Skip to Main Content
Walmart
All Departments
All Services
Customer ratings and reviews for
J. Adams Shirley High Silver Comfortable Heels for Women | Open Toe Ankle Strap Sandal Block Heel Dress Platform
4.4 out of 5 stars
stars149 ratings117 reviews
  1. 5 stars62% (93)
  2. 4 stars28% (42)
  3. 3 stars1% (1)
  4. 2 stars1% (1)
  5. 1 star8% (12)
How item rating is calculated

Reviews summary

Pros

  • : Made with high-quality materials that last.
  • : Has a classic look suitable for various occasions.
  • : Offers good quality at a lower cost.
  • : Provides adequate arch support and cushioning.
  • : Provides additional support with thicker heel and straps.

Neutral

  • : Can be comfortable for some, but may run large or feel loose for others.
Generated by AI

Customer photos

Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 117 reviews
Sep 19, 2025
Margaret
Top Reviewer
Item details
Shoe size: 9
Color: Dark Green Suede
Sold and shipped byShoes For Dinner
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Perfect!

These shoes are gorgeous and exactly the color I was looking for! They are a beautiful shade of olive green! Although the heel is somewhat high, they are surprisingly comfortable! I can hardly wait to wear them !

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Dec 13, 2022
Cindy
Item details
Shoe size: 7.5
Color: Silver Glitter
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Really cute heels! I was feeling adventurous and chose the silver glitter heels and I do not regret doing so at all. I absolutely love them! They would definitely be a statement piece for any outfit and I cannot wait to show them off.

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
May 6, 2026
Rachael
Item details
Shoe size: 9
Color: Wine Vegan Suede
Sold byShoes For DinnerDelivered byWalmart
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

The shoes came individually wrapped. They were stylish and comfortable.

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Oct 26, 2022
Walmart customer
Item details
Shoe size: 7.5
Color: Wine Vegan Suede
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Beautiful Wine Red Color!

These shoes are so perfect! I love the height and the straps actually provide a lot of support. There is padding on the inside where your foot rests so they are comfortable when worn. Also the color is really beautiful in person! I got the wine red and it is going to go with so many things!

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Oct 18, 2022
JKO
Item details
Shoe size: 8.5
Color: Red Vegan Suede
5 out of 5 stars review

... I want one in EVERY COLOR!

These shoes are beautiful! The red is a bright red, my favorite type of red! But what I am so amazed about these shoes is that they are so COMFY!! Yes they are high but for how high they are, they truly are so comfortable. I wore it... the whole day....!!! I was truly amazed myself. Can I just add that these are timeless and super cute! No joke, I want one in every color!

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Oct 10, 2022
Jessica
Item details
Shoe size: 7
Color: Red Vegan Suede
5 out of 5 stars review

Easy to walk high heels for any fancy occasion!

My favorite part of these shoes is the chunky block heel. Despite the height of these heels, the chunky heels make it very easy to walk! The suede makes the shoe feel very expensive. I love how the buckle on the strap is a gold color because it really pops on top of the black suede. There’s also a bit of elastic behind the buckle to make the fit around your ankle more comfortable, if needed. The fit of the shoe is true to size. These shoes would be great for a wedding or any fancy event!

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Jun 18, 2024
Lizzerly
5 out of 5 stars review

Bought these for my daughter for prom. She wanted something high-heeled, but not too high-heeled and with a thicker heel so she wouldn't feel off balance. She said even after standing and/or dancing in them for 2-3 hours, they didn't hurt her feet at all. We did have to add some moleskine on the inside of the part across the toes, as she has narrow feet to prevent her from slipping and sliding in the shoe, but that was easy to do.

Review from jadamsshoes.com
Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Dec 26, 2023
w33nie
Item details
Shoe size: 7.5
Color: Black Vegan Suede
Sold byShoes For Dinner
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

cute shoes

i usually wear 7/7.5 US but they both were a bit small around the strap in the front, it felt tight. still super cute!! i just recommend sizing up

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Apr 12, 2026
Lisa
Item details
Shoe size: 7.5
Color: Silver Vegan Leather
Sold byShoes For DinnerDelivered byWalmart
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

one of the heels broke within an hour of wearing.

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900
Sep 27, 2024
nancy
Walmart Associate
Item details
Shoe size: 8
Color: Bone Lizard
Sold byJ. AdamsDelivered byWalmart
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Very poorly made shoe

Lasted two hours before they disintegrated.

Helpful?59RKGYJU4JRL329057900