Gym owner Ivy Lowell is looking for a Mrs. The almost-40-year-old retired stuntwoman swipes on dating apps like it's her job, armed with her "Wife List" of desires and dealbreakers. But no one keeps her attention like the delicious owner of Besos Bakery.
Analeigh Fonseca works hard and plays, well, almost not at all. She's hustled her ass off to build her business by 25, and has the added financial pressure of helping her younger sister pay for college. The highlight to her workday is a visit from one of her regulars, the blonde bombshell whose crush on Ana is as obvious as her sweet tooth.
When Ana's coven of witchy friends persuades her to get out of her chef whites and bar hop on Halloween, she runs into Ivy, and they flirt and dance the night away. But their fun is cut short when Ivy has to use her martial arts training on a drunk dude who can't take Ana's "no."
Impressed, Ana proposes an arrangement: after-hours gym sessions in exchange for pastries. Ana might reciprocate Ivy's crush, but it can't go further - Ivy is wealthy, accomplished, and already everywhere Ana is trying to get. Ana barely has time to sleep. When could she pencil in a relationship?
Ivy thinks she can maintain professional distance, but the more she gets to know Ana, the more she rethinks who would make her happy. Ana is surely too young and too much of a workaholic to settle down, and yet Ivy is bewitched by her.
What happens when you meet someone who could be the love of your life, but they're in a different life stage?
Pickup or delivery?