All Toys & GamesPre-order toys12+ Years2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAction FiguresAction Figures and PlaysetsAdult Party GamesAll Play VehiclesAll Stuffed Animals & PlushAll VehiclesBoard GamesCard GamesCars & SUV ToysCars, RC, Drones & TrainsCollectible Action FiguresCollectible VehiclesDiecast and Collectible CarsDiecast and Mini VehiclesEngineering ToysFeatured Collectible BrandsFunko Pop Vinyl FiguresGames by AgeHot WheelsLEGONovelty ToysParty GamesPlay Vehicles & Toy CarsPreschool Action Figures and PlaysetsStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsSuper Mario Stuffed AnimalsSuper Mario ToysSurprise ToysToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 5 to 7 YearsToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsValentine's Day PlushValentine's Day Stuffed AnimalsVinyl FiguresVinyl Figures and Bobble Heads
Sort by|
All Toys & GamesPre-order toys12+ Years2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAction FiguresAction Figures and PlaysetsAdult Party GamesAll Play VehiclesAll Stuffed Animals & PlushAll VehiclesBoard GamesCard GamesCars & SUV ToysCars, RC, Drones & TrainsCollectible Action FiguresCollectible VehiclesDiecast and Collectible CarsDiecast and Mini VehiclesEngineering ToysFeatured Collectible BrandsFunko Pop Vinyl FiguresGames by AgeHot WheelsLEGONovelty ToysParty GamesPlay Vehicles & Toy CarsPreschool Action Figures and PlaysetsStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsSuper Mario Stuffed AnimalsSuper Mario ToysSurprise ToysToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 5 to 7 YearsToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsValentine's Day PlushValentine's Day Stuffed AnimalsVinyl FiguresVinyl Figures and Bobble Heads

Guy Shy

Uses item details. Price when purchased online

Little Buddy Toys Nintendo Super Mario All Stars Collection Shy Guy 6" Plush $12.99 Was $16.99 $68.37/ea

Little Buddy Toys Nintendo Super Mario All Stars Collection Shy Guy 6" Plush
current price Now $12.99, Was $16.99
$68.37/ea

Little Buddy Toys Nintendo Super Mario All Stars Collection Shy Guy 6" Plush

4.2 out of 5 Stars. 39 reviews
Everyone 10+

Nintendo 2.5" Limited Articulation Shy Guy Was $14.95

Nintendo 2.5" Limited Articulation Shy Guy

Nintendo 2.5" Limited Articulation Shy Guy

5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews

Sanei Boeki Super Mario Shy Guy FCM-028 Figure Collection 4 Inch Figurine $22.99 $22.99/g

Sanei Boeki Super Mario Shy Guy FCM-028 Figure Collection 4 Inch Figurine
current price $22.99
$22.99/g

Sanei Boeki Super Mario Shy Guy FCM-028 Figure Collection 4 Inch Figurine

World of Nintendo Shy Guy with Propeller Action Figure $32.38

World of Nintendo Shy Guy with Propeller Action Figure
current price $32.38

World of Nintendo Shy Guy with Propeller Action Figure

Nintendo Red Shy Guy Action Figure Set $38.95

Nintendo Red Shy Guy Action Figure Set
current price $38.95

Nintendo Red Shy Guy Action Figure Set

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Nintendo 4" Inch Figure Shy Guy $15.99 Was $19.99

Nintendo 4" Inch Figure Shy Guy
current price Now $15.99, Was $19.99

Nintendo 4" Inch Figure Shy Guy

Everyone 10+

Club Mocchi- Mocchi- Super Mario Shy Guy Junior, Super Soft 6" Plush Toy

Club Mocchi- Mocchi- Super Mario Shy Guy Junior, Super Soft 6" Plush Toy
Available in additional 3 options

Club Mocchi- Mocchi- Super Mario Shy Guy Junior, Super Soft 6" Plush Toy

3.5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Sanei Super Mario All Star Collection AC25 Shy Guy 6.5 Plush $15.00

Sanei Super Mario All Star Collection AC25 Shy Guy 6.5 Plush
current price $15.00

