All Toys & Games0-12 Months12+ Years12-24 Months2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAll Stuffed Animals & PlushBaby & Toddler ToysCostumes For KidsHalloween Stuffed AnimalsPretend PlaySquishmallows Stuffed AnimalsStuff Animals for BoysStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsWild Republic Stuffed Animals
Sort by|
All Toys & Games0-12 Months12+ Years12-24 Months2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAll Stuffed Animals & PlushBaby & Toddler ToysCostumes For KidsHalloween Stuffed AnimalsPretend PlaySquishmallows Stuffed AnimalsStuff Animals for BoysStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsWild Republic Stuffed Animals
Cryptid Plush(10)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
Real Planet 17" Green Praying Mantis Realistic Stuffed Animal, Bug Insect Creepy Plush Toy & STEM Learning Gift for Birthday Boys & Girls $29.99
Sponsored
$2999
current price $29.99Real Planet 17" Green Praying Mantis Realistic Stuffed Animal, Bug Insect Creepy Plush Toy & STEM Learning Gift for Birthday Boys & Girls
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Save with
Gothic Mothman Plushie - Soft and Cuddly Cryptid Toy for Collectors - A Magical and Unique Plush Toy for Fans of Cryptozoology and Gothic Style
Gothic Mothman Plushie - Soft and Cuddly Cryptid Toy for Collectors - A Magical and Unique Plush Toy for Fans of Cryptozoology and Gothic Style
SIYTUAU Gothic Mothman Plush Monster Figure Cute Stuffed Animal Winged Cryptid Home Decor Unique Curio Decoration Multicolor Plush Fabric Multicolor
SIYTUAU Gothic Mothman Plush Monster Figure Cute Stuffed Animal Winged Cryptid Home Decor Unique Curio Decoration Multicolor Plush Fabric Multicolor
Gaiwos Mothman Plush Toys 14 inches, Creepy Goth Mothman Stuffed Animals, Soft Hugging Mothman Plushies Toys, Scary Gift Idea for Cryptid Lovers & Collectors
Gaiwos Mothman Plush Toys 14 inches, Creepy Goth Mothman Stuffed Animals, Soft Hugging Mothman Plushies Toys, Scary Gift Idea for Cryptid Lovers & Collectors
Cute Flying Monster Plush Toy – Soft Cryptid Stuffed Animal with Wings, Mystery Forest Creature Plush Doll, Funny Fantasy Monster Gift for Kids and Adults
Cute Flying Monster Plush Toy – Soft Cryptid Stuffed Animal with Wings, Mystery Forest Creature Plush Doll, Funny Fantasy Monster Gift for Kids and Adults
Squishmallows Fantasy Squad Dani the Blue Bigfoot Yeti Sasquatch 8" NWT Cryptid $29.99
$2999
current price $29.99Squishmallows Fantasy Squad Dani the Blue Bigfoot Yeti Sasquatch 8" NWT Cryptid
Clearance Gothic Mothman Plush Stuffed Animal, 14 Inch Dark Decor with Bright Red Eyes for Cryptid Lovers Was $15.72
Gothic Mothman Plush Stuffed Animal, 14 Inch Dark Decor with Bright Red Eyes for Cryptid Lovers
Gothic Mothman Plushie, Cryptid Plush Toy, Red Eyed Mothman Stuffed Animal for Dark Home Decor, 14 Inch Large Soft Plush Doll, Perfect Gift for Cryptid Lovers and Plush Collectors Was $11.12
Gothic Mothman Plushie, Cryptid Plush Toy, Red Eyed Mothman Stuffed Animal for Dark Home Decor, 14 Inch Large Soft Plush Doll, Perfect Gift for Cryptid Lovers and Plush Collectors
Gothic Mothman Plushie Stuffed Toy With Bright Red Eyes Magical Home Decor Cryptid Collector Gift
Gothic Mothman Plushie Stuffed Toy With Bright Red Eyes Magical Home Decor Cryptid Collector Gift
Squishmallows Select Series Ennis the Pink Loch Ness Monster 5" NWT Cryptid
Squishmallows Select Series Ennis the Pink Loch Ness Monster 5" NWT Cryptid
Other options to consider(82)
Aurora - Medium Green Mythical Creatures - 9" Gribble The Goblin - Enchanting Stuffed Animal
4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsAurora - Medium Green Mythical Creatures - 9" Gribble The Goblin - Enchanting Stuffed Animal
94.7 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviews
Cryptids USA Playset - 5 Piece Box Set $12.95
$1295
current price $12.95Cryptids USA Playset - 5 Piece Box Set
Monster Plush Toy Single Piece, Soft Stuffed Creature Doll, Funny Character Plush Decor
Monster Plush Toy Single Piece, Soft Stuffed Creature Doll, Funny Character Plush Decor
Forest Mythical Creature Sasquatch Bigfoot Cryptid Ape Standing Figurine 9"H $29.99
$2999
current price $29.99Forest Mythical Creature Sasquatch Bigfoot Cryptid Ape Standing Figurine 9"H
Dark style plush toys mythical creatures dolls From $28.99
