Chocolate Buckeyes(15)
Marsha's Homemade Buckeyes - 8 oz. Tub Peanut Butter Balls Covered in Chocolate $7.84 98.0 ¢/oz

Marsha's Homemade Buckeyes - 8 oz. Tub Peanut Butter Balls Covered in Chocolate
Anthony-Thomas, Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes in Ohio State Buckeyes Box, Deliciously Delightful Snacks (12 Count) $14.99

Anthony-Thomas, Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes in Ohio State Buckeyes Box, Deliciously Delightful Snacks (12 Count)
Anthony Thomas, Award Winning Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes, Deliciously Delightful Snacks, (6 Count, Milk Chocolate Buckeyes) $10.97 Was $12.99

Anthony Thomas, Award Winning Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes, Deliciously Delightful Snacks, (6 Count, Milk Chocolate Buckeyes)
Kauffman Orchards Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes, 14 Ounce Bag $29.99

Kauffman Orchards Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes, 14 Ounce Bag
Marsha's Homemade Buckeyes - 8 oz. Tub $30.99

Marsha's Homemade Buckeyes - 8 oz. Tub
Ohio Made Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Bulk Bags $35.00

Ohio Made Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Bulk Bags
Waggoner Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Clear 13 oz. Container $34.70

Waggoner Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Clear 13 oz. Container
Waggoner Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Red Round Latch Tin 12 oz. $40.75

Waggoner Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Red Round Latch Tin 12 oz.
Ohio Made Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Bulk Bags $79.50

Ohio Made Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Bulk Bags
Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes - 1.5 Lb Tub $29.99

Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes - 1.5 Lb Tub
Half Pound Waggoner Buckeyes Gift Box $28.50

Half Pound Waggoner Buckeyes Gift Box
Kauffman Orchards Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes, 2 Pound Bag $38.99

Kauffman Orchards Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes, 2 Pound Bag
Peanut Butter Chocolate Buckeye - 12oz $15.99

Peanut Butter Chocolate Buckeye - 12oz
(Price/Case)Prepack Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes 12/11oz, 053275 $116.38

(Price/Case)Prepack Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes 12/11oz, 053275
Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes, Bite-Sized Treats, 1 lb Bag

Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes, Bite-Sized Treats, 1 lb Bag
Other options to consider(58)
Chocolate Buck Deer Poop - Chocolate Raisins in Vintage Cotton Bag $9.99

Chocolate Buck Deer Poop - Chocolate Raisins in Vintage Cotton Bag
Lindt Lindor Holiday Assorted Chocolate Candy Truffles, 12.7 oz. Bag $14.97 $1.18/oz

Lindt Lindor Holiday Assorted Chocolate Candy Truffles, 12.7 oz. Bag
Brookside Dark Chocolate, Acai and Blueberry Flavored Snacking Chocolate, Bag 7 oz

Brookside Dark Chocolate, Acai and Blueberry Flavored Snacking Chocolate, Bag 7 oz
Rollback, Lindt LINDOR White Chocolate Assorted Chocolate Candy Truffles, 8.5 oz. Bag $9.87 Was $10.97 $1.16/oz

Lindt LINDOR White Chocolate Assorted Chocolate Candy Truffles, 8.5 oz. Bag
Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Candy Sharing Size 9.6 oz $11.99

Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Candy Sharing Size 9.6 oz
Rollback, Lindt Lindor Assorted Chocolate Truffles, Candy Variety Pack, 8.5 oz Bag From $6.88

Lindt Lindor Assorted Chocolate Truffles, Candy Variety Pack, 8.5 oz Bag
Rollback, Lindt Lindor Milk Assorted Chocolate Candy Truffles, 8.5 oz, Bag $9.87 Was $11.96 $1.16/oz

Lindt Lindor Milk Assorted Chocolate Candy Truffles, 8.5 oz, Bag
Brookside Dark Chocolate, Acai & Blueberry Daring Ball Smooth Chocolate Candy Fruit Flavored Centered 32oz. Bag Great for Snacks Trail Mix Halloween Basket Stuffers Christmas Holiday Treats & Gifts