Sanei Super Mario All Star Collection AC25 Shy Guy 6.5 Plush

NINTENDO 4 INCH RED SHY GUY WITH QUESTION BLOCK $14.00

NINTENDO 4 INCH RED SHY GUY WITH QUESTION BLOCK
current price $14.00

NINTENDO 4 INCH RED SHY GUY WITH QUESTION BLOCK

Save with
Walmart Plus

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Yellow Shy Guy Diecast Car [Standard Kart] [No Packaging] $27.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Yellow Shy Guy Diecast Car [Standard Kart] [No Packaging]
current price $27.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Yellow Shy Guy Diecast Car [Standard Kart] [No Packaging]

5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews

World of Nintendo Super Mario Kart 8 Shy Guy Jakks Pacific Figure $15.99

World of Nintendo Super Mario Kart 8 Shy Guy Jakks Pacific Figure
current price $15.99

World of Nintendo Super Mario Kart 8 Shy Guy Jakks Pacific Figure

World of Nintendo Super Mario Yellow Shy Guy Mini Figure $22.88

World of Nintendo Super Mario Yellow Shy Guy Mini Figure
current price $22.88

World of Nintendo Super Mario Yellow Shy Guy Mini Figure

4.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Super Mario Series 2 Shy Guy Vinyl Mini Figure $35.98

Super Mario Series 2 Shy Guy Vinyl Mini Figure
current price $35.98

Super Mario Series 2 Shy Guy Vinyl Mini Figure

Save with
Walmart Plus

Super Mario Villains 12 Inch Plush | Shy Guy $14.99

Super Mario Villains 12 Inch Plush | Shy Guy
current price $14.99

Super Mario Villains 12 Inch Plush | Shy Guy

3.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Club Mocchi- Mocchi- Super Mario Shy Guy Mega 15 inch Plush Stuffed Toy $78.99

Club Mocchi- Mocchi- Super Mario Shy Guy Mega 15 inch Plush Stuffed Toy
current price $78.99

Club Mocchi- Mocchi- Super Mario Shy Guy Mega 15 inch Plush Stuffed Toy

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 13 reviews

Super Mario Red Shy Guy 4 Inch Action Figure with Question Block $29.97

Super Mario Red Shy Guy 4 Inch Action Figure with Question Block
current price $29.97

Super Mario Red Shy Guy 4 Inch Action Figure with Question Block

World of Nintendo Wave 40 Green Shy Guy Action Figure (with POW Block) $16.95 Was $18.98

World of Nintendo Wave 40 Green Shy Guy Action Figure (with POW Block)
current price Now $16.95, Was $18.98

World of Nintendo Wave 40 Green Shy Guy Action Figure (with POW Block)

4.8 out of 5 Stars. 13 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Mattel Hot Wheels Car Mario Kart Nintendo Collection Light Blue ShyGuy $22.27

Mattel Hot Wheels Car Mario Kart Nintendo Collection Light Blue ShyGuy
current price $22.27

Mattel Hot Wheels Car Mario Kart Nintendo Collection Light Blue ShyGuy

World of Nintendo Wave 47 Green Shy Guy Mini Figure $28.74

World of Nintendo Wave 47 Green Shy Guy Mini Figure
current price $28.74

World of Nintendo Wave 47 Green Shy Guy Mini Figure

LEGO Super Mario: Mario Kart Shy Guy & P-Wing 72045 $47.98

LEGO Super Mario: Mario Kart Shy Guy & P-Wing 72045
current price $47.98

LEGO Super Mario: Mario Kart Shy Guy & P-Wing 72045

4.8 out of 5 Stars. 13 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Super Mario Nintendo 4 Inch Action Figure Wave 40 4-Pack, Includes Mario, Dry Bones, Light Blue Yoshi, and Green Shy Guy $49.95

Super Mario Nintendo 4 Inch Action Figure Wave 40 4-Pack, Includes Mario, Dry Bones, Light Blue Yoshi, and Green Shy Guy
current price $49.95

Super Mario Nintendo 4 Inch Action Figure Wave 40 4-Pack, Includes Mario, Dry Bones, Light Blue Yoshi, and Green Shy Guy

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 6-Pack Set, Toad, Princess Peach, Yoshi, Donkey Kong, Koopa Troopa, Shy Guy Gbg25-957h $54.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 6-Pack Set, Toad, Princess Peach, Yoshi, Donkey Kong, Koopa Troopa, Shy Guy Gbg25-957h
current price $54.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 6-Pack Set, Toad, Princess Peach, Yoshi, Donkey Kong, Koopa Troopa, Shy Guy Gbg25-957h

