All Toys & Games0-12 Months12+ Years12-24 Months2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAll Stuffed Animals & PlushBaby & Toddler ToysCostumes For KidsHalloween Stuffed AnimalsPretend PlaySquishmallows Stuffed AnimalsStuff Animals for BoysStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsWild Republic Stuffed Animals
Sort by|
All Toys & Games0-12 Months12+ Years12-24 Months2 to 4 Years5 to 7 Years8 to 11 YearsAll Stuffed Animals & PlushBaby & Toddler ToysCostumes For KidsHalloween Stuffed AnimalsPretend PlaySquishmallows Stuffed AnimalsStuff Animals for BoysStuffed Animals & Plush ToysStuffed Animals for BoysStuffed Animals for GirlsToys for AdultsToys for Kids 12 Years & UpToys for Kids 8 to 11 YearsWild Republic Stuffed Animals
Cryptid Plush(11)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
Apricot Lamb Timid Rat Plush Toy for Kids 5.1 Inches $19.99
Sponsored
$1999
current price $19.99Apricot Lamb Timid Rat Plush Toy for Kids 5.1 Inches
Gothic Mothman Plushie, Cryptid Plush Toy, Red Eyed Mothman Stuffed Animal for Dark Home Decor, 14 Inch Large Soft Plush Doll, Perfect Gift for Cryptid Lovers and Plush Collectors $9.90
$990
current price $9.90Gothic Mothman Plushie, Cryptid Plush Toy, Red Eyed Mothman Stuffed Animal for Dark Home Decor, 14 Inch Large Soft Plush Doll, Perfect Gift for Cryptid Lovers and Plush Collectors
VVQ Gothic Mothman Plushie 14 Inch, Cryptid Stuffed Animal with Bright Red Eyes, Mothman Plush for Dark Home Decor, Plushies for Bed Shelf Dresser for Cryptid Lovers $21.99
$2199
current price $21.99VVQ Gothic Mothman Plushie 14 Inch, Cryptid Stuffed Animal with Bright Red Eyes, Mothman Plush for Dark Home Decor, Plushies for Bed Shelf Dresser for Cryptid Lovers
Mothman Plush Toy Mysterious Cryptid Stuffed Animal Soft Folklore Legend Doll Black Cryptozoology Plushie with Red Eyes Halloween Home Decor Birthday Gifts $21.99
$2199
current price $21.99Mothman Plush Toy Mysterious Cryptid Stuffed Animal Soft Folklore Legend Doll Black Cryptozoology Plushie with Red Eyes Halloween Home Decor Birthday Gifts
Cute Flying Monster Plush Toy – Soft Cryptid Stuffed Animal with Wings, Mystery Forest Creature Plush Doll, Funny Fantasy Monster Gift for Kids and Adults
Cute Flying Monster Plush Toy – Soft Cryptid Stuffed Animal with Wings, Mystery Forest Creature Plush Doll, Funny Fantasy Monster Gift for Kids and Adults
Gothic Mothman Plush Stuffed Animal, 14 Inch Dark Decor with Bright Red Eyes for Cryptid Lovers
Gothic Mothman Plush Stuffed Animal, 14 Inch Dark Decor with Bright Red Eyes for Cryptid Lovers
Gothic Mothman Plushie Stuffed Animal, Usupdd Cryptid Monster Plush Toy for Dark Home Decor, 14 Inch Soft Huggable Mothman Doll for Bed Shelf Dresser $24.99
$2499
current price $24.99Gothic Mothman Plushie Stuffed Animal, Usupdd Cryptid Monster Plush Toy for Dark Home Decor, 14 Inch Soft Huggable Mothman Doll for Bed Shelf Dresser
Gothic Mothman Plushie Stuffed Toy With Bright Red Eyes Magical Home Decor Cryptid Collector Gift
Gothic Mothman Plushie Stuffed Toy With Bright Red Eyes Magical Home Decor Cryptid Collector Gift
Clearance Gothic Mothman Plushie - Soft and Cuddly Cryptid Toy for Collectors - A Magical and Unique Plush Toy for Fans of Cryptozoology and Gothic Style Was $23.99
Gothic Mothman Plushie - Soft and Cuddly Cryptid Toy for Collectors - A Magical and Unique Plush Toy for Fans of Cryptozoology and Gothic Style
Squishmallows Fantasy Squad Dani the Blue Bigfoot Yeti Sasquatch 8" NWT Cryptid
Squishmallows Fantasy Squad Dani the Blue Bigfoot Yeti Sasquatch 8" NWT Cryptid
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Squishmallows Select Series Ennis the Pink Loch Ness Monster 5" NWT Cryptid
Squishmallows Select Series Ennis the Pink Loch Ness Monster 5" NWT Cryptid
Other options to consider(85)
Jellycat Rose Dragon Stuffed Animal, Large 19.5 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Classic Children's Gift $49.99
$4999
current price $49.99Jellycat Rose Dragon Stuffed Animal, Large 19.5 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Classic Children's Gift
Twisted Cryptids $19.98
$1998
current price $19.98Twisted Cryptids
35 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews
Forest Mythical Creature Sasquatch Bigfoot Cryptid Ape Standing Figurine 9"H $29.99
$2999
current price $29.99Forest Mythical Creature Sasquatch Bigfoot Cryptid Ape Standing Figurine 9"H
Clearance Children's Plush Toys Emotionmonster The Color Monster Cartoon Plush Toy-Single Blue $1.99 Was $2.99
Now$199
