This tasted so bad we had to throw it out. I thought perhaps I had gotten bad box. It was a light brown color with a horrible, bitter taste to it. After reading the reviews, I can see it's just a problem with the product. I still have a bad taste in my mouth from it. I wasted 3 cups of milk and a pack of graham crackers I used to make a crust. Plus, I will have to make a trip to the store to return it.

Wow, so bitter we threw it out after making it. Wish we had read reviews before buying. This is literally the first review I've ever done for a mix, as we've never encountered something like this. It wasn't just “a little off” or “not our thing”, it was inedible. The flavor was actually fine, but it has an incredibly bitter aftertaste that was like nothing I've ever experienced in a food. It was as bitter as the product they sell for your fingernails to break the habit of biting your nails. So bad we thought it was a mistake with something we did and we tested everything we used to make it thinking it had to be accidental contamination until we read these other reviews. Please either reformulate this completely or take it off the market. Didn't even feel safe giving it to the dog so we threw it in the trash. In case someone is wondering, it comes in a two part mix and we made and tested each part separately and both mixes had this bitter component (yellow part much more bitter than the white but both inedible).