Hero image 0 of Peanut Butter Vanilla Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound, 0 of 4
Peanut Butter Vanilla Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound
Peanut Butter Vanilla Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundPeanut Butter Vanilla Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundButtered Popcorn Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundBlue Raspberry Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundLicorice Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundBanana Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound Resealable BagAll Flavor Gourmet Salt Water Taffy Pink Bubble Gum 2 PoundRoot Beer Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundMaple Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundKey Lime Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundGreen Apple Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundSour Blue Raspberry Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundAssorted Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound Resealable BagCaramel Apple Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundRed Hot Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound Resealable BagAll Flavor Gourmet Salt Water Taffy Strawberry 2 LBVanilla Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundYellow Lemon Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundWatermelon Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound Resealable BagPeppermint Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound Resealable BagCoconut Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundChocolate Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 PoundSugar Free Assorted Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound Resealable BagSour Pink Watermelon Gourmet Salt Water Taffy 2 Pound
Flavor:Peanut Butter Vanilla-Out of stock
Key item features
CONTAINS: SOY AND PEANUT
Specs
- Texturechewy
- Size2 lbs
- Container typeBag
- Color categoryWhite
- ManufacturerFirstChoiceCandy
- MaterialResealable Bag
Current price is USD$17.99
Price when purchased online
Selected option out of stock
More options available
How do you want your item?
Out of stock
Similar items you might like
Based on what customers bought
Best seller Bit-O-Honey Honey and Almond Chewy Taffy Candy 11.5 oz. Lay Down Bag $4.97
Best seller
3 optionsAvailable in additional 3 optionsSponsored$497current price $4.97Options from $4.97 – $28.14Bit-O-Honey Honey and Almond Chewy Taffy Candy 11.5 oz. Lay Down Bag
9024.7 out of 5 Stars. 902 reviewsSave with
Pickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleSaltwater Taffy Candy – 12 Fruity Flavors– 1 LB–60 Wrapped Pieces $13.49
$1349current price $13.49Saltwater Taffy Candy – 12 Fruity Flavors– 1 LB–60 Wrapped Pieces
84.5 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysSalt Water Taffy Assorted Mix, 1 Pound Bulk Bag, 10 Assorted Flavors, Individually Wrapped Taffy Candy $12.99
6 optionsAvailable in additional 6 options$1299current price $12.99Options from $12.99 – $19.99Salt Water Taffy Assorted Mix, 1 Pound Bulk Bag, 10 Assorted Flavors, Individually Wrapped Taffy Candy
744.4 out of 5 Stars. 74 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysCotton Candy Salt Water Taffy, 3lbs (48oz). $14.99
$1499current price $14.99Cotton Candy Salt Water Taffy, 3lbs (48oz).
11 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 2 daysReduced price SweetGourmet Blue Raspberry Whipped Salt Water Taffy Bulk Candy | 1 Pound $11.19 Was $14.39
Reduced price
14 optionsAvailable in additional 14 optionsNow$1119current price Now $11.19, Was $14.39$14.39You save $3.20You save$3.20Options from $11.19 – $20.39SweetGourmet Blue Raspberry Whipped Salt Water Taffy Bulk Candy | 1 Pound
124.8 out of 5 Stars. 12 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Chocolate, 15 oz Single Resealable Bag $11.99
$1199current price $11.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Chocolate, 15 oz Single Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Caramel Apple, 15 oz Resealable Bag $11.99
$1199current price $11.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Caramel Apple, 15 oz Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Buttered Popcorn, 15 oz Single Resealable Bag $12.99
$1299current price $12.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Buttered Popcorn, 15 oz Single Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Neapolitan, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag $11.99
$1199current price $11.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Neapolitan, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Individually Wrapped, 15 oz Resealable Bag $9.99
10 optionsAvailable in additional 10 options$999current price $9.99Options from $9.99 – $11.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Individually Wrapped, 15 oz Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysReduced price SweetGourmet Peppermint Salt Water Taffy | Christmas Candy | 2 Pounds $16.59 Was $19.99
Reduced price
9 optionsAvailable in additional 9 optionsNow$1659current price Now $16.59, Was $19.99$19.99You save $3.40You save$3.40More options from $13.99SweetGourmet Peppermint Salt Water Taffy | Christmas Candy | 2 Pounds
424 out of 5 Stars. 42 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysBest seller Sweet's Salt Water Taffy Candies, 14 oz. $3.46
Best seller
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 options$346current price $3.46Options from $3.46 – $20.76Sweet's Salt Water Taffy Candies, 14 oz.