current price Now $1.99, Was $2.99$2.99
Children's Plush Toys Emotionmonster The Color Monster Cartoon Plush Toy-Single Blue
Jellycat Rose Dragon Stuffed Animal, Little 12 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Classic Children's Gift $44.99
$4499
current price $44.99Jellycat Rose Dragon Stuffed Animal, Little 12 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Classic Children's Gift
Top Secret Toys GigaPets Virtual Pet, Cryptids, Orange, Product Width 2 Inches
Top Secret Toys GigaPets Virtual Pet, Cryptids, Orange, Product Width 2 Inches
64.2 out of 5 Stars. 6 reviews
Apricot Lamb Timid Rat Plush Toy for Kids 5.1 Inches $19.99
$1999
current price $19.99Apricot Lamb Timid Rat Plush Toy for Kids 5.1 Inches
Clearance Children's Plush Toys Emotionmonster The Color Monster Cartoon Plush Toy-Single Yellow $2.99 Was $3.99
Now$299
current price Now $2.99, Was $3.99$3.99
Children's Plush Toys Emotionmonster The Color Monster Cartoon Plush Toy-Single Yellow
Jellycat Malachy Dragon Stuffed Animal, 19.7 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Classic Children's Gift $49.99
$4999
current price $49.99Jellycat Malachy Dragon Stuffed Animal, 19.7 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Classic Children's Gift
Modiphius Entertainment: Fallout: Miniatures - Cryptids - Sheepsquatch - Resin Figure, Unpainted-Unassembled, Tabletop RPG, Wilds Of Appalachia Wave
Modiphius Entertainment: Fallout: Miniatures - Cryptids - Sheepsquatch - Resin Figure, Unpainted-Unassembled, Tabletop RPG, Wilds Of Appalachia Wave
Fridja Halloween Gothic Mothman Plush Doll, Medieval Vintage Evil Goth Moth Figure Plushies Stuffed Dolls Toys, Cool Decorations for Home Bedroom Decor, Birthday for Gothic Lovers (Black)
Fridja Halloween Gothic Mothman Plush Doll, Medieval Vintage Evil Goth Moth Figure Plushies Stuffed Dolls Toys, Cool Decorations for Home Bedroom Decor, Birthday for Gothic Lovers (Black)
233.6 out of 5 Stars. 23 reviews
Frankie the Monster 8 inch Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Monster Toy Gift Collectible Plush $16.73
$1673
current price $16.73Frankie the Monster 8 inch Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Monster Toy Gift Collectible Plush
Jellycat Lavender Dragon Stuffed Animal, Large 19.5 inches | Mythical Plush Toy | Classic Children's Gift $49.99
$4999
current price $49.99Jellycat Lavender Dragon Stuffed Animal, Large 19.5 inches | Mythical Plush Toy | Classic Children's Gift
Bigfoot, Sasquatch, Wild Man, Yeti, Statue, Cryptid, Very Realistic Rubber Figure, Model, Educational, Animal, Hand Painted, Kids, Educational, Gift, 5" CH297 BB180 $9.59
$959
current price $9.59Bigfoot, Sasquatch, Wild Man, Yeti, Statue, Cryptid, Very Realistic Rubber Figure, Model, Educational, Animal, Hand Painted, Kids, Educational, Gift, 5" CH297 BB180
Labyrinth The Worm 14-Inch Character Plush Toy | Toynk Exclusive $39.99
$3999
current price $39.99Labyrinth The Worm 14-Inch Character Plush Toy | Toynk Exclusive
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Surprise Mythical Plush Blind Box Plush, inspired by Classic Chinese Tales, Huggable Plush Baby Doll, Mini Plush Animals, detailed Plush Figure toys, Blind Box Figures, Baby Plush
Surprise Mythical Plush Blind Box Plush, inspired by Classic Chinese Tales, Huggable Plush Baby Doll, Mini Plush Animals, detailed Plush Figure toys, Blind Box Figures, Baby Plush
Mothman Action Figure - 3D Printed Model Collectible Cryptid Figurine - Made in WV USA $15.90
$1590
current price $15.90Mothman Action Figure - 3D Printed Model Collectible Cryptid Figurine - Made in WV USA
25 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Giant Microbes Plush - C. Diff Clostridioides Difficile $12.87
$1287
current price $12.87Giant Microbes Plush - C. Diff Clostridioides Difficile
Mythical Fantasy Legend Black Dark Unicorn Hell Steed Luxe Soft Plush Toy Doll $24.98
$2498
current price $24.98Mythical Fantasy Legend Black Dark Unicorn Hell Steed Luxe Soft Plush Toy Doll
34 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviews
Cryptid Confluence Monster Puzzle | 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle $17.99
$1799
current price $17.99Cryptid Confluence Monster Puzzle | 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
Wild Republic Artist Collection, Bigfoot, Gift for Kids, 15 inches, Plush Toy, Fill is Spun Recycled Water Bottles. $31.58
$3158
current price $31.58Wild Republic Artist Collection, Bigfoot, Gift for Kids, 15 inches, Plush Toy, Fill is Spun Recycled Water Bottles.