Save with
Walmart Plus

Super Mario All Star Collection Shy Guy Plush

Super Mario All Star Collection Shy Guy Plush

Super Mario All Star Collection Shy Guy Plush

Super Mario 4 inch Green Shy Guy Action Figure with POW Block

Super Mario 4 inch Green Shy Guy Action Figure with POW Block

Super Mario 4 inch Green Shy Guy Action Figure with POW Block

Other options to consider

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Diecast Glider Vehicle Pack, 8 Action Figure Set $54.65 Was $61.00

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Diecast Glider Vehicle Pack, 8 Action Figure Set
current price Now $54.65, Was $61.00

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Diecast Glider Vehicle Pack, 8 Action Figure Set

4 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 8-Pack Set, Nintendo Gaming Collectibles GBG25-957K $89.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 8-Pack Set, Nintendo Gaming Collectibles GBG25-957K
current price $89.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 8-Pack Set, Nintendo Gaming Collectibles GBG25-957K

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Super Mario Series 2 Boo Minifigure (No Packaging) $35.98

Super Mario Series 2 Boo Minifigure (No Packaging)
current price $35.98

Super Mario Series 2 Boo Minifigure (No Packaging)

Funko POP! Animation The Great Grape Ape Vinyl Figure (Super-Sized) $89.99

Funko POP! Animation The Great Grape Ape Vinyl Figure (Super-Sized)
current price $89.99

Funko POP! Animation The Great Grape Ape Vinyl Figure (Super-Sized)

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 8-Pack Set, Nintendo Gaming Collectibles GBG25-957N $99.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 8-Pack Set, Nintendo Gaming Collectibles GBG25-957N
current price $99.99

Hot Wheels Mario Kart Die-Cast Character Cars Collection, 8-Pack Set, Nintendo Gaming Collectibles GBG25-957N

Save with
Walmart Plus

Jakks Pacific Mario Kart 8 World of Nintendo Mini Figure and Vehicle Race Car, Series 1-3 $14.98

Jakks Pacific Mario Kart 8 World of Nintendo Mini Figure and Vehicle Race Car, Series 1-3
current price $14.98

Jakks Pacific Mario Kart 8 World of Nintendo Mini Figure and Vehicle Race Car, Series 1-3

3 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Jakks Pacific Squish-Dee-Lish Series 1 Mystery Pack Soft Foam Action Figures $20.98

Jakks Pacific Squish-Dee-Lish Series 1 Mystery Pack Soft Foam Action Figures
current price $20.98

Jakks Pacific Squish-Dee-Lish Series 1 Mystery Pack Soft Foam Action Figures

5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews

LEGO Super Mario Boomer Bill Barrage Expansion Set 71366 Building Set (132 Pieces) $45.88

LEGO Super Mario Boomer Bill Barrage Expansion Set 71366 Building Set (132 Pieces)
current price $45.88

LEGO Super Mario Boomer Bill Barrage Expansion Set 71366 Building Set (132 Pieces)

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 44 reviews

Mario Party Superstars (Nintendo Switch) $54.99

Mario Party Superstars (Nintendo Switch)
current price $54.99

Mario Party Superstars (Nintendo Switch)

5 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
Everyone

LEGO Super Mario Soda Jungle Maker, Mario Playset, Buildable Nintendo Birthday Gift for Kids, 71434 $40.44 Was $54.99

LEGO Super Mario Soda Jungle Maker, Mario Playset, Buildable Nintendo Birthday Gift for Kids, 71434
current price Now $40.44, Was $54.99

LEGO Super Mario Soda Jungle Maker, Mario Playset, Buildable Nintendo Birthday Gift for Kids, 71434

4.5 out of 5 Stars. 82 reviews
Save with
Walmart Plus

Family Guy Series 3 Jasper Action Figure (Pink Shirt) $46.98

Family Guy Series 3 Jasper Action Figure (Pink Shirt)
current price $46.98

Family Guy Series 3 Jasper Action Figure (Pink Shirt)

Q*pid (Paperback) by Xavier Mayne $14.99

Q*pid (Paperback) by Xavier Mayne
current price $14.99

Q*pid (Paperback) by Xavier Mayne

Save with
Walmart Plus

Popular in Guy Shy

Related Products