Emergency prep petsFreeze Dried Pet FoodNew Pet EssentialsAll LocalFinds PetsCat BirthdayCat FoodCat Health and WellnessCat ToysCat TreatsCat Vitamins and SupplementsDental Cat TreatsDog EnrichmentDog FoodDog Health and WellnessDog ToysDog TreatsDog Vitamins and SupplementsFancy FeastHill's Science DietI and Love and You Pet FoodIamsInstinctKitten SuppliesPet Hip & Joint SupplementsPet Vitamins and SupplementsPremium Cat NutritionPremium Dry Cat FoodPremium Pet NutritionPremium Wet Cat FoodRoyal CaninSheba Cat FoodSmartyKatStella and Chewy'sWeruva
Sort by|
Emergency prep petsFreeze Dried Pet FoodNew Pet EssentialsAll LocalFinds PetsCat BirthdayCat FoodCat Health and WellnessCat ToysCat TreatsCat Vitamins and SupplementsDental Cat TreatsDog EnrichmentDog FoodDog Health and WellnessDog ToysDog TreatsDog Vitamins and SupplementsFancy FeastHill's Science DietI and Love and You Pet FoodIamsInstinctKitten SuppliesPet Hip & Joint SupplementsPet Vitamins and SupplementsPremium Cat NutritionPremium Dry Cat FoodPremium Pet NutritionPremium Wet Cat FoodRoyal CaninSheba Cat FoodSmartyKatStella and Chewy'sWeruva
Cat Picky Eater(291)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
NATOO Cat Food Topper for Picky Eaters & Healthy Soft Cat Treat (Tuna & Brown Rice in Broth), Wet Cat Food, Gravy Cat Food, High Protein & Limited Ingredient Cat & Kitten Food, 2.4 oz (Case of 20) From $29.99

Sponsored
From$2999
NATOO Cat Food Topper for Picky Eaters & Healthy Soft Cat Treat (Tuna & Brown Rice in Broth), Wet Cat Food, Gravy Cat Food, High Protein & Limited Ingredient Cat & Kitten Food, 2.4 oz (Case of 20)
4.5 out of 5 stars
Beefeaters Lickable Wet Cat Treats Variety Pack, Creamy Squeezable Puree - Salmon Tuna Chicken for Hydration & Training, Grain Free, Taurine Enriched, High Moisture, 0.53 Ounces Tube, 120 Tubes Total From $20.99

Sponsored
From$2099
Beefeaters Lickable Wet Cat Treats Variety Pack, Creamy Squeezable Puree - Salmon Tuna Chicken for Hydration & Training, Grain Free, Taurine Enriched, High Moisture, 0.53 Ounces Tube, 120 Tubes Total
4.5 out of 5 stars
Beefeaters Tuna Lickable Cat Treats with Lobster and Krill Oil, 3 Pack Puree Sachets, 0.53 oz Each, Antioxidant Support, Grain Free Cat Food Topper, No Sugar Added, Taurine, Vitamin E, No Corn $19.99

Sponsored
$1999
current price $19.99Beefeaters Tuna Lickable Cat Treats with Lobster and Krill Oil, 3 Pack Puree Sachets, 0.53 oz Each, Antioxidant Support, Grain Free Cat Food Topper, No Sugar Added, Taurine, Vitamin E, No Corn
Cat Grass Sticks for Teeth Cleaning & Hairball Removal, Edible Cat Treats, Chicken Flavor 60 g From $9.99

Sponsored
From$999
Cat Grass Sticks for Teeth Cleaning & Hairball Removal, Edible Cat Treats, Chicken Flavor 60 g
3.8 out of 5 stars
WHISKAS PURRFECTLY Chicken Variety Pack Wet Cat Food 3 Ounces (10 Count) $10.83 36.1 ¢/oz

$1083
current price $10.8336.1 ¢/oz
WHISKAS PURRFECTLY Chicken Variety Pack Wet Cat Food 3 Ounces (10 Count)
4.6 out of 5 stars
Whisker Lickin's Cat Treats, Crunchy and Yummy Chicken and Seafood Flavors 6.5 oz. Pouch

Whisker Lickin's Cat Treats, Crunchy and Yummy Chicken and Seafood Flavors 6.5 oz. Pouch
4.9 out of 5 stars
INABA Twin-Packs for Cats, Chicken/Gelée Topper, 1.4 oz/srv, 16 srvs, Chicken in Chicken Broth

3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsINABA Twin-Packs for Cats, Chicken/Gelée Topper, 1.4 oz/srv, 16 srvs, Chicken in Chicken Broth
4.6 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Stix Gelee Wet Cat Treats, Tuna, 3 oz. Pouch From $5.39

