Maybelline Lasting Drama Waterproof Gel Pencil, 601 Sleek Onyx

I really hate seeing all these negative comments about this pencil but mine works just fine. It looks like plastic before you sharpen it but it really does sharpen. I used a cover girl sharpener and it worked just fine for me. It's the best eyeliner I've ever owned and used.

I bought this a week ago, and their glazed toffee is the most lovely shade of brown eyeliner I have ever put on (I have tried high end products, everything across the board with brown). It stayed perfectly all day (Seriously all day). It has a very silky texture, but I don’t mind that it’s not a super hard product. It’s actually more comfy on. It is my absolute favorite eyeliner, BUT this company has done a terrible job showing how to get more product out. The pencil twists, so I thought it was mechanical. It is plastic- so I wouldn’t have thought to sharpen plastic. I bought another pencil thinking that one was defective. I shouldn’t have to google how to get the product out. In fact, that is how I got to this site. However, once I learned that you sharpen it, it was too difficult to sharpen. The product doesn’t have a sharpen end when sharpened, but I don’t mind that as it still goes on beautifully to me.