4004.5 out of 5 Stars. 400 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todaySNAP EBT eligibleSugar-Free Taffy Assortment - 10 Flavors, 1 lb (16 oz) Gluten & Nut-Free, Diabetic & Keto-Friendly Gourmet Candy $13.99
$1399current price $13.99Sugar-Free Taffy Assortment - 10 Flavors, 1 lb (16 oz) Gluten & Nut-Free, Diabetic & Keto-Friendly Gourmet Candy
54.8 out of 5 Stars. 5 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Bubble Gum, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag $10.99
$1099current price $10.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Bubble Gum, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Town Salt Water Taffy (Grape, 1 Lb) $14.99
$1499current price $14.99Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy (Grape, 1 Lb)
25 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Cotton Candy, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag $9.99
$999current price $9.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Cotton Candy, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Pear, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag $12.99
$1299current price $12.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Pear, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysCandy Retailer Salt Water Taffy (Watermelon, 3 Lb) $25.99
$2599current price $25.99Candy Retailer Salt Water Taffy (Watermelon, 3 Lb)
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy Assorted Mix, Chewniverse Edition, 10 Flavor Variety, 7 oz $8.99
$899current price $8.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Assorted Mix, Chewniverse Edition, 10 Flavor Variety, 7 oz
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysSnackathon Salt Water Taffy, Strawberry Creme, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag $11.99
$1199current price $11.99Snackathon Salt Water Taffy, Strawberry Creme, 15 oz Singe Resealable Bag
Shipping, arrives in 3+ days
More items to consider
Based on what customers bought
Best seller Bit-O-Honey Honey and Almond Chewy Taffy Candy 11.5 oz. Lay Down Bag $4.97
Best seller3 optionsAvailable in additional 3 optionsSponsored$497current price $4.97Options from $4.97 – $28.14Bit-O-Honey Honey and Almond Chewy Taffy Candy 11.5 oz. Lay Down Bag
9024.7 out of 5 Stars. 902 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleRollback Pepsi Cola Soda Pop, 12 fl oz, 12 Pack Cans $5.98 Was $7.28
Rollback
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 optionsSponsoredNow$598current price Now $5.98, Was $7.28$7.28You save $1.30You save$1.30Options from $5.98 – $12.48Pepsi Cola Soda Pop, 12 fl oz, 12 Pack Cans
475034.7 out of 5 Stars. 47503 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleTaffy Town Salt Water Taffy | Individually Wrapped Candy | Bulk Treat | Pickle, 2.5Ibs $18.99
33 optionsAvailable in additional 33 options$1899current price $18.99Options from $18.99 – $22.99Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy | Individually Wrapped Candy | Bulk Treat | Pickle, 2.5Ibs
4064.8 out of 5 Stars. 406 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 2 daysBest seller Hot Tamales Fierce Cinnamon Chewy Candy, 4.25 Ounce Theater Box $1.24
Best seller
6 optionsAvailable in additional 6 options$124current price $1.24Options from $1.24 – $18.84Hot Tamales Fierce Cinnamon Chewy Candy, 4.25 Ounce Theater Box
16254.7 out of 5 Stars. 1625 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleHi-Chew Fruit Chew Candy, 4-Flavor Variety Pack, 330 Pieces, 4 lb $39.89
$3989current price $39.89Hi-Chew Fruit Chew Candy, 4-Flavor Variety Pack, 330 Pieces, 4 lb
24 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowSweet's Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy - 3 Lb $24.12
$2412current price $24.12Sweet's Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy - 3 Lb
84.5 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTootsie Child's Play, Assorted Candy, 56 oz. Individually Wrapped, Peanut Free, Gluten Free, Contains Milk. $12.68
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 optionsSponsored$1268current price $12.68Tootsie Child's Play, Assorted Candy, 56 oz. Individually Wrapped, Peanut Free, Gluten Free, Contains Milk.
