Tillamook Extra Creamy Salted Butter Sticks, 4 Count 16 oz
Tillamook Extra Creamy Salted Butter Sticks, 4 Count 16 oz
Hero image 0 of Tillamook Extra Creamy Salted Butter Sticks, 4 Count 16 oz, 0 of 9
Overall pick

Tillamook Extra Creamy Salted Butter Sticks, 4 Count 16 oz

Ingredients

Key item features

  • One 16 oz cardboard box of four Tillamook Extra Creamy Salted Butter Sticks
  • Stick butter is salted to perfection and made with only two ingredients-real sea salt and pasteurized cream-for a delicious and real butter taste
  • More butterfat than required makes this soft butter spreadable and creamy for easy use
  • Spread sweet cream butter on toast and rolls, or use in recipes like mashed potatoes, crepes, croissants, pie crusts, cookies and more
  • These sticks of butter are made from pasteurized high-quality cream and have no artificial preservatives or artificial flavors
  • Whole food form with a creamy texture that's perfect for cooking and baking
  • As a Certified B Corp, Tillamook is committed to being good stewards of cows and farms, of people and products, their communities and the environment
  • Serving size: 14g. 12g total fat per serving.
Current price is Now $5.28
You save $0.68
was $5.96
33.0 ¢/oz
Price when purchased online
Out of stock

How do you want your item?

How do you want your item?
Out of stock
SNAP EBT eligible

About this item

Product details

Specifications

Directions

Ingredients

Customer ratings & reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars
stars1,001 ratings196 reviews
How item rating is calculated

Customer photos

Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Sort by |

Showing 1-3 of 196 reviews

Jun 20, 2025
Teresa
Top Reviewer
Item details
Flavor: Salted Butter
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Expensive but worth it for butter-based recipes

Expensive, but worth it when it flavor matters the most. It's still less expensive than Kerrygold Irish Butter, since Kerrygold typically is sold in 8 oz packages (a half pound) rather than a full pound like Tillamook. To be honest, I think Kerrygold Irish Butter does edge out Tillamook in creaminess with 82% butterfat compared to Tillamook's 81%. Many European butters, which are harder to find where I live, and even more expensive, can have as much as 86% butterfat, which I can't imagine what a kick in the taste buds that would be! Still, Tillamook's 81% butterfat is still higher than the minimum of 80% required by USDA standards to be even called "butter". This small percentage point makes a difference in cooking or baking where fat content determines how butter-based recipes come out, not only in terms of that luscious butter flavor, but in texture. If you are making traditional Scottish shortbread, the only ingredients are flour, butter, and sugar. Sometimes a pinch of salt is added to bring out the butter flavor and balance the sweetness of the sugar. Generally I prefer to use salted butters in most of my recipes--other cookies, cakes, pie crusts, biscuits, and other foods, even those calling for unsalted butter, including American buttercream frosting that can be cloyingly sweet. I do notice that Tillamook is less salty than many salted butters--especially compared to the cheap butters that seem to add salt to cover up off, even bitter, flavors in the butter itself. You may need to still add salt in certain recipes such as pasta sauces if that is according to your taste. Tillamook does make an unsalted version as well. I have used both, and there is no difference in how my food turns out when adjusted for salt. And yes, it is delicious on bread and biscuits, toasts, vegetables, and so forth. Other than salt in the unsalted version, Tillamook also does not contain any artificial colors or preservatives, but it's butter, so it's not by any means "healthy". I find it hard not to use Tillamook for everyday because it is a definite luxury purchase in this household. I still recommend it for anyone trying out a "butter-forward" recipe.

Helpful?3512T65Y0R5T10292903
Mar 13, 2026
Lou
Item details
Flavor: Salted Butter
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

This REAL BUTTER!

I watched a rating show about butter and how it is made. This kind was the %231 rated! It costs a bit more, but after seeing the PETROLEUM put into “butter” then I will happily pay extra to not put that garbage in my body! Butter should only have two ingredients, not a dozen or more!

Helpful?3512T65Y0R5T10292903
Jan 29, 2026
NotSoExcited
Top Reviewer
Item details
Flavor: Salted Butter
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

This is REAL BUTTER. Don't expect it to be soft. It won't cut easy or spread easy straight out of the fridge but the taste is much better! when you melt it you don't have all that water like you do with margarine. As far as healthy, I personally would rather put this in my body than whatever is in the margarine or "fake" butter. It is "pricey" but it's worth it to me occasionally or for special purposes. Homemade goodies are so much better made with this and it also comes in unsalted! I think if you try it you will love it!! You might even find a store brand that you like just as much but I tried this and other Tillamook brand items. This brand hasn't failed me in any of their items so far!

Helpful?3512T65Y0R5T10292903