New Pet EssentialsAll Bird SuppliesAll ChickensAll Farm AnimalsAll Fish Tanks and SuppliesAll HamstersAll RatsAll Small PetsBird PerchesBird ToysCat Collars, Leashes & HarnessesCat ExerciseCat Halloween EssentialsCat Litter and AccessoriesCat ScratchersCat ToysCat TreesChicken CoopsDog BedsDog Bowls and AccessoriesDog Clothes and CostumesDog Collars, Leashes, and HarnessesDog EnrichmentDog ExerciseDog Halloween EssentialsDog Potty TrainingDog ToysFerret CagesFish Tank DecorationFish TanksHalloween Pet Accessories And ApparelHamster ToysKitten SuppliesKONG Dog ToysPuppy SuppliesPuppy ToysRat ToysShop All Pet Halloween
Sort by|
New Pet EssentialsAll Bird SuppliesAll ChickensAll Farm AnimalsAll Fish Tanks and SuppliesAll HamstersAll RatsAll Small PetsBird PerchesBird ToysCat Collars, Leashes & HarnessesCat ExerciseCat Halloween EssentialsCat Litter and AccessoriesCat ScratchersCat ToysCat TreesChicken CoopsDog BedsDog Bowls and AccessoriesDog Clothes and CostumesDog Collars, Leashes, and HarnessesDog EnrichmentDog ExerciseDog Halloween EssentialsDog Potty TrainingDog ToysFerret CagesFish Tank DecorationFish TanksHalloween Pet Accessories And ApparelHamster ToysKitten SuppliesKONG Dog ToysPuppy SuppliesPuppy ToysRat ToysShop All Pet Halloween
Color Pets(157)
Uses item details. Price when purchased online
Crayola 6" Aromatherapy Yellow Purple Blue Crayon Plush Squeaker Pet Toy- 3PK $12.99
$1299
current price $12.99Crayola 6" Aromatherapy Yellow Purple Blue Crayon Plush Squeaker Pet Toy- 3PK
Stuffed Husky Plush Toy, Ultra Soft Cute Dog Plush, Small Sitting Puppy Doll for Bed Desk Decor Gift, Cuddly Animal Toy for All Ages
Stuffed Husky Plush Toy, Ultra Soft Cute Dog Plush, Small Sitting Puppy Doll for Bed Desk Decor Gift, Cuddly Animal Toy for All Ages
Squishmallow 8 Inch Hello Kitty Black Cat Halloween Sanrio Plush Toy From $8.50
4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsFrom$850
Squishmallow 8 Inch Hello Kitty Black Cat Halloween Sanrio Plush Toy
1564.9 out of 5 Stars. 156 reviews
Toy Walking Barking Faux Polka Dot Dalmatian Spotted Springer Spaniel Catahoula Leopard Dog Puppy (1 dog in Random Color) $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99Toy Walking Barking Faux Polka Dot Dalmatian Spotted Springer Spaniel Catahoula Leopard Dog Puppy (1 dog in Random Color)
Talking Dog Toy, Talking Pet Toy, Kids Speak Talking Sound Record Mimicry Pet Toy, Cute Dog Style, Battery Operated, 20x15cm, White Yellow Color, Interactive Kids Gift $7.29
$729
current price $7.29Talking Dog Toy, Talking Pet Toy, Kids Speak Talking Sound Record Mimicry Pet Toy, Cute Dog Style, Battery Operated, 20x15cm, White Yellow Color, Interactive Kids Gift
BESTSKY 2026 New Plush Cat Toy for Kids with Realistic Kitten Shape in Assorted Colors for Playing at Home for Interactive Play,Kids' Entertainment,Cuddling,Pretend Play,Gift Giving. $14.38
$1438
current price $14.38BESTSKY 2026 New Plush Cat Toy for Kids with Realistic Kitten Shape in Assorted Colors for Playing at Home for Interactive Play,Kids' Entertainment,Cuddling,Pretend Play,Gift Giving.
