After losing her cherished job at the local library, shy type A librarian Amy Merrit is coerced into helping her sister Katina at an audition for the reality dating show "American Cinderella". When she accidentally catches the eye of the executive producer, she is cast instead of her sister.Her romantic whirl begins with meeting each of the eight possible Prince Charming's including a fastidious dentist anxious to market a new veneer design, a handsome aging NFL player who wants to jump-start a new career, a dark-hearted investment broker, a high school teacher, a body-builder, a contractor, a former high school basketball champion and a male model. Will Amy find true love despite being hindered by a vengeful producer, a scheming sister, a lying suitor and, an unexpected pregnancy?