NYX Professional Makeup All-in-One Jumbo Eyeshadow and Eyeliner Multi-Stick Eye Pencil, Eggplant, 0.18 oz

I saw this in black and decided to give it a try. I needed black eyeliner/shadow/whatever for around my eyes and on my face for my plague doctor outfit for Halloween. I usually just use cheap eye shadow, but it doesn't last long and rubs off too easily. This pencil is fantastic. It went on smoothly and easily (I didn't even need to blend it) and it washed off slightly less easy (I used makeup remover to get it all off). But it is fantastic and it did exactly what I hoped it would do.

decent color payoff on waterline, although 619 Rust color appears a bit pinkish until you really layer it on (if you're not into the whole pink-eye look). Please include instructions on package for how to sharpen! Tried to pull it open and twist and all the things until found a video online explaining (you just sharpen as if it's a regular wood pencil with a pencil sharpener)