7864.6 out of 5 Stars. 786 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleBest seller SWEDISH FISH Mini Soft & Chewy Candy, Family Size, Bulk Candy, 1.8 lb $7.97
Best seller
Sponsored$797current price $7.97SWEDISH FISH Mini Soft & Chewy Candy, Family Size, Bulk Candy, 1.8 lb
10464.7 out of 5 Stars. 1046 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleBest seller Dr Pepper Soda Pop, 16.9 fl oz, 6 Pack Bottles $4.48 4.4 ¢/fl oz
Best seller
$448current price $4.484.4 ¢/fl ozDr Pepper Soda Pop, 16.9 fl oz, 6 Pack Bottles
135324.7 out of 5 Stars. 13532 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleBest seller Werther's Original Hard Caramel Candy, 30 oz $10.17
Best seller
15 optionsAvailable in additional 15 options$1017current price $10.17Options from $10.17 – $336.99Werther's Original Hard Caramel Candy, 30 oz
18714.8 out of 5 Stars. 1871 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleTwizzlers Unwrapped Strawberry Licorice 6 lb $14.84 18.6 ¢/oz
$1484current price $14.8418.6 ¢/ozTwizzlers Unwrapped Strawberry Licorice 6 lb
10954.4 out of 5 Stars. 1095 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleJelly Belly Sugar-free Assorted Jelly Beans - 2.8 oz Grab & Go® Bag $6.29
$629current price $6.29Jelly Belly Sugar-free Assorted Jelly Beans - 2.8 oz Grab & Go® Bag
593.7 out of 5 Stars. 59 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowBest seller Skittles Wild Berry Chewy Candy, Sharing Size, 15.6 oz Bag $4.57
Best seller
4 optionsAvailable in additional 4 options$457current price $4.57More options from $2.56Skittles Wild Berry Chewy Candy, Sharing Size, 15.6 oz Bag
37844.7 out of 5 Stars. 3784 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todaySNAP EBT eligibleBest seller Werthers Original Hard Sugar Free Assorted Flavors, Caramel Coffee, Caramel Chocalate, Caramel Candy 7.7 oz $6.82
Best seller
$682current price $6.82Werthers Original Hard Sugar Free Assorted Flavors, Caramel Coffee, Caramel Chocalate, Caramel Candy 7.7 oz
22904.7 out of 5 Stars. 2290 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleHershey's Kisses Milk Chocolate Candy, Family Pack 17.9 oz $9.74
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 options$974current price $9.74Options from $9.74 – $27.26Hershey's Kisses Milk Chocolate Candy, Family Pack 17.9 oz
34224.8 out of 5 Stars. 3422 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleBest seller Smarties Original Candy Rolls 5, Ib $14.16
Best seller
$1416current price $14.16Smarties Original Candy Rolls 5, Ib
3334.7 out of 5 Stars. 333 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todayShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleBest seller Tootsie Pops, Assorted Flavor Gluten Free Lollipops, 10.12 oz $4.44
Best seller
$444current price $4.44Tootsie Pops, Assorted Flavor Gluten Free Lollipops, 10.12 oz
14594.6 out of 5 Stars. 1459 reviewsSave withPickup todayDelivery todaySNAP EBT eligibleBit-O-Honey Candy, 1 Pound Bag, Individually Wrapped Candy, Honey Taffy $10.50 Was $12.99
SponsoredNow$1050current price Now $10.50, Was $12.99$12.99You save $2.49You save$2.49Bit-O-Honey Candy, 1 Pound Bag, Individually Wrapped Candy, Honey Taffy
594.7 out of 5 Stars. 59 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 2 days
About this item
Product details
INGREDIENTS: CORN SYRUP, SUGAR, HYDROGENATED PALM KERNEL OIL WITH SOY LECITHIN, WATER, SALT, PEANUT BUTTER (DRY ROASTED PEANUTS, DEXTROSE, HYDROGENATED COTTONSEED AND/OR RAPEEED OIL, AND SALT), NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL (VANILLA) FLAVOR, CORN STARCH.