Brookside Dark Chocolate, Acai & Blueberry Daring Ball Smooth Chocolate Candy Fruit Flavored Centered 32oz. Bag Great for Snacks Trail Mix Halloween Basket Stuffers Christmas Holiday Treats & Gifts
MINIS Peanut Butter Colorful Milk Chocolate Candy Football Tailgating NFL Super Bowl Sharing Size 1 Bag 8.6 Oz $10.31

MINIS Peanut Butter Colorful Milk Chocolate Candy Football Tailgating NFL Super Bowl Sharing Size 1 Bag 8.6 Oz
Barry Callebaut Mini Dark Choc $25.79

Barry Callebaut Mini Dark Choc
M&M'S Cleveland Browns NFL Milk Chocolate Candies, 2 lb Bulk Bag with Team Colors and Logos $44.99

M&M'S Cleveland Browns NFL Milk Chocolate Candies, 2 lb Bulk Bag with Team Colors and Logos
Lindt Gourmet Truffles Assorted Chocolate Candy, Gift Box, 6.8 oz $14.97 $2.20/oz

Lindt Gourmet Truffles Assorted Chocolate Candy, Gift Box, 6.8 oz
Buc-ee's Dark Chocolate Beaver Nuggets 3 oz $16.95

Buc-ee's Dark Chocolate Beaver Nuggets 3 oz
Oh Henry Peanut Butter Chocolate - 1 lb $14.99

Oh Henry Peanut Butter Chocolate - 1 lb
Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Creamy Peanut Butter Filled Milk Chocolate Candy Classic Sweet & Nutty Treat for Snacks, Gifts & Desserts 1 lb Pack $16.99

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Creamy Peanut Butter Filled Milk Chocolate Candy Classic Sweet & Nutty Treat for Snacks, Gifts & Desserts 1 lb Pack
BROOKSIDE Dark Chocolate Pomegranate Flavored Snacking Chocolate, Bulk Bag (32 oz.) $24.99

BROOKSIDE Dark Chocolate Pomegranate Flavored Snacking Chocolate, Bulk Bag (32 oz.)
Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy - Case Of 24 $48.84

Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy - Case Of 24
Chocolate Double Crisp Googly Eyes - Bulk Bags $45.00

Chocolate Double Crisp Googly Eyes - Bulk Bags
Brookside Dark Chocolate and Pomegranate Flavored Snacking Chocolate, Bag 7 oz $5.97 85.3 ¢/oz

Brookside Dark Chocolate and Pomegranate Flavored Snacking Chocolate, Bag 7 oz
Brookside Dark Chocolate Covered Fruit (40 Count Variety Pack)z, 0.7 ounces $32.93

Brookside Dark Chocolate Covered Fruit (40 Count Variety Pack)z, 0.7 ounces
Oh Henry Peanut Butter Chocolate - 5 lb $41.46

Oh Henry Peanut Butter Chocolate - 5 lb
(Price/Case)Giannios Candy Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter 10lb, 643104 $181.59

