Hero image 0 of Sour Punch Straws Fruity Mystery Candy, 4.5oz Tray, 0 of 12
Sour Punch Straws Fruity Mystery Candy, 4.5oz Tray
Ingredients
Ingredients
CORN SYRUP, HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP, WHEAT FLOUR, SUGAR, CITRIC ACID, MALIC ACID, TARTARIC ACID, GLYCERYL MONOSTEARATE, GLYCERIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, COLOR ADDED RED 40, BLUE 1 AND YELLOW 5 (TARTRAZINE).
Key item features
- One Secret Flavor. Good Luck. — Black straws, zero hints, and a fruity mystery flavor that'll have you and your crew debating from the first bite to the last straw in the tray
- The Ultimate Blind Taste Test — Pass the tray around and see who guesses it first. Spoiler: everyone thinks they know. Nobody agrees. That's the whole point.
- Sour Sugar Coating on Every Mysterious Bite — Whatever the flavor is, it's fully smothered in Sour Punch's signature sour coating. Bold, chewy, and impossible to put down even when it's driving you crazy
- Soft, Chewy & Built for the Long Debate — These aren't quick snacks. Mystery Straws are made for the kind of hangout where everyone has a theory and nobody wants to stop until they figure it out
- 4.5oz of Pure Intrigue — Plenty of straws to share the experience, run multiple taste tests, or go back for another round when your first guess was definitely wrong
- Low Fat, Low Sodium, All Punch — The mystery doesn't stop at the flavor. Halal and Kosher certified because everyone deserves a chance to crack the code
Specs
- FlavorMystery
- BrandSour Punch
- TextureGummy
- Size4.5 oz
- Piece count22
- Container typeBag
Current price is USD$4.88$1.08/oz
Price when purchased online
Out of stock
How do you want your item?
Out of stock
SNAP EBT eligible
Similar items you might like
Based on what customers bought
Feastables MrBeast Sour Strikes, Raspberry Flavor Gummy Candy, 7.5 oz Bag $3.92 52.3 ¢/oz
Sponsored$392current price $3.9252.3 ¢/ozFeastables MrBeast Sour Strikes, Raspberry Flavor Gummy Candy, 7.5 oz Bag
2314.6 out of 5 Stars. 231 reviewsSave with
Delivery as soon as 1 hourPickup as soon as tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleSour Strips Bites Rainbow Flavored Chewy, Sour Candy Bag, 6.35 oz $3.92 30.9 ¢/oz
Sponsored$392current price $3.9230.9 ¢/ozSour Strips Bites Rainbow Flavored Chewy, Sour Candy Bag, 6.35 oz
464.5 out of 5 Stars. 46 reviewsSave withDelivery as soon as 1 hourPickup as soon as tomorrowSNAP EBT eligibleBest seller Sour Punch Bites Assorted Flavors Candy, 9oz Resealable Bag $9.00 Was $13.28 $1.00/oz
Best seller
6 optionsAvailable in additional 6 options$900current price $9.00, Was $13.28$13.28$1.00/ozSour Punch Bites Assorted Flavors Candy, 9oz Resealable Bag
7974.6 out of 5 Stars. 797 reviewsBest seller SOUR PATCH KIDS Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 3.5 oz $3.72 35.4 ¢/oz
Best seller
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 options$372current price $3.7235.4 ¢/ozSOUR PATCH KIDS Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 3.5 oz
16244.7 out of 5 Stars. 1624 reviewsSOUR PATCH KIDS BITES SOFT CANDY 1.8 OZ $4.99 $2.77/oz
$499current price $4.99$2.77/ozSOUR PATCH KIDS BITES SOFT CANDY 1.8 OZ
2104.8 out of 5 Stars. 210 reviewsSOUR PATCH KIDS Glow Ups Strawberry-Watermelon Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 6.7 oz $4.97 74.2 ¢/oz
$497current price $4.9774.2 ¢/ozSOUR PATCH KIDS Glow Ups Strawberry-Watermelon Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 6.7 oz
