Skip to Main Content
Walmart
All Departments
All Services
Customer ratings and reviews for
SmartLine 28' Round Tidal Surge Overlap Above Ground Swimming Pool Liner, 54" Height, 20 Gauge
4.8 out of 5 stars
stars241 ratings164 reviews
  1. 5 stars85% (205)
  2. 4 stars11% (26)
  3. 3 stars3% (8)
  4. 2 stars0% (0)
  5. 1 star1% (2)
How item rating is calculated
Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 164 reviews
Jun 21, 2025
Amy Bavone
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

Not only does it look great but the quality is wonderful and the service was above and beyond. I initially bought the wrong size and they gladly exchanged for the right size. The shipping was super fast and my account got credited the day the wrong liner got back to them. Im very impressed by everything!

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Apr 3, 2026
Michael McDonald
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

It's been many years since I last bought a liner for our 18 ft. Round aboveground pool. You guys were very quick in shipping my order. Received everything no damage boxes. I can't wait to install it in late April to early May. Would love to tell you more about that timeline. Thanks.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Aug 13, 2025
Michael weaver
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

The liner arrived very quickly. I think two days after I placed the order the directions were good. The liner went on just the way it should've I believe. Got it filled with water and enjoying the pool. Thank you for your quick service and quality product.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Jun 11, 2025
Craig Baskin
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

I bought the liner with cove moulding and a rhino pad. The 25 mil liner seems plenty thick but still will stretch where needed. I did it with no help one step at a time. Tamp the sand down when damp and add the pad.it came out pretty smooth, better than before.I think cove moulding is necessary

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Jun 16, 2025
logan miller
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

This was the wrong size for us but we got the 27 foot and the pool is filling as I type! Install went very smooth, of course it's our third or fourth time installing a liner. Thanks for great customer service! We were disappointed that we are stuck with the wrong side and can't return it! 🫣

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Jul 12, 2025
Laura Maldonado
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

My experience so far has been very good. I haven't installed the new liner yet as we are doing it this weekend. I will say this is the second liner I had to buy. I've only had my Pool three years after the first year there was a leak in the sea it was covered under warranty, so they sent me a new one then this year in the exact same spot and directly across from it on the other side of the pool in the same spot, there was another leak in both sea. I paid for a new liner because I wanted a stronger one which I received a 30 gauge and that's what I ordered. I'm keeping my fingers crossed that this is the last time I have to replace a liner at least for 10 years, but I will say overall my experience has been very good. I will let you know how it goes after this liner has been installed.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Sep 6, 2025
Edward Palmer
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

I just wish in my 18 round 52 deep pool I lost half the waterfall pulling th liner in the pool. I was hoping to have a lot more of that showing but it's ok. We love it.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Aug 11, 2025
sheila Hess
5 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

The pool liner arrived I believe with in 3 or 4 days from the day I ordered it which was fantastic. My family help install it into our new pool very easily.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
Apr 20, 2026
Jeff Efird
4 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

Fast delivery was awesome. Quality of material is very nice. The only thing that would have helped, is if the instructions were a little more detailed about centering the liner using the seams. Since it was an oval and not a circle, it has to go in a certain way. The seal on the long side needed to be in the center. I did figure that out. Also, the two seams in the middle I had to figure out too. I thought one was in the center. Actually the center was the middle of the two seams. A diagram would have helped.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433
May 18, 2025
Beverly Brannon
3 out of 5 stars review

Seller Verified Purchase

I normally give good scores but with this liner we had problems. First of all the liner seemed a little bit too big. We had to overlap on part of the walls to take up the extra liner. We have put liners in our pool before and never had a problem like this one in order to get the liner tight against the wall we had to make the waterfall shorter, which looks ridiculous. So I am so very unsatisfied with this product so hopefully they will give me a refund or something to make up for me having to put a pool liner in our pool too big and yes, we have a big outing next weekend so we try to get it done thinking it was gonna work, but it didn't. We made it work. This could be just a mishap in the product being made. I'm not sure. So my rating is going to be a three the pool liner was pretty and I paid $400 for someone to help me put this in and he's helped me before.

Review from poolsupplies.com
Helpful?3SHJ7J1VE3YX17885750433