Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Duo Glossy Liquid Eyeliner, 520 Navy Gleam, 0.05 Fl. Oz.

This eyeliner doesn't smudge!!! I've tried a lot of eyeliners (both department and drugstore brands) and this is one of the few eyeliners that don't smudge. Also it doesn't contain any parabens. I guess some people might think the brush tip is kind of inconvenient - I actually cut out the round tip part of the brush to draw a sharper line. This eyeliner deserves a 5 star just for being an eyeliner that doesn't smudge! If you're looking for an eyeliner that doesn't smudge you should try this out.

II've been wearing this eyeliner for several years and haven't found anything else I like better. I tend to have greasy eyelids, so a pencil eyeliner doesn't work. This stays put, is easy to apply, and washes off in the shower with a little rubbing. I don't understand the negative reviews. As far as it being watery, I'm thinking that maybe they didn't shake the product before applying. As far as it burning the eyes, I've never had an issue, so maybe some people are just allergic or sensitive. I've had people comment about my eyeliner and asked me what I use. I'm no makeup artist, but I find the applicator fairly easy to use, especially since there are two dimensions to it. I use the bronzed shimmer and prefer it over the black since I have brown hair with highlights.