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$539
Tiki Cat Stix Gelee Wet Cat Treats, Tuna, 3 oz. Pouch
4.3 out of 5 stars
Royal Canin Wet Cat Food Slices in Gravy Variety Pack 6 Count with Toy, MerlinsMart Zine $31.97

$3197
current price $31.97Royal Canin Wet Cat Food Slices in Gravy Variety Pack 6 Count with Toy, MerlinsMart Zine
4.4 out of 5 stars
Cat Grass For Indoor Cats, Cat Grass Treats, Cat Food For Training Rewards Treats, Cat Chew Toys Natural Hairball Support & Digestive Aid, Healthy Crunchy Snacks for Feline Health $13.99

$1399
current price $13.99Cat Grass For Indoor Cats, Cat Grass Treats, Cat Food For Training Rewards Treats, Cat Chew Toys Natural Hairball Support & Digestive Aid, Healthy Crunchy Snacks for Feline Health
3.6 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Friends Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Pumpkin, 2.5 oz. Pouch From $1.52

Sponsored
From$152
Tiki Cat Friends Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Pumpkin, 2.5 oz. Pouch
4.7 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Beef, 2.8 oz. Pouch $2.18 Was $3.83 77.9 ¢/oz

Sponsored
Now$218
current price Now $2.18, Was $3.83$3.83
77.9 ¢/oz
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Beef, 2.8 oz. Pouch
Reveal Pet Food Natural Wet Cat Food, Fish & Chicken in Broth Variety Pack, 12 x 2.47oz Pouches $15.97 53.9 ¢/oz

$1597
current price $15.9753.9 ¢/oz
Reveal Pet Food Natural Wet Cat Food, Fish & Chicken in Broth Variety Pack, 12 x 2.47oz Pouches
4.5 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Baby Variety Pack Wet Cat Food 2.4 oz. Count of 12 $22.68

$2268
current price $22.68Tiki Cat Baby Variety Pack Wet Cat Food 2.4 oz. Count of 12
3.7 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Friends Wet Cat Food Chicken Variety Pack, 2.5 oz. Pouch (12 Pack)

Tiki Cat Friends Wet Cat Food Chicken Variety Pack, 2.5 oz. Pouch (12 Pack)
4.1 out of 5 stars
Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Minnows Cat Treats | Single Ingredient | Grain Free, Healthy Treats for Cats, 0.5 oz bag $7.99

$799
current price $7.99Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Minnows Cat Treats | Single Ingredient | Grain Free, Healthy Treats for Cats, 0.5 oz bag
4.5 out of 5 stars
In 50+ people's carts, Cat Grass Treats, Cat Grass For Indoor Cats, Cat Food For Training Rewards Treats, Cat Chew Toys $12.59 Was $29.99
In 50+ people's carts

Now$1259
current price Now $12.59, Was $29.99$29.99
Cat Grass Treats, Cat Grass For Indoor Cats, Cat Food For Training Rewards Treats, Cat Chew Toys
4.3 out of 5 stars
Reduced price, Cat Variety Pack Feline Favorites, Wet Canned Food, Variety 12 Pack $16.47 Was $21.97
Reduced price

Now$1647
current price Now $16.47, Was $21.97$21.97
Cat Variety Pack Feline Favorites, Wet Canned Food, Variety 12 Pack
4.7 out of 5 stars
Made by Nacho Dry Cat Kibble, Infused with Bone Broth for Hydration, Cage-Free Chicken & Pumpkin Recipe, High Protein and Grain-Friendly Premium Cat Food, Limited Ingredients, 3lb Bag From $13.97

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$1397
Made by Nacho Dry Cat Kibble, Infused with Bone Broth for Hydration, Cage-Free Chicken & Pumpkin Recipe, High Protein and Grain-Friendly Premium Cat Food, Limited Ingredients, 3lb Bag
4.7 out of 5 stars
PAWUP Freeze Dried Cat Treats, Single Ingredient Whole Shrimp with Omega-3 for Cats & Dogs All Life Stages, 1.5 oz Bag From $13.99

5 options
Available in additional 5 optionsFrom$1399
PAWUP Freeze Dried Cat Treats, Single Ingredient Whole Shrimp with Omega-3 for Cats & Dogs All Life Stages, 1.5 oz Bag
3.9 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Pate Wet Cat Food, Rabbit & Chicken Liver, 3 oz. Can From $2.18