Squishmallows Original 12 inch Autumn the Cat w/Potion - Child's Ultra Soft Plush Toy - Halloween 2025 $29.99 Was $38.88
Now$2999
current price Now $29.99, Was $38.88$38.88
Squishmallows Original 12 inch Autumn the Cat w/Potion - Child's Ultra Soft Plush Toy - Halloween 2025
25 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Warren London Critter Color Temporary Pet Fur Color Hair Coloring Tool Kit $13.99
$1399
current price $13.99Warren London Critter Color Temporary Pet Fur Color Hair Coloring Tool Kit
45 out of 5 Stars. 4 reviews
Halloween Cat Stuffed Animal, 8.66 Inch Stitched Kitty Plush with Cross Eye Detail, Soft Halloween Toys for Sofa Bedroom Decor and Halloween Gifts (Pink)
Halloween Cat Stuffed Animal, 8.66 Inch Stitched Kitty Plush with Cross Eye Detail, Soft Halloween Toys for Sofa Bedroom Decor and Halloween Gifts (Pink)
Ty Pluffies - Puppers the Brown Dog - Stuffed Animal $95.00 Was $118.75
Now$9500
current price Now $95.00, Was $118.75$118.75
Ty Pluffies - Puppers the Brown Dog - Stuffed Animal
15.7-inch Shar Pei Dog Plush Toy - Wrinkled Stuffed Animal Pillow, Cute Car Bed Sofa Decor, Unique Gift for Girls, Halloween & Christmas Present Brown From $9.61
From$961
15.7-inch Shar Pei Dog Plush Toy - Wrinkled Stuffed Animal Pillow, Cute Car Bed Sofa Decor, Unique Gift for Girls, Halloween & Christmas Present Brown
Reduced price Steal A Brainrot Meowl Plushie - 10 INCH Steal A Brainrot Character Stuffed Animals - Best Birthday Christmas Halloween Gifts & Decorations for Gamers From $8.85
4 options
Available in additional 4 optionsFrom$885
Steal A Brainrot Meowl Plushie - 10 INCH Steal A Brainrot Character Stuffed Animals - Best Birthday Christmas Halloween Gifts & Decorations for Gamers
23.5 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
SIYTUAU Electric Plush Walking Cat Toy With Leash Simulation Moving Pet Interactive Yellow Feline 95 Polyester 5 Spandex Stuffed Animal Toy For Kids $12.37
$1237
current price $12.37SIYTUAU Electric Plush Walking Cat Toy With Leash Simulation Moving Pet Interactive Yellow Feline 95 Polyester 5 Spandex Stuffed Animal Toy For Kids
Electronic Plush Puppy Dog Toy, Fun Interactive Toys,Walks,Barks,Shake Tail,Animal Dog, Gift for Girls Boys Age 3-6 Year Old
Electronic Plush Puppy Dog Toy, Fun Interactive Toys,Walks,Barks,Shake Tail,Animal Dog, Gift for Girls Boys Age 3-6 Year Old
Ty Flippables Sequin Plush - Jinx the Halloween Cat Medium (10") - Stuffed Animal $18.89
$1889
current price $18.89Ty Flippables Sequin Plush - Jinx the Halloween Cat Medium (10") - Stuffed Animal
ToysYGift Moving Pet Plush Toy, Interactive Dog Toy Pet Bouncing Balls, Cartoon Pig Plush Sound Electronic Dog Toy, Cute Shake Bounce Toys for Dog CatsCute Shake Bounce Toys for Dog From $6.96
From$696
ToysYGift Moving Pet Plush Toy, Interactive Dog Toy Pet Bouncing Balls, Cartoon Pig Plush Sound Electronic Dog Toy, Cute Shake Bounce Toys for Dog CatsCute Shake Bounce Toys for Dog
54 out of 5 Stars. 5 reviews
Hatchimals CollEGGtibles Mermal Magic Underwater Aquarium $34.99
$3499
current price $34.99Hatchimals CollEGGtibles Mermal Magic Underwater Aquarium
245 out of 5 Stars. 24 reviews
Kitten Plush, Cute Stuffed Animal, Cat in Pot Plush, Whimsical Plush, Peach Style 7X4 in Multi-Color Calico Cat Tree Plush, Soft Snuggly Small Plush, Perfect Nursery Accent Decor, From $9.19
From$919
Kitten Plush, Cute Stuffed Animal, Cat in Pot Plush, Whimsical Plush, Peach Style 7X4 in Multi-Color Calico Cat Tree Plush, Soft Snuggly Small Plush, Perfect Nursery Accent Decor,
Squishmallows Original 12 inch Callista the Halloween Cat - Child's Ultra Soft Stuffed Plush Toy $25.00
$2500
current price $25.00Squishmallows Original 12 inch Callista the Halloween Cat - Child's Ultra Soft Stuffed Plush Toy
