Holiday baked goodsShop All BakingShop All Bread and BakeryShop All CandyShop All FrozenAll Food GiftsBakery CookiesBakery SweetsBaking IngredientsBrittle, Caramel & ToffeeBulk CandyCakesChilled Snacks & BeveragesChipsChocolateCookiesCreate Your Charcuterie BoardFreshness Guaranteed BakeryFreshness Guaranteed FoodFrom our brands bakeryFrozen DessertsFruit Flavored & Sour CandyFruit SnacksGluten Free Meals and moreGluten-Free SnacksGreat Value Snack CakesGumGum & mintsGummy & Chewy CandyHard Candy & LollipopsHealth-inspired SnacksHerbs, spices & seasoning mixesHoliday Meal & Entertaining EssentialsHoliday sprinklesIce Cream & NoveltiesMarketsideMarketside BakeryMarketside FoodMediterranean DietMintsMore bakingNuts, Trail Mix & SeedsOatmeal & GritsPantry EssentialsPantry meal essentialsParty Food ShopSeasonal BakeryShop all BakeryShop all Bakery & BreadShop All Gluten FreeShop All SnacksSnack BarsSnacks and Beverages $1Snacks Food GiftsSoda ShopSprinklesSweet TreatsTrail Mix
Sort by|
Holiday baked goodsShop All BakingShop All Bread and BakeryShop All CandyShop All FrozenAll Food GiftsBakery CookiesBakery SweetsBaking IngredientsBrittle, Caramel & ToffeeBulk CandyCakesChilled Snacks & BeveragesChipsChocolateCookiesCreate Your Charcuterie BoardFreshness Guaranteed BakeryFreshness Guaranteed FoodFrom our brands bakeryFrozen DessertsFruit Flavored & Sour CandyFruit SnacksGluten Free Meals and moreGluten-Free SnacksGreat Value Snack CakesGumGum & mintsGummy & Chewy CandyHard Candy & LollipopsHealth-inspired SnacksHerbs, spices & seasoning mixesHoliday Meal & Entertaining EssentialsHoliday sprinklesIce Cream & NoveltiesMarketsideMarketside BakeryMarketside FoodMediterranean DietMintsMore bakingNuts, Trail Mix & SeedsOatmeal & GritsPantry EssentialsPantry meal essentialsParty Food ShopSeasonal BakeryShop all BakeryShop all Bakery & BreadShop All Gluten FreeShop All SnacksSnack BarsSnacks and Beverages $1Snacks Food GiftsSoda ShopSprinklesSweet TreatsTrail Mix
Ny Sweets(62)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
Best seller Freshness Guaranteed New York Style Cheesecake, 16 oz, 6inch $5.98 37.4 ¢/oz
$598
current price $5.9837.4 ¢/oz
Freshness Guaranteed New York Style Cheesecake, 16 oz, 6inch
37674.3 out of 5 Stars. 3767 reviews
NY Spice Shop Mixed Fruit Burst Jelly Candy - 5 Pound - Mixed Fruit Burst Sweets - Stuffed Fruit Chews - Fruit Explosion Candies - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies $49.99
$4999
current price $49.99NY Spice Shop Mixed Fruit Burst Jelly Candy - 5 Pound - Mixed Fruit Burst Sweets - Stuffed Fruit Chews - Fruit Explosion Candies - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies
NY SPICE SHOP Strawberry Fruit Filled Candy 3 Pound - Strawberry Burst Candy - Juicy Strawberry Gummy - Berry Explosion Sweets - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies $29.99
$2999
current price $29.99NY SPICE SHOP Strawberry Fruit Filled Candy 3 Pound - Strawberry Burst Candy - Juicy Strawberry Gummy - Berry Explosion Sweets - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies
Freshness Guaranteed New York Style Full Cheesecake, 40 oz, 12 Count (Refrigerated) $12.98 32.5 ¢/oz
$1298
current price $12.9832.5 ¢/oz
Freshness Guaranteed New York Style Full Cheesecake, 40 oz, 12 Count (Refrigerated)
29654.4 out of 5 Stars. 2965 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Pink Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 5 Pound - Pink Raspberry Candy Puffs - Pink Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Pink & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets $49.99
$4999
current price $49.99NY SPICE SHOP Pink Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 5 Pound - Pink Raspberry Candy Puffs - Pink Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Pink & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets
NY SPICE SHOP Starlight Spearmints Hard Candy - 2 Pound - Green & White Mint Discs - Individually Wrapped Classic Mints - Classic Spearmint Hard Candy - Traditional Refreshing Mint Sweets $10.95
$1095
current price $10.95NY SPICE SHOP Starlight Spearmints Hard Candy - 2 Pound - Green & White Mint Discs - Individually Wrapped Classic Mints - Classic Spearmint Hard Candy - Traditional Refreshing Mint Sweets
84.9 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
Davids Cookies 10" Original New York Style Cheesecake, Pre-Sliced Birthday Cake, 14 Servings $56.95
$5695
current price $56.95Davids Cookies 10" Original New York Style Cheesecake, Pre-Sliced Birthday Cake, 14 Servings