Sponsored
From$218
Tiki Cat After Dark Pate Wet Cat Food, Rabbit & Chicken Liver, 3 oz. Can
4.2 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Gelee Wet Cat Food, Variety Pack, 2.8 oz. Pouch (12 Count) $24.97 74.3 ¢/oz

Sponsored
$2497
current price $24.9774.3 ¢/oz
Tiki Cat Gelee Wet Cat Food, Variety Pack, 2.8 oz. Pouch (12 Count)
3 out of 5 stars
Choolip Vita Stick Variety Pack Lickable Treats for Cats & Dogs, 3.7 oz (7 Sticks) From $10.49

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$1049
Choolip Vita Stick Variety Pack Lickable Treats for Cats & Dogs, 3.7 oz (7 Sticks)
4.8 out of 5 stars
LOVE, NALA - Single Protein - Natural Adult Cat Wet Food - Grain Free, Non-GMO, Prebiotic Fiber, Vitamins, Minerals (12 cans, Variety Pack) $19.49

$1949
current price $19.49LOVE, NALA - Single Protein - Natural Adult Cat Wet Food - Grain Free, Non-GMO, Prebiotic Fiber, Vitamins, Minerals (12 cans, Variety Pack)
3.9 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Friends Stix Chicken & Pumpkin Flavor, 1.6 oz. Pouch (4 Stix) From $3.42

5 options
Available in additional 5 optionsFrom$342
Tiki Cat Friends Stix Chicken & Pumpkin Flavor, 1.6 oz. Pouch (4 Stix)
4.7 out of 5 stars
Cat Hariball Treatment Treats, Hairball Support Chews for Cats & Kittens, Chicken Flavor, 3.7oz/100g (Approx 30 Day Supply) From $8.99

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$899
Cat Hariball Treatment Treats, Hairball Support Chews for Cats & Kittens, Chicken Flavor, 3.7oz/100g (Approx 30 Day Supply)
5 out of 5 stars
Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Cat Treats | Chicken Breast, Single Ingredient | Grain Free, Healthy Treats for Cats, 2.1 oz bag From $8.99

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$899
Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Cat Treats | Chicken Breast, Single Ingredient | Grain Free, Healthy Treats for Cats, 2.1 oz bag
4.4 out of 5 stars
PureBites Tuna & Salmon Mixers for Cats, Only 3 Ingredients, Case of 12

3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsPureBites Tuna & Salmon Mixers for Cats, Only 3 Ingredients, Case of 12
4.8 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Variety Pack, 2.8 oz. Pouch (12 Count) From $26.11

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$2611
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Variety Pack, 2.8 oz. Pouch (12 Count)
5 out of 5 stars
Bone Broth Powder for Dogs and Cats - Dog & Cat Food Topper for Picky Eaters - Grass Fed Beef Bone Broth Supplement - Supports Hydration, Joint, Immunity & Heart Health - Serve Dry or Wet - 9.5oz From $24.95

3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsFrom$2495
Bone Broth Powder for Dogs and Cats - Dog & Cat Food Topper for Picky Eaters - Grass Fed Beef Bone Broth Supplement - Supports Hydration, Joint, Immunity & Heart Health - Serve Dry or Wet - 9.5oz
4.6 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Quail Egg, 2.8 oz. Pouch From $2.18

Sponsored
From$218
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Quail Egg, 2.8 oz. Pouch
4.8 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Stix Wet Cat Treats, Variety Pack, 3 oz. Pouch From $5.39

Sponsored
From$539
Tiki Cat Stix Wet Cat Treats, Variety Pack, 3 oz. Pouch
4.7 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Wet Cat Food, Mousse, Tuna & Shrimp Recipe in Tuna Broth, 2.4 oz. Pouch $1.68 $8.00/oz

$168
current price $1.68$8.00/oz
Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Wet Cat Food, Mousse, Tuna & Shrimp Recipe in Tuna Broth, 2.4 oz. Pouch
4.7 out of 5 stars
Inaba Twins Wet Cat Topper Cups, 1.23 oz Serving, 16 Servings, Tuna & Chicken From $15.85

3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsFrom$1585
Inaba Twins Wet Cat Topper Cups, 1.23 oz Serving, 16 Servings, Tuna & Chicken
4.7 out of 5 stars
(6 pack) Sheba Perfect Portions Kitten Wet Cat Food Variety Pack, 2.6 Oz Twin-Pack Trays (12 Pack) From $86.76

3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsFrom$8676
(6 pack) Sheba Perfect Portions Kitten Wet Cat Food Variety Pack, 2.6 Oz Twin-Pack Trays (12 Pack)
Dr. Marty Nature's Feast Essential Wellness Beef, Salmon, & Poultry Blend Freeze Dried Raw Cat Food 5.5 oz $30.50

