Walmart LocalFinds
Treasure Keeper profile photo

Treasure Keeper

1355 Paramount Pkwy
Batavia, IL 60510, US
|
(630) 761-1500

Seller Reviews

4.8 out of 5
658 ratings100 reviews

About the seller

We're a small family run business reselling fine collectibles and toys. It started with a single Beanie Baby, Bubbles the fish. Since then we've expanded to sell all kinds of toys and collectibles. While our inventory is ever changing and expanding, our mission is steadfast: Spreading joy through to…
Business Name: Treasure Keeper
Report an issue with this seller

Top picks from seller

Seller reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars
658 ratings100 reviews
How seller rating is calculated

Showing 1 - 10 of 100 reviews

Feb 16, 2026
Alice
Item bought
Ty Beanie Babies - Peace Bear
5 out of 5 stars review

Hard to believe these are still floating around! Cute, new, good price, has it's OG tag, I love the little bear.

Feb 6, 2026
Terrence
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby: Jinglepup the Dog - Green Hat - White Tail | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
5 out of 5 stars review

I want to give thanks to Treasure Keeper for shipping this Jingle Pup in a timely manner. It came in mint condition and brought back memories of prior Jingle Pups. Thank you once again for an Additional touch of Christmas magic.

Feb 3, 2026
Mutt
Item bought
Swarovski Figurine: 230586 Pierrot | Faceted Crystal
5 out of 5 stars review

This was a gift to a Swarovski collector. She was ecstatic when she saw him very beautiful

Jan 30, 2026
Sharon
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby - Kayla the Kangaroo – 30th Anniversary - Stuffed Animal
5 out of 5 stars review

I was so pleased with the item! It was delivered in a timely manner! Just in time for Christmas

Jan 30, 2026
Selena
5 out of 5 stars review

The item shipped fast, was just as described, and was good quality. This was an excellent transaction, thank you.

Jan 29, 2026
THPaul
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby - Dumbo The Elephant - 6"
5 out of 5 stars review

Absolutely no problems. Shipped quickly and item arrived on time and exactly as advertised.

Jan 29, 2026
Candis
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby: Quackers the Duck | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
3 out of 5 stars review

Good quality. Arrived quickly. My only thing is I thought it would be bigger. My son has one at preschool and he loves it so I was trying to get him one and this is about a third the size. He still liked it though.

Jan 27, 2026
jollyann2
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby: Pellet the Hamster | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
5 out of 5 stars review

Always a pleasure ordering from Treasure Keeper… they always add a personal touch and for that, I would 100 percent recommend this company to others!

Jan 19, 2026
Tamara
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby: Congo the Gorilla | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
5 out of 5 stars review

Got exactly what I ordered. Just a delay in shipping but otherwise no problems

Jan 15, 2026
Hunnybee
Item bought
Ty Beanie Baby: Fridge the Polar Bear | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
5 out of 5 stars review

Arrived very quickly and matched the description perfectly. Very cute.