CONTAINS: SOY AND PEANUT
info:
We aim to show you accurate product information. Manufacturers, suppliers and others provide what you see here, and we have not verified it. Â
Specifications
Brand
First Choice
Texture
chewy
Size
2 lbs
Container type
Bag
Warranty
Warranty information
Please be aware that the warranty terms on items offered for sale by third party Marketplace sellers may differ from those displayed in this section (if any). To confirm warranty terms on an item offered for sale by a third party Marketplace seller, please use the 'Contact seller' feature on the third party Marketplace seller's information page and request the item's warranty terms prior to purchase.
Popular items in this category
Best selling items that customers love
Taffy Shop Cinniminni, Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy, Personal(7oz) $12.48
26 optionsAvailable in additional 26 options$1248current price $12.48Options from $12.48 – $26.48Taffy Shop Cinniminni, Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy, Personal(7oz)
254.8 out of 5 Stars. 25 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Town Assorted Gourmet Salt Water Taffy, 2.5 Pound $22.90
$2290current price $22.90Taffy Town Assorted Gourmet Salt Water Taffy, 2.5 Pound
93.7 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Shop Caramel Lovers Favorites, Salt Water Taffy(32oz) $26.48
24 optionsAvailable in additional 24 options$2648current price $26.48More options from $12.48Taffy Shop Caramel Lovers Favorites, Salt Water Taffy(32oz)
164.3 out of 5 Stars. 16 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Shop Tropical Coconut Salt Water Super Soft Taffy - Personal (7oz) Bag $12.48
29 optionsAvailable in additional 29 options$1248current price $12.48Options from $12.48 – $26.48Taffy Shop Tropical Coconut Salt Water Super Soft Taffy - Personal (7oz) Bag
43.8 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Shop "Favorites" Mix Salt Water Super Soft Taffy(7oz) $12.48
$1248current price $12.48Taffy Shop "Favorites" Mix Salt Water Super Soft Taffy(7oz)
233.6 out of 5 Stars. 23 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 2 daysSweetGourmet Assorted Whipped Salt Water Taffy | Boardwalk Bulk Candy | 2 Pound $17.19
4 optionsAvailable in additional 4 options$1719current price $17.19More options from $13.69SweetGourmet Assorted Whipped Salt Water Taffy | Boardwalk Bulk Candy | 2 Pound
213.7 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Shop Tropical Favorites, Salt Water Taffy (7oz) $12.48
$1248current price $12.48Taffy Shop Tropical Favorites, Salt Water Taffy (7oz)
64.2 out of 5 Stars. 6 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 2 daysBest seller Laffy Taffy Assorted, Mini Bars, Chewy Candy in a Variety of Fruity Flavors, 22 oz Bag $8.47 38.5 ¢/oz
Best seller
$847current price $8.4738.5 ¢/ozLaffy Taffy Assorted, Mini Bars, Chewy Candy in a Variety of Fruity Flavors, 22 oz Bag
10914.7 out of 5 Stars. 1091 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleLaffy Taffy Candy, Stretchy and Tangy, Strawberry Flavor, 1.5 Ounce Bar $0.98 65.3 ¢/oz
$098current price $0.9865.3 ¢/oz+$5.98 shippingLaffy Taffy Candy, Stretchy and Tangy, Strawberry Flavor, 1.5 Ounce Bar
143.8 out of 5 Stars. 14 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Town Saltwater Taffy - Sassy Watermelon | Gourmet | Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies | 12 Ounce $9.99
15 optionsAvailable in additional 15 options$999current price $9.99Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy - Sassy Watermelon | Gourmet | Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies | 12 Ounce