$3050
current price $30.50Dr. Marty Nature's Feast Essential Wellness Beef, Salmon, & Poultry Blend Freeze Dried Raw Cat Food 5.5 oz
4.1 out of 5 stars
(6 pack) Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken, 2.8 oz. Pouch $13.08 Was $34.38 77.9 ¢/oz

Now$1308
current price Now $13.08, Was $34.38$34.38
77.9 ¢/oz
(6 pack) Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken, 2.8 oz. Pouch
Hill's Science Diet Wet Cat Food Variety Pack, 2.8oz Pouch 12pk $23.74

$2374
current price $23.74Hill's Science Diet Wet Cat Food Variety Pack, 2.8oz Pouch 12pk
4.2 out of 5 stars
(2 pack) Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Complements Wet Cat Food Topper, Chicken & Egg 2.1 oz. Pouch $3.36 80.0 ¢/oz

$336
current price $3.3680.0 ¢/oz
(2 pack) Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Complements Wet Cat Food Topper, Chicken & Egg 2.1 oz. Pouch
Applaws Wet Cat Food in Broth Variety Pack 6 Count, Chicken Liver, Tuna Shrimp, Salmon 2.12 oz, MerlinsMart Zine $28.97

$2897
current price $28.97Applaws Wet Cat Food in Broth Variety Pack 6 Count, Chicken Liver, Tuna Shrimp, Salmon 2.12 oz, MerlinsMart Zine
5 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Complements Wet Cat Food Topper, Variety Pack 2.1 oz. Pouch (12 Pack) From $20.42

2 options
Available in additional 2 optionsFrom$2042
Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Complements Wet Cat Food Topper, Variety Pack 2.1 oz. Pouch (12 Pack)
4.8 out of 5 stars
Solid Gold Flavorful Feast Indoor Recipe with Real Chicken, Grain-Free Gravy Pate Wet Cat Food, 3 Count Sample Pack, 3oz cans $6.24

$624
current price $6.24Solid Gold Flavorful Feast Indoor Recipe with Real Chicken, Grain-Free Gravy Pate Wet Cat Food, 3 Count Sample Pack, 3oz cans
2 out of 5 stars
Special Kitty Chicken Dinner & Turkey & Giblets & Mixed Grill Cuts in Gravy Wet Cat Food Poultry Variety Pack, 3 oz Pouches, 12 Pack

4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsSpecial Kitty Chicken Dinner & Turkey & Giblets & Mixed Grill Cuts in Gravy Wet Cat Food Poultry Variety Pack, 3 oz Pouches, 12 Pack
4.4 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Quail Egg, 2.8 oz. Pouch From $2.18

4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsFrom$218
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse Wet Cat Food, Chicken & Quail Egg, 2.8 oz. Pouch
4.8 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse, Chicken & Duck, 2.8 oz. Pouch From $2.18

4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsFrom$218
Tiki Cat After Dark Velvet Mousse, Chicken & Duck, 2.8 oz. Pouch
4.7 out of 5 stars
(6 pack) Sheba Perfect Portions Variety Pack Cuts In Gravy Cat Food, 2.6 Oz Twin-Pack Trays (24 Count) From $167.76

3 options
Available in additional 3 optionsFrom$16776
(6 pack) Sheba Perfect Portions Variety Pack Cuts In Gravy Cat Food, 2.6 Oz Twin-Pack Trays (24 Count)
Tiki Cat Friends Stix, Variety Pack, 1.6 oz. Pouch (4 Stix) From $3.42

6 options
Available in additional 6 optionsFrom$342
Tiki Cat Friends Stix, Variety Pack, 1.6 oz. Pouch (4 Stix)
4.9 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Friends Stix Tuna & Pumpkin Flavor, 1.6 oz. Pouch (4 Stix) From $3.42

4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsFrom$342
Tiki Cat Friends Stix Tuna & Pumpkin Flavor, 1.6 oz. Pouch (4 Stix)
4.9 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat After Dark Pate+ Wet Cat Food Chicken & Duck 2.8 oz. Can From $2.18

5 options
Available in additional 5 optionsFrom$218
Tiki Cat After Dark Pate+ Wet Cat Food Chicken & Duck 2.8 oz. Can
4.5 out of 5 stars
Tiki Cat Gelee Wet Cat Food, Variety Pack, 2.8 oz. Pouch (12 Count) $24.97 74.3 ¢/oz