5264.7 out of 5 Stars. 526 reviewsMike and Ike Mega Mix SOUR! Chewy Candy, 4.25 Ounce, 1 Count $6.50 $1.53/oz
$650current price $6.50$1.53/ozMike and Ike Mega Mix SOUR! Chewy Candy, 4.25 Ounce, 1 Count
3394.7 out of 5 Stars. 339 reviewsTrolli Electric Crawlers 4.25 Ounce Peg Bag $2.24 52.7 ¢/oz
$224current price $2.2452.7 ¢/ozTrolli Electric Crawlers 4.25 Ounce Peg Bag
4054.4 out of 5 Stars. 405 reviewsRollback SOUR PATCH KIDS Strawberry Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, Share Size, 12 oz $3.96 Was $4.84 33.0 ¢/oz
Rollback
$396current price $3.96, Was $4.84$4.8433.0 ¢/ozSOUR PATCH KIDS Strawberry Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, Share Size, 12 oz
3884.6 out of 5 Stars. 388 reviewsRetro Sours Tangerine 2.12oz Tin $2.96 $1.40/oz
3 optionsAvailable in additional 3 options$296current price $2.96$1.40/ozRetro Sours Tangerine 2.12oz Tin
2394.6 out of 5 Stars. 239 reviewsBest seller MIKE AND IKE Sour Blue Raspberry flavored Chewy Candy $6.99 $1.65/oz
Best seller
6 optionsAvailable in additional 6 options$699current price $6.99$1.65/ozMIKE AND IKE Sour Blue Raspberry flavored Chewy Candy
4794.6 out of 5 Stars. 479 reviewsSour Punch Straws, Blue Raspberry Chewy Candy, 4.5oz $2.28 50.7 ¢/oz
$228current price $2.2850.7 ¢/ozSour Punch Straws, Blue Raspberry Chewy Candy, 4.5oz
614.8 out of 5 Stars. 61 reviewsRollback SOUR PATCH KIDS Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, Share Size, 12 oz $3.96 Was $4.84 33.0 ¢/oz
Rollback
$396current price $3.96, Was $4.84$4.8433.0 ¢/ozSOUR PATCH KIDS Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, Share Size, 12 oz
13644.7 out of 5 Stars. 1364 reviewsSOUR PUNCH® Straws, Blue Raspberry Chewy Candy, 2 oz Tray $6.30 Was $7.85 $3.15/oz
$630current price $6.30, Was $7.85$7.85$3.15/ozSOUR PUNCH® Straws, Blue Raspberry Chewy Candy, 2 oz Tray
564.8 out of 5 Stars. 56 reviewsSour Punch Bites, Rad Reds Candy, Resealable 9oz $2.88 32.0 ¢/oz
$288current price $2.8832.0 ¢/ozSour Punch Bites, Rad Reds Candy, Resealable 9oz
614.3 out of 5 Stars. 61 reviewsSkittles Sour Candy, Chewy Candy Grab N Go - 7.2 oz Bag $8.45 $1.17/oz
2 optionsAvailable in additional 2 options$845current price $8.45$1.17/ozSkittles Sour Candy, Chewy Candy Grab N Go - 7.2 oz Bag
40644.5 out of 5 Stars. 4064 reviewsBest seller Airheads Xtremes Belts Sweetly Sour Candy Pack, Rainbow Berry, Nut Free, 3 oz Bag $1.98 66.0 ¢/oz
Best seller
$198current price $1.9866.0 ¢/ozAirheads Xtremes Belts Sweetly Sour Candy Pack, Rainbow Berry, Nut Free, 3 oz Bag
4164.6 out of 5 Stars. 416 reviewsSOUR PATCH KIDS Watermelon Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 3.5 oz $1.24 35.4 ¢/oz
6 optionsAvailable in additional 6 options$124current price $1.2435.4 ¢/ozSOUR PATCH KIDS Watermelon Soft & Chewy Gummy Candy, 3.5 oz
3054.7 out of 5 Stars. 305 reviewsSour Punch Straws Rainbow Assorted Candy, 3.2oz Tray $1.48 46.3 ¢/oz
$148current price $1.4846.3 ¢/ozSour Punch Straws Rainbow Assorted Candy, 3.2oz Tray
104.6 out of 5 Stars. 10 reviewsFeastables MrBeast Sour Strikes, Assorted Flavor Sour Gummy Candy, 7.5 oz Bag $3.92 52.3 ¢/oz
$392current price $3.9252.3 ¢/ozFeastables MrBeast Sour Strikes, Assorted Flavor Sour Gummy Candy, 7.5 oz Bag
6764.6 out of 5 Stars. 676 reviews
About this item
Product details
Sour Punch Fruity Mystery Straws, 4.5oz Tray — We Know the Flavor. We're Not Telling.