7 options
Available in additional 7 optionsFrom$2899
Dark style plush toys mythical creatures dolls
MetaZoo Trading Card Game Cryptid Nation Nightfall Spellbook (1st Edition) $28.00
$2800
current price $28.00MetaZoo Trading Card Game Cryptid Nation Nightfall Spellbook (1st Edition)
23.5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Save with
Purple Monster Plush Toy Soft Scary-Cute Stuffed Animal with Big Smile $14.52
$1452
current price $14.52Purple Monster Plush Toy Soft Scary-Cute Stuffed Animal with Big Smile
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Kidrobot City Cryptid 3" Dunny Vinyl Figure - Sasquatch $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99Kidrobot City Cryptid 3" Dunny Vinyl Figure - Sasquatch
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
CthulhuCraft Mythical Creatures Series CthulhuCraft Octopus Monster Plush Doll Children's Doll Toy
CthulhuCraft Mythical Creatures Series CthulhuCraft Octopus Monster Plush Doll Children's Doll Toy
Twisted Cryptids $19.98
$1998
current price $19.98Twisted Cryptids
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Save with
11.4 Inches Singing Monster Stuffed Plush-Sing Monster Toy (Little Green Monster) $26.00
$2600
current price $26.0011.4 Inches Singing Monster Stuffed Plush-Sing Monster Toy (Little Green Monster)
The Freak Circus Stuffed Plush Pierrot Luxury Plush 3.93 Inch Collectible Game Character Stuffed Toy Collectible Toys for Fan From $13.55
From$1355
The Freak Circus Stuffed Plush Pierrot Luxury Plush 3.93 Inch Collectible Game Character Stuffed Toy Collectible Toys for Fan
Mythical Fantasy Legend Black Dark Unicorn Hell Steed Luxe Soft Plush Toy Doll $24.99
$2499
current price $24.99Mythical Fantasy Legend Black Dark Unicorn Hell Steed Luxe Soft Plush Toy Doll
34 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews
Bigfoot, Sasquatch, Wild Man, Yeti, Statue, Cryptid, Very Realistic Rubber Figure, Model, Educational, Animal, Hand Painted, Kids, Educational, Gift, 5" CH297 BB180 $9.59
$959
current price $9.59Bigfoot, Sasquatch, Wild Man, Yeti, Statue, Cryptid, Very Realistic Rubber Figure, Model, Educational, Animal, Hand Painted, Kids, Educational, Gift, 5" CH297 BB180
Frankie the Monster 8 inch Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Monster Toy Gift Collectible Plush $16.88
$1688
current price $16.88Frankie the Monster 8 inch Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Monster Toy Gift Collectible Plush
Apricot Lamb Timid Rat Plush Toy for Kids 5.1 Inches $19.99
$1999
current price $19.99Apricot Lamb Timid Rat Plush Toy for Kids 5.1 Inches
Save with
Clearance LYINGF Dragon Plush Sofa Cuddle Companion - Mythical Creature Fantasy Decor Plush Toy for Boys/Girls, Huggable Storytime Friend for Bedroom Decoration From $13.25
From$1325
LYINGF Dragon Plush Sofa Cuddle Companion - Mythical Creature Fantasy Decor Plush Toy for Boys/Girls, Huggable Storytime Friend for Bedroom Decoration
Mothman Action Figure - 3D Printed Model Collectible Cryptid Figurine - Made in WV USA $15.90
$1590
current price $15.90Mothman Action Figure - 3D Printed Model Collectible Cryptid Figurine - Made in WV USA
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Kwyptids Mothman (Moffy) Previews Exclusive 8In Plush $26.70
$2670
current price $26.70Kwyptids Mothman (Moffy) Previews Exclusive 8In Plush
Surprise Mythical Plush Blind Box Plush, inspired by Classic Chinese Tales, Huggable Plush Baby Doll, Mini Plush Animals, detailed Plush Figure toys, Blind Box Figures, Baby Plush
Surprise Mythical Plush Blind Box Plush, inspired by Classic Chinese Tales, Huggable Plush Baby Doll, Mini Plush Animals, detailed Plush Figure toys, Blind Box Figures, Baby Plush
MetaZoo Cryptid Nation Pukwudgie Chieftain Tribal Theme Deck (1st Edition) $19.95 Was $28.95
Now$1995
current price Now $19.95, Was $28.95$28.95
MetaZoo Cryptid Nation Pukwudgie Chieftain Tribal Theme Deck (1st Edition)
FanWraps Kwyptid Cthulhu Cthulius Previews Exclusive Plush Toy 1-Count 8 Inch $12.96
$1296
current price $12.96FanWraps Kwyptid Cthulhu Cthulius Previews Exclusive Plush Toy 1-Count 8 Inch
Furrybones Blue Enchanted Unicorn Unie Cute Skeleton Monster Plush Doll Toy Collectible $18.99
$1899
current price $18.99Furrybones Blue Enchanted Unicorn Unie Cute Skeleton Monster Plush Doll Toy Collectible