193.5 out of 5 Stars. 19 reviews
DOLITY Realistic Puppy Dog Toy Cute Kids Valentines Day Gifts for Home Home Bedroom White From $9.99
From$999
DOLITY Realistic Puppy Dog Toy Cute Kids Valentines Day Gifts for Home Home Bedroom White
Bwiyojiz Stuffed Animals Toys Pet Special Large Small Dog Resistants Indoor Supplies Toy, Gifts for Daughter
Bwiyojiz Stuffed Animals Toys Pet Special Large Small Dog Resistants Indoor Supplies Toy, Gifts for Daughter
25 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Interactive Cat for Indoor Cats, Colorful Plush Crinkle Balls with Catnip, Kittens for Boredom and Exercise, Cat Enrichment Pet Supplies (Random Colors 1Pcs) A From $4.00
From$400
Interactive Cat for Indoor Cats, Colorful Plush Crinkle Balls with Catnip, Kittens for Boredom and Exercise, Cat Enrichment Pet Supplies (Random Colors 1Pcs) A
SHURUIMA Fluffy Fur Plush Dog Biting Chew Toy, Durable Stitched Multi Color Interactive Stuffed Pet Play Doll, 12.2 Inch Assorted A/B/C Tone Indoor Outdoor Puppy Fetch Toy, 1 Count
SHURUIMA Fluffy Fur Plush Dog Biting Chew Toy, Durable Stitched Multi Color Interactive Stuffed Pet Play Doll, 12.2 Inch Assorted A/B/C Tone Indoor Outdoor Puppy Fetch Toy, 1 Count
Peeps Squeaky 5 Inch Pet Toy For Dogs, Color Is Chosen At Random $19.99
$1999
current price $19.99Peeps Squeaky 5 Inch Pet Toy For Dogs, Color Is Chosen At Random
Walking Dog Toy Wagging Tail Puppy Affenpinscher Maltese Bichon Frise With Sounds Furry Cute in Random Color $11.99
$1199
current price $11.99Walking Dog Toy Wagging Tail Puppy Affenpinscher Maltese Bichon Frise With Sounds Furry Cute in Random Color
15 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
TTJ Cute Plushies Mini Gifts Cute Decorative Pillows for Couch 1PC Pull String Small Doll Cute Moggie Dog Wagging Tail Doll Shiba Inu Small Toy Gift 's Holiday Gifts Birthday Gifts $9.99
$999
current price $9.99TTJ Cute Plushies Mini Gifts Cute Decorative Pillows for Couch 1PC Pull String Small Doll Cute Moggie Dog Wagging Tail Doll Shiba Inu Small Toy Gift 's Holiday Gifts Birthday Gifts
Ty Beanie Baby: Seadog the Dog | Stuffed Animal | MWMT $12.89
$1289
current price $12.89Ty Beanie Baby: Seadog the Dog | Stuffed Animal | MWMT
25 out of 5 Stars. 2 reviews
Halloween Devil Bunny Stuffed Animal, 8.66 Inch Gothic Rabbit Plush, Soft Halloween Toys for Sofa Bedroom Decor, Halloween Gifts and Trick or Treat Party Displays (Red and Black) $15.99
$1599
current price $15.99Halloween Devil Bunny Stuffed Animal, 8.66 Inch Gothic Rabbit Plush, Soft Halloween Toys for Sofa Bedroom Decor, Halloween Gifts and Trick or Treat Party Displays (Red and Black)
Clearance Bwiyojiz Stuffed Animals Toys Trendy Roast Chicken and Turkey for Pet Interesting Dogs Cats User-friendly Chewers Barkers Toy, Home Gifts, Orange From $3.99
From$399
Bwiyojiz Stuffed Animals Toys Trendy Roast Chicken and Turkey for Pet Interesting Dogs Cats User-friendly Chewers Barkers Toy, Home Gifts, Orange
Walking Dog Toy Wagging Tail Puppy Siberian Husky With Sounds Furry Cute in Random Color $12.99
$1299
current price $12.99Walking Dog Toy Wagging Tail Puppy Siberian Husky With Sounds Furry Cute in Random Color
Walking and Barking Puppy Dog Toy, Plush Puppy Dog Toy, Interactive Dog Toy for for 2 3 4 Year Old Boys, Gift for Girls Grandchildren From $8.69
From$869
Walking and Barking Puppy Dog Toy, Plush Puppy Dog Toy, Interactive Dog Toy for for 2 3 4 Year Old Boys, Gift for Girls Grandchildren
Interactive Walking & Meowing Stuffed Animal - Electronic Moving Plush Toy with Surprise Collar for Kids, Fun Pet Lovers Gift White Was $10.84
Interactive Walking & Meowing Stuffed Animal - Electronic Moving Plush Toy with Surprise Collar for Kids, Fun Pet Lovers Gift White
