Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Pencil Eyeliner, Coal Commander

I have been a long time user of this eyeliner. It WAS my holy grail eyeliner - it beat ALL the top end brands in my opinion. I would always recommend it. The recent change to packaging and product is horrible. Don't waste your money, this is nothing like the previous formula, tip or packaging (the lid comes off easily in my makeup bag). Like other loyal fans, I am so disappointed with the new version - I immediately noticed the difference in one application. You will lose a lot of fans - listen to your feedback and bring back the old version.

For the past few years I have purchased a master precise liner every couple of months. I raved about them. They were an excellent product and a fantastic price. Last week I picked up one of the new ones and... ugh. It's changed for the worse. - The tip is dry. I can only get liquid out by lying the brush flat and dragging it across the back of my hand but it won't work precisely across my lid. The old one was amazing. You'd just swipe and go and people would ALWAYS comment on how good it looked. - The formula seems different but that might just be a result of the appallingly poor applicator. I have no idea why the product was changed but it's atrocious. I went online to look for similar reviews and that's how I ended up here. Save your money, folks and buy one of the other (unfortunately more expensive) brands. This WAS an excellent product. It is now useless. I threw it away.