44.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
NY Spice Shop Mixed Fruit Burst Jelly Candy - 1 Pound - Mixed Fruit Burst Sweets - Stuffed Fruit Chews - Fruit Explosion Candies - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies $11.95
$1195
current price $11.95NY Spice Shop Mixed Fruit Burst Jelly Candy - 1 Pound - Mixed Fruit Burst Sweets - Stuffed Fruit Chews - Fruit Explosion Candies - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies
NY SPICE SHOP Blue Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 5 Pound - Blue Raspberry Candy Puffs - Blue Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Blue & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets $54.99
$5499
current price $54.99NY SPICE SHOP Blue Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 5 Pound - Blue Raspberry Candy Puffs - Blue Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Blue & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets
NY SPICE SHOP Strawberry Fruit Filled Candy - 1 Pound - Strawberry Burst Candy - Juicy Strawberry Gummy - Berry Explosion Sweets - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99NY SPICE SHOP Strawberry Fruit Filled Candy - 1 Pound - Strawberry Burst Candy - Juicy Strawberry Gummy - Berry Explosion Sweets - Juicy Fruity Filled Gummies
NY SPICE SHOP Pink Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 1 Pound - Pink Raspberry Candy Puffs - Pink Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Pink & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets $13.99
$1399
current price $13.99NY SPICE SHOP Pink Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 1 Pound - Pink Raspberry Candy Puffs - Pink Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Pink & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets
NY SPICE SHOP Grapes Fruit Filled Gummy - 1 Pound - Grapes Burst Juice Jelly Candy - Filled Grape Gummies - Grape Jelly Gummies - Juicy Grape Sweets Candy $15.99
$1599
current price $15.99NY SPICE SHOP Grapes Fruit Filled Gummy - 1 Pound - Grapes Burst Juice Jelly Candy - Filled Grape Gummies - Grape Jelly Gummies - Juicy Grape Sweets Candy
Marketside New York Style Cheesecake Slice, 8 oz $3.98 49.8 ¢/oz
$398
current price $3.9849.8 ¢/oz
Marketside New York Style Cheesecake Slice, 8 oz
5424.3 out of 5 Stars. 542 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Blue Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 1 Pound - Blue Raspberry Candy Puffs - Blue Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Blue & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets $13.99
$1399
current price $13.99NY SPICE SHOP Blue Raspberry Puffy Puffs - 1 Pound - Blue Raspberry Candy Puffs - Blue Cotton Candy Puffs - Dome Shaped Candy - Blue & White Fruity Puffy Puffs Sweets
Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | All Natural, Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Tray of 10 Cookies | 10 oz Sterns Bakery $18.89
$1889
current price $18.89Black and White Cookies | NY Style Black & White Cookies | Snack Cakes | All Natural, Fresh & Delicious | Kosher | Tray of 10 Cookies | 10 oz Sterns Bakery
213.6 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Starlight Spearmints Hard Candy - 3 Pound - Green & White Mint Discs - Individually Wrapped Classic Mints - Classic Spearmint Hard Candy - Traditional Refreshing Mint Sweets $16.99
$1699
current price $16.99NY SPICE SHOP Starlight Spearmints Hard Candy - 3 Pound - Green & White Mint Discs - Individually Wrapped Classic Mints - Classic Spearmint Hard Candy - Traditional Refreshing Mint Sweets
84.9 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
NY Spice Sweat Pear Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Fruit Slices Candy - Candy Fruit Slices $12.99
$1299
current price $12.99NY Spice Sweat Pear Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Fruit Slices Candy - Candy Fruit Slices
493.9 out of 5 Stars. 49 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Chews Licorice Sweet Toffees - 1 Pound $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99NY SPICE SHOP Chews Licorice Sweet Toffees - 1 Pound
Black & White Cookies Gift Basket 12 Individually Wrapped Cookies NY Style Black and White Cookies 2-3 Day Delivery Christmas, Hanukkah, Thanksgiving Men & Women Sterns Bakery $21.99
$2199
current price $21.99Black & White Cookies Gift Basket 12 Individually Wrapped Cookies NY Style Black and White Cookies 2-3 Day Delivery Christmas, Hanukkah, Thanksgiving Men & Women Sterns Bakery
