Melissa & Doug Shake It! Farm Animals Beginner Craft Kit - Confetti-Covered Cow and Horse (4? x 1.5? Each)

My 4 year old absolutely loved this set. I did the first one with him, and then he was able to do the other two almost completely by himself (with great joy and minimal mess). It was easy to pull the adhesive off and he loved that there were a few different elements to complete: removing adhesive, shaking in bag to get the tissue paper / confetti to stick, adding stickers, and then creating each animal's home (which I had to help with). I recommend doing this on a floor or table that is easy to sweep up because it was hard for him to keep all the confetti in the bag (but not impossible). The bags were high quality. If you were doing this with 3 kids, you would need the 3 bags but for our purposes the extra bags were saved to use for other projects (as not necessary to use the 3 bags for 1 kid and they are sturdy).

My daughter loved making these farm animals. She liked all the steps, especially shaking the bag. There was definitely some mess but easily vacuumed up.