e.l.f. Brightening Eyeliner, Black

I love the color , its a soft cool brown. So many brown liners are almost black or warm and have a deep chestnut color. This liner is for the upper and lower lashes and not the waterline. With the price and its comes with a shapener it is a great deal. I am glad I bought two.

I have black hair but I use this liner in coffee. It looks much more natural and I get so many more compliments on my brows than when I was using a darker color. A woman asked me last week if i get my brows threaded. I have oily skin and it still lasts me all day because I set my face with mineral powder. The only issue is I had the same problem as others with trying to sharpen it because it is kinda soft but when I want to sharpen it, I just pop it in the freezer and that hardens it so I can get a sharp edge but when it warms up it goes back to it's regular consistency which I love. Fabulous deal for the money!