144.7 out of 5 Stars. 14 reviews
CthulhuCraft Mythical Creatures Series Plush Toys Keslow Commune Octopus Monster Doll
CthulhuCraft Mythical Creatures Series Plush Toys Keslow Commune Octopus Monster Doll
Cryptids USA Playset - 5 Piece Box Set
Cryptids USA Playset - 5 Piece Box Set
20cm Gothic Skull Sloth Plush Ornament, Spooky Halloween Skeleton Stuffed Decor Doll, Soft Fluffy Character Toy For Halloween Indoor Scene Layout & Holiday Present Giving From $7.99
From$799
20cm Gothic Skull Sloth Plush Ornament, Spooky Halloween Skeleton Stuffed Decor Doll, Soft Fluffy Character Toy For Halloween Indoor Scene Layout & Holiday Present Giving
MetaZoo Cryptid Nation Pukwudgie Chieftain Tribal Theme Deck (1st Edition) $24.95
$2495
current price $24.95MetaZoo Cryptid Nation Pukwudgie Chieftain Tribal Theme Deck (1st Edition)
DevSeries chillthrill709 Collector Plush - 8 inch Polyester Plush with Exclusive Virtual Item Code $24.99
$2499
current price $24.99DevSeries chillthrill709 Collector Plush - 8 inch Polyester Plush with Exclusive Virtual Item Code
Jellycat Opalite Dragon Stuffed Animal, Medium 19.7 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Limited Edition Children's Gift $49.99
$4999
current price $49.99Jellycat Opalite Dragon Stuffed Animal, Medium 19.7 inches - Mythical Plush Toy - Limited Edition Children's Gift
Modiphius Entertainment: Fallout: Miniatures - Cryptids - Snallygasters - 2 Resin Figures, Unpainted & Unassembled, RPG, Wilds Of Appalachia, Licensed $40.11
$4011
current price $40.11Modiphius Entertainment: Fallout: Miniatures - Cryptids - Snallygasters - 2 Resin Figures, Unpainted & Unassembled, RPG, Wilds Of Appalachia, Licensed
Popular in Cryptid Plush Toys Collection Featuring Unique Mythical Creatures
Related Products
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Brown Toro - Adorable Stuffed Animal
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Brown Toro - Adorable Stuffed Animal$10.38current price $10.38Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie - Durable and Huggable Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults - for All Ages and Ideal
Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie - Durable and Huggable Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults - for All Ages and Ideal$27.93current price $27.93Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Cheki Chimp - Adorable Stuffed Animal
Aurora - Small Brown Mini Flopsie - 8" Cheki Chimp - Adorable Stuffed Animal$9.89current price $9.89Manhattan Kids Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Toy | Zack the Zebra | Cuddly Zebra Plush Doll | Cute Gift for Kids & Babies | Huggable Nursery Decor | Adorable Baby Shower Present
Manhattan Kids Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Toy | Zack the Zebra | Cuddly Zebra Plush Doll | Cute Gift for Kids & Babies | Huggable Nursery Decor | Adorable Baby Shower Present$12.99current price $12.99Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults Durable Huggable Ideal for All Ages for Indoor and Outdoor
Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Plushie Cute Animal Toy for Kids and Adults Durable Huggable Ideal for All Ages for Indoor and Outdoor$23.49current price $23.49Toy Soft Animal Stuffed Toy for All Ages Durable Cute and Huggable Design for Kids and Adults
Toy Soft Animal Stuffed Toy for All Ages Durable Cute and Huggable Design for Kids and Adults$6.70current price $6.70Salamander Plush Doll, Cute Cartoon Pillow, Soft Stuffed Animal, Kids Toy, Decorative Accent, Huggable Companion, Collectible Plushie
Salamander Plush Doll, Cute Cartoon Pillow, Soft Stuffed Animal, Kids Toy, Decorative Accent, Huggable Companion, Collectible Plushie$5.13current price $5.13