94.3 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviews
NY Spice Shop Assorted Chewy Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Jelly Candy $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99NY Spice Shop Assorted Chewy Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Jelly Candy
133.3 out of 5 Stars. 13 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Sanded Fruit Drops - 3 Pound - Old Fashioned Sanded Drops - Fresh Delicious Bulk Candy - Sanded Hard Candy - Sour Drops Candy - Tangy and Sweet Healthy Snacks $34.99
$3499
current price $34.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Sanded Fruit Drops - 3 Pound - Old Fashioned Sanded Drops - Fresh Delicious Bulk Candy - Sanded Hard Candy - Sour Drops Candy - Tangy and Sweet Healthy Snacks
45 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
NY Spice Shop Assorted Mix Jelly Tray - 2 Pound Lemon Candy Fruit Slices, Key Lime Fruit Slices, Red Raspberry Fruit Slices, Orange Fruit Slices, Black Cherry Fruit Slices $23.99
$2399
current price $23.99NY Spice Shop Assorted Mix Jelly Tray - 2 Pound Lemon Candy Fruit Slices, Key Lime Fruit Slices, Red Raspberry Fruit Slices, Orange Fruit Slices, Black Cherry Fruit Slices
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 1 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight $12.99
$1299
current price $12.99NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 1 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight
34.3 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Sanded Fruit Drops - 1 Pound - Old Fashioned Sanded Drops - Fresh Delicious Bulk Candy - Sanded Hard Candy - Sour Drops Candy - Tangy and Sweet Healthy Snacks $12.95
$1295
current price $12.95NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Sanded Fruit Drops - 1 Pound - Old Fashioned Sanded Drops - Fresh Delicious Bulk Candy - Sanded Hard Candy - Sour Drops Candy - Tangy and Sweet Healthy Snacks
45 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Cola Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Fruit Slices Candy - Juicy Jellies Candy $11.95
$1195
current price $11.95NY SPICE SHOP Cola Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Fruit Slices Candy - Juicy Jellies Candy
493.9 out of 5 Stars. 49 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Sour Balls - 1 Pound - Sour Balls Candy - Sour Candy Balls $12.99
$1299
current price $12.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Sour Balls - 1 Pound - Sour Balls Candy - Sour Candy Balls
42.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Gummy Strawberries Candy - 5 Pound - Strawberry Gummies - Strawberry Shaped Candy - Strawberry Jelly Candy - Strawberry Gumy Candy $44.99
$4499
current price $44.99NY SPICE SHOP Gummy Strawberries Candy - 5 Pound - Strawberry Gummies - Strawberry Shaped Candy - Strawberry Jelly Candy - Strawberry Gumy Candy
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy - Fruit Candy $37.99
$3799
current price $37.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 3 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy - Fruit Candy
493.9 out of 5 Stars. 49 reviews
Caramel Squares - Caramel Candy Square Slices - Holiday Sweets - Holiday Gift - 3 Lbs. $39.99
$3999
current price $39.99Caramel Squares - Caramel Candy Square Slices - Holiday Sweets - Holiday Gift - 3 Lbs.
NY SPICE SHOP Grape Fruit Sour Balls - 08 Ounce $7.99
$799
current price $7.99NY SPICE SHOP Grape Fruit Sour Balls - 08 Ounce
42.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Root Beer Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Jelly Fruit Slices Candy - Jelly Candy $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99NY SPICE SHOP Root Beer Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Jelly Fruit Slices Candy - Jelly Candy
493.9 out of 5 Stars. 49 reviews
NY Spice Shop Assorted Chewy Fruit Slices - Jelly Candy - 8 Ounces $6.99
$699
current price $6.99NY Spice Shop Assorted Chewy Fruit Slices - Jelly Candy - 8 Ounces
133.3 out of 5 Stars. 13 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Sugar Free Gummy Worms Candy - 1 Pound - Colorful Sugar Free Gummy Worms $18.99
$1899
current price $18.99NY SPICE SHOP Sugar Free Gummy Worms Candy - 1 Pound - Colorful Sugar Free Gummy Worms
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Caramel Squares - Caramel Candy Square Slices - Holiday Sweets - Holiday Gift - 1 Lb. $14.99
$1499
current price $14.99Caramel Squares - Caramel Candy Square Slices - Holiday Sweets - Holiday Gift - 1 Lb.
