NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil, All-in-one Eyeshadow and Eyeliner Multi-stick, Cashmere

I've been using the Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk for literally the last 6 years as an eyeshadow base, it's pretty much my holy grail when 30$ bases crease or get too oily. I have the sharpener but honestly I prefer using a small cosmetic spatula to scoop some product onto my eyelid then blend out with fingers before eyeshadow application, and believe me there is SO MUCH product in these things, I use it daily and only have to buy 1 to last me a solid year. It's always in my recommended products when people come to me for makeup advice and I usually have 1 or 2 extra on hand to just give away to people LOL. One of my top 5 makeup products hands down.

I saw this in black and decided to give it a try. I needed black eyeliner/shadow/whatever for around my eyes and on my face for my plague doctor outfit for Halloween. I usually just use cheap eye shadow, but it doesn't last long and rubs off too easily. This pencil is fantastic. It went on smoothly and easily (I didn't even need to blend it) and it washed off slightly less easy (I used makeup remover to get it all off). But it is fantastic and it did exactly what I hoped it would do.