Look Who Crunching Animals - Assorted Colors - 8 in. - Case of 30 - Fun & Safe Playtime $21.25
$2125
current price $21.25Look Who Crunching Animals - Assorted Colors - 8 in. - Case of 30 - Fun & Safe Playtime
Clearance Plush Pangolin Squeaky Dog Toy - Cute Stuffed Animal with Sound, Soft Plush Material in Camel Color - for Puppies, Small Dogs, Kids as Birthday or Holiday Gift From $6.09
From$609
Plush Pangolin Squeaky Dog Toy - Cute Stuffed Animal with Sound, Soft Plush Material in Camel Color - for Puppies, Small Dogs, Kids as Birthday or Holiday Gift
25cm Cute Pomeranian Plush Toy with Lace Collar, Soft Stuffed Puppy in White/Brown for Kids and Dog Lovers
25cm Cute Pomeranian Plush Toy with Lace Collar, Soft Stuffed Puppy in White/Brown for Kids and Dog Lovers
Halloween Black Cat Stuffed Animal, 13.7 in Vampire Kitty Plush, Halloween Indoor Decoration for Table Fireplace, Trick Or Treat Halloween Party Gift (Black) From $17.99
From$1799
Halloween Black Cat Stuffed Animal, 13.7 in Vampire Kitty Plush, Halloween Indoor Decoration for Table Fireplace, Trick Or Treat Halloween Party Gift (Black)
Fruit Shaped Plush Mouse Cat Interactive Toy, Soft Polyester Squeaky Pet Chew Toy, Cute Colorful Kitten Teething Toy, Indoor Play Bonding Companion Toy for Cats Daily Entertainment, 1Pc
Fruit Shaped Plush Mouse Cat Interactive Toy, Soft Polyester Squeaky Pet Chew Toy, Cute Colorful Kitten Teething Toy, Indoor Play Bonding Companion Toy for Cats Daily Entertainment, 1Pc
Clearance Puppy Squeaking Plush Dog Toy Bag Small Plush Puppy Chewing Toy Loose and Squeaking Dog Toy Cute Plush Pet Toy, Yellow 1PC From $5.03
From$503
Puppy Squeaking Plush Dog Toy Bag Small Plush Puppy Chewing Toy Loose and Squeaking Dog Toy Cute Plush Pet Toy, Yellow 1PC
OEFNTAC Toys Simulation Stuffed Cat Toy Plush for Kids Birthday Gift Cuddling and Decorative Play Halloween
OEFNTAC Toys Simulation Stuffed Cat Toy Plush for Kids Birthday Gift Cuddling and Decorative Play Halloween
Rottweiler Simulated 3d Simulation Standing Black Dog Plush Stuffed Doberman Animal Halloween Gift $16.99
$1699
current price $16.99Rottweiler Simulated 3d Simulation Standing Black Dog Plush Stuffed Doberman Animal Halloween Gift
Popular in Color Pets
Related Products
OAVQHLG3B Plush Dog Toy with Squeaker & Crinkle Paper for Chewing, Multi-color, Large
OAVQHLG3B Plush Dog Toy with Squeaker & Crinkle Paper for Chewing, Multi-color, Large$2.77current price $2.77Squeaky Dog Toys for Large Dogs, No Stuffing Crinkle Paper Plush Dog Toys for Puppy Teething, Dog Toys, Durable Interactive Dog Toys for Small Medium Dogs, Dog Squeaky Octopus Toys(4 Pack)
Squeaky Dog Toys for Large Dogs, No Stuffing Crinkle Paper Plush Dog Toys for Puppy Teething, Dog Toys, Durable Interactive Dog Toys for Small Medium Dogs, Dog Squeaky Octopus Toys(4 Pack)$18.30current price $18.30Fringe Studio 3-Piece Plush Dog Toy Set with 3 Toys
Fringe Studio 3-Piece Plush Dog Toy Set with 3 Toys$12.99current price $12.99Dog Gift Box 4 Piece Blue Plush & Ball Toy Set AVAILABLE IN BULK PACKS TOO(1 Gift Pack)
Dog Gift Box 4 Piece Blue Plush & Ball Toy Set AVAILABLE IN BULK PACKS TOO(1 Gift Pack)$22.99current price $22.99Squeaky Crinkle Interactive Dog Toy Soft Fabric Chew Play For Daily And Boredom With Breakfast Bread Design
Squeaky Crinkle Interactive Dog Toy Soft Fabric Chew Play For Daily And Boredom With Breakfast Bread Design$6.47current price $6.47Woof The Pupsicle Treat Dispensing Dog Toy, Forest Green, Small
Woof The Pupsicle Treat Dispensing Dog Toy, Forest Green, Small$19.99current price $19.99MULTIPET Duckworth Plush Filled Dog Toy, Assorted Colors, (Pack of 1) E11
MULTIPET Duckworth Plush Filled Dog Toy, Assorted Colors, (Pack of 1) E11$14.29current price $14.29