GOOD AMERICAN womens Good 90s Icon Black Straight Jean, 14, Black

I own the Good 90's but those are 62% Cotton and 38% Lyocell in a size 4. I asked the Good American agents what size I should buy n the Good Icon and she suggested my regular size 4. That was very disappointing because these jeans here are 100% Cotton and do not stretch. The first pair I ordered was a 6 but that was wayyyyyy to tight, I just received the size 8 and they fit a lot better. They do feel stiff and they do not hug my curbs like the Good 90's. In length they are a little longer on me than on the model but they have that 90's vibe I like. I like the color and style, cotton usually stretches a bit once you wear it but it also shrinks when you wash. Once I do that I will have a better idea if I will ever purchase this material again. For reference I am 5'5, weigh 150, 28" waist.

Super bummed, I was so excited to get these jeans as they were my first good American jeans. Unfortunately the sizing is way off. These were SO tight. I'm not sure if I would size up once or twice. They also were not like pictured. The bottoms are almost flared.