Maybelline Line Works Ultra Liner Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner, Dark Brown [302], 0.25 oz

For years this has been my go to eyeliner. Unfortunately the last few times I've purchased it seems as though the formula changed. It is now watery - less coverage. I have to go over the line several times when previously once was sufficient. I recently came an old tube in a travel bag (same product but the tube was white, not gray so that tells you it was probably 15 years old) and it was still vibrant and you only needed to draw one line! The old one worked better than a brand new tube. I will be looking for a new eyeliner.

First off I do love this product but I didn't receive my order. I contacted Walmart through the chat and the person said ti wait another 48 hrs to see if it shows up. It did not so I called the customer service number and talked to a woman. I thought she fixed everything but still nothing happened. I called again yesterday and the guy on the phone was super helpful and refunded my first order. He helped me reorder my items. I'm still waiting for those ones to arrive.