Black straws. Secret flavor. Zero hints. Sour Punch Fruity Mystery Straws are exactly what they sound like — a blind taste test in a tray, wrapped in that signature sour sugar coating and daring you to figure out what you're eating. Is it? Maybe. Could be. Take another bite and get back to us.
The only thing we'll confirm: it's fruity, it's bold, it's coated in Sour Punch's signature sour punch, and it's going to drive you absolutely crazy in the best possible way. Grab the tray, gather your crew, and see who cracks the code first. Or don't share it and keep the mystery all to yourself. Either way — good luck.
- One Secret Flavor. Good Luck. — Black straws, zero hints, and a fruity mystery flavor that'll have you and your crew debating from the first bite to the last straw in the tray
- The Ultimate Blind Taste Test — Pass the tray around and see who guesses it first. Spoiler: everyone thinks they know. Nobody agrees. That's the whole point.
- Sour Sugar Coating on Every Mysterious Bite — Whatever the flavor is, it's fully smothered in Sour Punch's signature sour coating. Bold, chewy, and impossible to put down even when it's driving you crazy
- Soft, Chewy & Built for the Long Debate — These aren't quick snacks. Mystery Straws are made for the kind of hangout where everyone has a theory and nobody wants to stop until they figure it out
- 4.5oz of Pure Intrigue — Plenty of straws to share the experience, run multiple taste tests, or go back for another round when your first guess was definitely wrong
- Low Fat, Low Sodium, All Punch — The mystery doesn't stop at the flavor. Halal and Kosher certified because everyone deserves a chance to crack the code
info:
We aim to show you accurate product information. Manufacturers, suppliers and others provide what you see here, and we have not verified it.
Specifications
Flavor
Mystery
Brand
Sour Punch
Texture
Gummy
Size
4.5 oz
Ingredients
Ingredients
CORN SYRUP, HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP, WHEAT FLOUR, SUGAR, CITRIC ACID, MALIC ACID, TARTARIC ACID, GLYCERYL MONOSTEARATE, GLYCERIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, COLOR ADDED RED 40, BLUE 1 AND YELLOW 5 (TARTRAZINE).
Customer ratings & reviews
How item rating is calculated
Customer photos
+18 images
Sort by |
Showing 1-3 of 37 reviews
Sep 13, 2025
Tkitts
5 out of 5 stars review
Aroused My Tastebuds
The Sour Patch Mystery Straws are definitely sour; with the sweet touch of sugar. My tastebuds were all over the place trying to guess the flavor. In the end I guess blue raspberry. This is a great package of candy to get for your family or for a party to try to guess the flavor. Have fun guessing the flavor!
Review from shop.americanlicorice.com
Helpful?64GB1KW1JD3V14982323757
Sep 15, 2025
Giana
5 out of 5 stars review
Loving the new mystery flavor straws!
I received a package today from sour punch straws with their new mystery flavor straws! My family and I love the new mystery flavor! They are sweet with a nice power packed punch of sour! They are fruity and tangy the perfect combination! I also love the packaging!
Review from shop.americanlicorice.com
Helpful?64GB1KW1JD3V14982323757
Aug 22, 2025
theylovemysplash
5 out of 5 stars review
So good!
Mystery straws can definitely ve used as an icebreaker lol. The packaging alone is a conversation starter. I have loved Sour Punch straws since childhood. The twist on the flavor captivating you as you try to guess without color association is cool. The quantity you receive is worth every cent. Such a fun way to experience your favorite candy.
Review from shop.americanlicorice.com
Helpful?64GB1KW1JD3V14982323757
