Maybelline The Falsies Surreal Extensions Washable Mascara, Meta Black, 0.33 fl oz

My sister has this and I had to use it in a pinch (at her daughter's wedding!). I went out and bought some for myself! I moisturize and use sunscreen like crazy so I get raccoon eyes from most mascaras. But this holds up pretty good! Very minimal color transfer to bottom eyelid.

I really, really like this mascara. I've been using it for about a month now and love the volume, ease of application, lack of clumping, and the fact that it doesn't run or smear but washes off really well. It doesn't exactly give "false lashes" volume or thickening (honestly does any mascara really do that?), but it does do a good job with my skimpy lashes. The one thing I don't love is the rounded bottom - I either have to lay it flat while I'm using it or prop it up. I doubt it matters to lay it flat, it just feels weird to me. But I'll happily deal with it for the tradeoff of having a good mascara that doesn't cost an arm and a leg!