NY SPICE SHOP Gummy Strawberries Candy - 1 Pound - Strawberry Gummies - Strawberry Shaped Candy - Strawberry Jelly Candy - Strawberry Gumy Candy $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99NY SPICE SHOP Gummy Strawberries Candy - 1 Pound - Strawberry Gummies - Strawberry Shaped Candy - Strawberry Jelly Candy - Strawberry Gumy Candy
NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 10 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight $99.99
$9999
current price $99.99NY SPICE SHOP Nougat Apricot With Pistachios - 10 Pound - Apricot Pistachio Nougat Bar - Mediterranean Fruit Nougat - Apricot Nougat with Pistachio - Pistachio Apricot Delight
34.3 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Jelly Rings Candy - 1 Pound - Fruit Jelly Rings - Assorted Jelly Candy Rings - Fruit Flavored Jelly Rings - Sugar Coated Jelly Rings - Mixed Fruit Jelly Rings $10.99
$1099
current price $10.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Jelly Rings Candy - 1 Pound - Fruit Jelly Rings - Assorted Jelly Candy Rings - Fruit Flavored Jelly Rings - Sugar Coated Jelly Rings - Mixed Fruit Jelly Rings
83.9 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy - Fruit Candy $13.99
$1399
current price $13.99NY SPICE SHOP Assorted Fruit Slices - Jelly Fruit Slices - 1 Pound - Jelly Slices Candy - Fruit Candy
493.9 out of 5 Stars. 49 reviews
NY Spice Shop Watermelon Sour Balls- 1 Pound - Healthy Snacks - Bulk Candy Balls - Assorted Candy Sour Balls $12.75
$1275
current price $12.75NY Spice Shop Watermelon Sour Balls- 1 Pound - Healthy Snacks - Bulk Candy Balls - Assorted Candy Sour Balls
42.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
NY SPICE SHOP Root Beer Jelly Fruit Slices - 8 Ounce - Jelly Fruit Slices Candy - Jelly Candy $7.49
$749
current price $7.49NY SPICE SHOP Root Beer Jelly Fruit Slices - 8 Ounce - Jelly Fruit Slices Candy - Jelly Candy
493.9 out of 5 Stars. 49 reviews
Other options to consider(129)
Popular in Ny Sweets
Related Products
Red Vines Ropes 12 Ounce Bag (Pack of 48)
Red Vines Ropes 12 Ounce Bag (Pack of 48)$183.17current price $183.17Wiley Wallaby Licorice 24 Ounce Classic Gourmet Soft & Chewy Australian Red Licorice Candy Twists, 3 Pack
Wiley Wallaby Licorice 24 Ounce Classic Gourmet Soft & Chewy Australian Red Licorice Candy Twists, 3 Pack$30.52current price $30.52Red Vines Ropes 12 Ounce Bag (Pack of 16)
Red Vines Ropes 12 Ounce Bag (Pack of 16)$72.92current price $72.92Red Vines Ropes 12 Ounce Bag (Pack of 8)
Red Vines Ropes 12 Ounce Bag (Pack of 8)$42.98current price $42.98Twizzlers Pull-N-Peel Cherry Chewy Licorice Candy - Snacks Size Bulk Twizzlers - Individually Wrapped - 1 Pound (Pack Of 1)
Twizzlers Pull-N-Peel Cherry Chewy Licorice Candy - Snacks Size Bulk Twizzlers - Individually Wrapped - 1 Pound (Pack Of 1)$19.33current price $19.33Super Ropes 34" Individually Wrapped Rope, 2oz (15 Pack), Red Licorice Candy Rope
Super Ropes 34" Individually Wrapped Rope, 2oz (15 Pack), Red Licorice Candy Rope
TWIZZLERS Pull 'n' Peel Licorice Candy, Cherry, 6.1 Ounce (Pack of 16)
TWIZZLERS Pull 'n' Peel Licorice Candy, Cherry, 6.1 Ounce (Pack of 16)$68.80current price $68.80Super Ropes 34" Individually Wrapped Rope, 2oz (60 Pack), Red Licorice Candy Rope
Super Ropes 34" Individually Wrapped Rope, 2oz (60 Pack), Red Licorice Candy Rope
Sour Strawberry Licorice Bits by Its Delish, 1 lb
Sour Strawberry Licorice Bits by Its Delish, 1 lb$18.99current price $18.99YANKEETRADERS Red Strawberry Licorice Laces - 2 lbs.
YANKEETRADERS Red Strawberry Licorice Laces - 2 lbs.$22.95current price $22.95Red Vines Twists Original Red, 5 oz - Case of 24
Red Vines Twists Original Red, 5 oz - Case of 24$63.92current price $63.92TWIZZLERS Licorice Candy, Cherry, 6 Ounce (Pack of 32)
TWIZZLERS Licorice Candy, Cherry, 6 Ounce (Pack of 32)$128.80current price $128.80TWIZZLERS NIBS Cherry Licorice Candy, 6 Ounce, Bag, 12 Count
TWIZZLERS NIBS Cherry Licorice Candy, 6 Ounce, Bag, 12 Count$42.30current price $42.30