(Price/Case)Giannios Candy Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter 10lb, 643104
FAQ
Are chocolate buckeyes from Ohio?
Chocolate buckeyes are closely linked to Ohio and are considered a classic treat in the state. They're named after the nut of the Ohio buckeye tree, which their appearance resembles. While you can find buckeyes in other places, they're especially popular at gatherings, holidays, and events throughout Ohio. If you're looking for an authentic taste of the Midwest, these peanut butter and chocolate candies are a great choice!
What kind of chocolate works best for buckeyes?
When making buckeyes, many people prefer using milk chocolate for its creamy, sweet flavor that pairs well with peanut butter. However, dark chocolate can also be used if you like a richer, less sweet taste. The key is to use chocolate that melts smoothly and sets up firmly, so your buckeyes hold their shape and have a nice snap when you bite in. You can find both milk and dark chocolate options in the candy aisle at Walmart.
What ingredients are in chocolate buckeyes?
Chocolate buckeyes are made with a few simple ingredients:
- Peanut butter
- Powdered sugar
- Butter
- Vanilla extract (optional)
- Chocolate coating (usually milk or dark chocolate)
The peanut butter mixture is rolled into balls, then partially dipped in chocolate to create the signature "buckeye" look. Some recipes may vary, but these are the basics you'll find in most buckeye candies.
How are buckeyes different from peanut butter balls?
While buckeyes and peanut butter balls share similar ingredients, the main difference is in how they're coated. Buckeyes are only partially dipped in chocolate, leaving a circle of peanut butter exposed on top, which makes them look like the nut from the buckeye tree. Peanut butter balls, on the other hand, are usually fully coated in chocolate. Both treats are delicious, but buckeyes have that classic two-tone appearance.
How should I store chocolate buckeyes?
To keep your chocolate buckeyes fresh, store them in an airtight container. They can be kept at room temperature for a few days, but for longer storage, it's best to refrigerate them. If you want to keep them even longer, you can freeze buckeyes in a sealed container for several weeks. Just let them come to room temperature before serving for the best texture and flavor.
Popular in Shop Chocolate Buckeyes Peanut Butter Treats
Related Products
MOUNDS Dark Chocolate and Coconut, Snack Size Bag of 2 Pound
MOUNDS Dark Chocolate and Coconut, Snack Size Bag of 2 Pound$49.33current price $49.33Milka Milk Chocolate with Caramel Filling, 100g (PACK OF 1)
Milka Milk Chocolate with Caramel Filling, 100g (PACK OF 1)$9.65current price $9.65MOUNDS Dark Chocolate and Coconut Snack Size, Candy Bag, 11.3 oz ( Pack of 2 )
MOUNDS Dark Chocolate and Coconut Snack Size, Candy Bag, 11.3 oz ( Pack of 2 )$18.99current price $18.99Terry's Milk Chocolate Orange, 5.53 oz
Terry's Milk Chocolate Orange, 5.53 oz$18.49current price $18.49Milka Milk Chocolate with Hazelnuts, 100g/3.5oz (PACK OF 5)
Milka Milk Chocolate with Hazelnuts, 100g/3.5oz (PACK OF 5)$23.95current price $23.95Milk Chocolate Covered Peanut Caramel Clusters by It's Delish, 5 lbs Bulk
Milk Chocolate Covered Peanut Caramel Clusters by It's Delish, 5 lbs Bulk$52.99current price $52.99Terry's Chocolate Orange Milk Chocolate 5.53 oz. 2 pack
Terry's Chocolate Orange Milk Chocolate 5.53 oz. 2 pack$27.49current price $27.49Milka Cherry Cream Chocolate Bar 100g (5-pack)
Milka Cherry Cream Chocolate Bar 100g (5-pack)$21.99current price $21.99HEATH Miniatures Chocolatey English Toffee, Christmas Candy Bag, 10 oz
HEATH Miniatures Chocolatey English Toffee, Christmas Candy Bag, 10 oz$18.88current price $18.88MOUNDS Dark Chocolate and Coconut 1.75 Oz Candy Bar, Multiple Pack Box By CANDY CABIN 12 Pack
MOUNDS Dark Chocolate and Coconut 1.75 Oz Candy Bar, Multiple Pack Box By CANDY CABIN 12 Pack$27.95current price $27.95Enstrom Almond Toffee in Milk Chocolate, Handcrafted Gluten Free All Natural Chocolate Candy with Soft and Crunchy Texture for Christmas Holiday Candy Buffet Gifts and Party Favors 2.34 LB
Enstrom Almond Toffee in Milk Chocolate, Handcrafted Gluten Free All Natural Chocolate Candy with Soft and Crunchy Texture for Christmas Holiday Candy Buffet Gifts and Party Favors 2.34 LB$38.98current price $38.98Milka Chocolate Bars Assorted NG01 Bundle of 5 (Bundle #1)
Milka Chocolate Bars Assorted NG01 Bundle of 5 (Bundle #1)$24.99current price $24.991 lb. Milk & Dark Chocolate Deluxe Assortment
1 lb. Milk & Dark Chocolate Deluxe Assortment$39.99current price $39.99(1PACK), Mounds Dark Chocolate and Coconut Snack Size Candy,
(1PACK), Mounds Dark Chocolate and Coconut Snack Size Candy,$9.49current price $9.49

