy| Edible Gift Ideas for Baby, Bridal Shower, Birthday | Candy Buffet Bar$17.25current price $17.25Efrutti Pizza Gummi Candy, 48-Count - Gummy Bulk Deal
Efrutti Pizza Gummi Candy, 48-Count - Gummy Bulk Deal$20.49current price $20.49Sour Patch Kids Blue Soft Chewy Candy 8 Oz Bags 12, Raspberry, 12 Count
Sour Patch Kids Blue Soft Chewy Candy 8 Oz Bags 12, Raspberry, 12 Count$32.50current price $32.50Amos Peelerz Exotic Fruit Gummy Candy, Variety Pack Candy Individually Wrapped Pack 8.47 oz
Amos Peelerz Exotic Fruit Gummy Candy, Variety Pack Candy Individually Wrapped Pack 8.47 oz$9.99current price $9.99Fruit Slices Candy, 1 Pound Bulk Bag, Candy Fruit Slices Gummy Candy
Fruit Slices Candy, 1 Pound Bulk Bag, Candy Fruit Slices Gummy Candy$12.99current price $12.99(6 pack) SOUR PATCH KIDS Blue Raspberry Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 3.6 oz
(6 pack) SOUR PATCH KIDS Blue Raspberry Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 3.6 oz$18.00current price $18.00FirstChoiceCandy Tropical Sour Mix Gummy (Mini Fruity Drop, Mini Rainbow Belts, Sour Flower Gummy , Sour Twister) - 2 Pound
FirstChoiceCandy Tropical Sour Mix Gummy (Mini Fruity Drop, Mini Rainbow Belts, Sour Flower Gummy , Sour Twister) - 2 Pound$24.99current price $24.992x Bags Sour Patch Kids Blue Raspberry Flavor Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy | 3.6oz
2x Bags Sour Patch Kids Blue Raspberry Flavor Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy | 3.6oz
Sour Patch Kids Black Raspberry Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy - 100g/3.5 oz
Sour Patch Kids Black Raspberry Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy - 100g/3.5 oz$14.99current price $14.99Snak Club Watermelon Rings Gummy Snack – 2 Bags (4 oz Each) No Known Allergens
Snak Club Watermelon Rings Gummy Snack – 2 Bags (4 oz Each) No Known Allergens$14.00current price $14.00Huer Sprinkle Bears Gummies, Assorted Flavors, Rainbow Gummy Candy - 120g/4.2 oz
Huer Sprinkle Bears Gummies, Assorted Flavors, Rainbow Gummy Candy - 120g/4.2 oz$14.99current price $14.99FirstChoiceCandy Sour Mini Strip Gummy Belts, Mini Bites Kosher Gummies ( 2 Pound - Very Berry )
FirstChoiceCandy Sour Mini Strip Gummy Belts, Mini Bites Kosher Gummies ( 2 Pound - Very Berry )$17.99current price $17.99