1904.8 out of 5 Stars. 190 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 3+ daysBest seller Howe Salt Water Taffy Taffy Candy, 13 oz, Bag $4.74
Best seller
3 optionsAvailable in additional 3 options$474current price $4.74Options from $4.74 – $9.55Howe Salt Water Taffy Taffy Candy, 13 oz, Bag
4944.6 out of 5 Stars. 494 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleCocomel Organic Coconut Milk Caramels Sea Salt, 3.5 oz $9.99
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 options$999current price $9.99Cocomel Organic Coconut Milk Caramels Sea Salt, 3.5 oz
10624.7 out of 5 Stars. 1062 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowTaffy Shop Pterodactyl Ptaffy, Breakfast Cereal Salt Water Taffy(7oz) $12.48
25 optionsAvailable in additional 25 options$1248current price $12.48Options from $12.48 – $26.48Taffy Shop Pterodactyl Ptaffy, Breakfast Cereal Salt Water Taffy(7oz)
Shipping, arrives in 3+ daysLaffy Taffy Rope Banana Candy, 0.81oz (24 Count) $13.95 Was $16.99
Now$1395current price Now $13.95, Was $16.99$16.99You save $3.04You save$3.04Laffy Taffy Rope Banana Candy, 0.81oz (24 Count)
74.1 out of 5 Stars. 7 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysTaffy Shop Choco Coco Loco, Chocolate, Coconut, Caramel Salt Water Taffy(7oz) $12.48
21 optionsAvailable in additional 21 options$1248current price $12.48Options from $12.48 – $26.48Taffy Shop Choco Coco Loco, Chocolate, Coconut, Caramel Salt Water Taffy(7oz)
35 out of 5 Stars. 3 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ daysWonka Stretchy Tangy Laffy Taffy, Grape 1.5-Ounce Packets (Pack of 24) $31.97
$3197current price $31.97Wonka Stretchy Tangy Laffy Taffy, Grape 1.5-Ounce Packets (Pack of 24)
85 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives in 2 daysLaffy Taffy Rope - Case of 24 (Grape) $12.50
$1250current price $12.50Laffy Taffy Rope - Case of 24 (Grape)
94.6 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviewsSave withShipping, arrives tomorrowTaffy Town Candies- Christmas Assortment, Gourmet, Nougat-Style, Soft & Delicious, Sumer Snack Treats, Party Good Candies, 5LB $29.99
3 optionsAvailable in additional 3 options$2999current price $29.99Options from $29.99 – $35.09Taffy Town Candies- Christmas Assortment, Gourmet, Nougat-Style, Soft & Delicious, Sumer Snack Treats, Party Good Candies, 5LB
214.9 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviewsShipping, arrives in 3+ days
Customer ratings & reviews
How item rating is calculated
Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Sort by |
Showing 1-3 of 10 reviews
Jun 20, 2025
Sheri
Item details
Sold and shipped byFirstChoiceCandyFlavor: Salt Water
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
This is very good taffy. I recommend to anyone who is thinking about buying it. Don't wait to long or it might be gone when you want it. Thank you to company that sold it it came earlier than I expected
Helpful?4VBE9G0AZ9XY716078135
Feb 6, 2026
brian
Item details
Sold and shipped byFirstChoiceCandyFlavor: Buttered Popcorn
4 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
more like buttercream than popcorn
it's good that is more like a buttercream other than popcorn I've had other brands that taste more like it's flavors good but not what it claims to be
Helpful?4VBE9G0AZ9XY716078135
Sep 17, 2025
Crap
Item details
Sold and shipped byFirstChoiceCandyFlavor: Salt Water
2 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
It's eatable. Don't like the texture, and the flavors are mediocre.
Helpful?4VBE9G0AZ9XY716078135