$2497
current price $24.9774.3 ¢/oz
Tiki Cat Gelee Wet Cat Food, Variety Pack, 2.8 oz. Pouch (12 Count)
3 out of 5 stars
Popular in Cat Picky Eater
Related Products
Puddonio Mixed Flavor Lickable Wet Cat Treats, 0.5 oz Tubes (20 ct)
Puddonio Mixed Flavor Lickable Wet Cat Treats, 0.5 oz Tubes (20 ct)$15.99current price $15.99Purina Whisker Lickin's Crunch Lovers Tuna Flavored Cat Treats [Cat, Cat Treats] 1.7 oz
Purina Whisker Lickin's Crunch Lovers Tuna Flavored Cat Treats [Cat, Cat Treats] 1.7 oz$18.97current price $18.97Puddonio Catnip Biscuit Chicken & Salmon Flavor Cat Treats, 16 oz
Puddonio Catnip Biscuit Chicken & Salmon Flavor Cat Treats, 16 oz$13.59current price $13.59Cat Crunchy Fish Shaped Catnip Treats, Natural Kitty Cat Treats, Delicious Catnip Flavored Snacks, 3.5 oz. Tub
Cat Crunchy Fish Shaped Catnip Treats, Natural Kitty Cat Treats, Delicious Catnip Flavored Snacks, 3.5 oz. Tub$11.99current price $11.99Temptations Cat Treat 8 Flavors Variety Pack, 3oz Each
Temptations Cat Treat 8 Flavors Variety Pack, 3oz Each$26.40current price $26.40Purina Dentalife Dental Cat Treats 2 Flavor 4 Pouch Variety 2 Each: Tasty Chicken, Savory Salmon + MerlinsMart Zine | Catnip Toy
Purina Dentalife Dental Cat Treats 2 Flavor 4 Pouch Variety 2 Each: Tasty Chicken, Savory Salmon + MerlinsMart Zine | Catnip Toy$27.97current price $27.97Beefeaters Lickables Puree Cat Treat, Variety, 3ct, Case of 12
Beefeaters Lickables Puree Cat Treat, Variety, 3ct, Case of 12$18.00current price $18.00Purina Friskies Party Mix Natural Yums Cat Treats, Natural Catnip Flavor with Added Vitamins, Minerals & Nutrients, For Adult Cats, 2.1 OZ Pouch (Pack of 3)
Purina Friskies Party Mix Natural Yums Cat Treats, Natural Catnip Flavor with Added Vitamins, Minerals & Nutrients, For Adult Cats, 2.1 OZ Pouch (Pack of 3)$12.70current price $12.70Rena's Recipe Kitty Licks ( 28 tubes/ variety flavors)
Rena's Recipe Kitty Licks ( 28 tubes/ variety flavors)$14.99current price $14.99Purina DentaLife Dental Treats for Cats Chicken [Cat, Cat Treats] 1.8 oz
Purina DentaLife Dental Treats for Cats Chicken [Cat, Cat Treats] 1.8 oz$17.99current price $17.99Purina DentaLife Dental Treats for Cats Salmon [Cat, Cat Treats] 1.8 oz
Purina DentaLife Dental Treats for Cats Salmon [Cat, Cat Treats] 1.8 oz$17.47current price $17.47Snowy’s Wild-Caught Tuna & Shrimp Lickable Wet Cat Treat | Limited-Ingredient Seafood Topper | No Natural Flavor | 4 x 0.5oz Tubes | Tuna
Snowy’s Wild-Caught Tuna & Shrimp Lickable Wet Cat Treat | Limited-Ingredient Seafood Topper | No Natural Flavor | 4 x 0.5oz Tubes | Tuna$9.99current price $9.99Cat by Scoochie Squeeze-Up Mixed Variety Pack Premium Creamy Salmon, Chicken Lickable Cat Treats, 8CT
Cat by Scoochie Squeeze-Up Mixed Variety Pack Premium Creamy Salmon, Chicken Lickable Cat Treats, 8CT$21.99current price $21.99Cat by Scoochie Sensations Mixed Variety Pack Catnip, Chicken, Tuna Filled Crunchy Cat Treats, 3CT
Cat by Scoochie Sensations Mixed Variety Pack Catnip, Chicken, Tuna Filled Crunchy Cat Treats, 3CT$20.99current price $20.99Café Nara Chicken Flavored Lickable Treats for Cats - Pack of 12
Café Nara Chicken Flavored Lickable Treats for Cats - Pack of 12$39.99current price $39.99Puddonio Salmon Lickable Wet Cat Treats, 0.5 oz Tubes (20 ct)
Puddonio Salmon Lickable Wet Cat Treats, 0.5 oz Tubes (20 ct)$16.99current price $16.99