Skeleton Bear Stuffed Animals,Skeleton Bear Plush Toy,Creepy Goth Bear Stuffed Cr*azy Bear Dolls,G*rumpy Bones Bear Plush Toy Gift From $14.31
From$1431
Skeleton Bear Stuffed Animals,Skeleton Bear Plush Toy,Creepy Goth Bear Stuffed Cr*azy Bear Dolls,G*rumpy Bones Bear Plush Toy Gift
Luna Purple Winged Unicorn Plush 16 Inch, Soft Magical Fantasy Creature, Imaginative Plush Toy $22.63
$2263
current price $22.63Luna Purple Winged Unicorn Plush 16 Inch, Soft Magical Fantasy Creature, Imaginative Plush Toy
PuffPurrs Lifelike White Moth Plush Toy, Realistic White Hairy Moth Teddy Stuffed Animal, Cute Hyphantria Cunea Unique Toy Gift, 33 Cm/13 In From $27.99
From$2799
PuffPurrs Lifelike White Moth Plush Toy, Realistic White Hairy Moth Teddy Stuffed Animal, Cute Hyphantria Cunea Unique Toy Gift, 33 Cm/13 In
Ebros Fantasy Mythical Cosmic Sea Monster Cthulhu Kraken Luxe Soft Plush Toy $24.99
$2499
current price $24.99Ebros Fantasy Mythical Cosmic Sea Monster Cthulhu Kraken Luxe Soft Plush Toy
Cryptids of the World - Lochness / Made to Order / Design by Big Bear Designs / Cotton
5 options
Available in additional 5 optionsCryptids of the World - Lochness / Made to Order / Design by Big Bear Designs / Cotton
Silent Hill: Red Pyramid Thing Plushie $40.00
$4000
current price $40.00Silent Hill: Red Pyramid Thing Plushie
Dragon Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Soft Mythical Creature Doll for Fans Home Decor Birthday Gift for Teens Adults Teal Orange Dragon Figure
Dragon Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Soft Mythical Creature Doll for Fans Home Decor Birthday Gift for Teens Adults Teal Orange Dragon Figure
Toy Vault Cthulhu Hand Puppet, Plush Stuffed H.P. Lovecraft Cthulhu Figure with Tentacles $22.92 $22.92/count
$2292
current price $22.92$22.92/count
Toy Vault Cthulhu Hand Puppet, Plush Stuffed H.P. Lovecraft Cthulhu Figure with Tentacles
Popular in Cryptid Plush Toys Collection Featuring Unique Mythical Creatures
Related Products
99 Nights in The Forest Deer Plush Soft Stuffed Animal Doll Owl Plush Toy for Survive Game Fans
99 Nights in The Forest Deer Plush Soft Stuffed Animal Doll Owl Plush Toy for Survive Game Fans$9.99current price $9.99Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Brown Toro - Adorable Stuffed Animal
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Brown Toro - Adorable Stuffed Animal$9.76current price $9.76Cuddle Up With Our Soft Toy: Adorable Stuffed Animal For Kids And Adults For Birthdays And Holidays!
Cuddle Up With Our Soft Toy: Adorable Stuffed Animal For Kids And Adults For Birthdays And Holidays!$11.15current price $11.15Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Toro - Adorable Stuffed Animal
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Toro - Adorable Stuffed Animal$9.99current price $9.99Toy Soft Animal Stuffed Toy for All Ages Durable Cute and Huggable Design for Kids and Adults
Toy Soft Animal Stuffed Toy for All Ages Durable Cute and Huggable Design for Kids and Adults$7.67current price $7.67Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie - Durable and Huggable Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults - for All Ages and Ideal
Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie - Durable and Huggable Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults - for All Ages and Ideal$27.45current price $27.45Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults Durable Huggable Ideal for All Ages for Indoor and Outdoor
Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults Durable Huggable Ideal for All Ages for Indoor and Outdoor$22.23current price $22.23Salamander Plush Doll, Cute Cartoon Pillow, Soft Stuffed Animal, Kids Toy, Decorative Accent, Huggable Companion, Collectible Plushie
Salamander Plush Doll, Cute Cartoon Pillow, Soft Stuffed Animal, Kids Toy, Decorative Accent, Huggable Companion, Collectible Plushie
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Cheki Chimp - Adorable Stuffed Animal
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Cheki Chimp - Adorable Stuffed Animal$11.14current price $11.14Soft Cuddle Toy – Adorable for Kids and Adults for Birthdays or Holidays
Soft Cuddle Toy – Adorable for Kids and Adults for Birthdays or Holidays$20.52current price $20.52
