Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boot, Dove/Stratus, 12

I actually bought these boots 5 years ago. To trek thru the slush & snow as a college commuter walking 1mi+ every day in Rochester, NY weather. These boots kept my feet warm & dry for 5 solid years and they STILL have life in them. I took them with me ice fishing that's how warm they are. I'm on here buying the ice maiden II now. I cannot compliment enough how good the construction is on these shoes. Beautifully engineered.

SIZING: I typically wear a 9 in regular shoes and an 8.5 if I'm buying wide. I got these in a 9W because they website said they ran small and I wanted to be able to wear thicker socks. I'm very happy with the 9W! I think I could have gotten away with the 8.5W but it would have been borderline short. The 9W do not look or feel sloppy. COMFORT: I love how the fabric is flexible around the ankle. I have had issues with boots being too stiff which causes rubbing on my heel. These have a very comfortable foot bed and I can add my arch inserts for extra support. HIGHLY recommend.