For several years now I have been searching for the charcoal gray eye pencils. I began to think I was the only one that used it, so you got rid of it. After reading all these reviews, I find I am not alone. What will it take for Maybelline to listen to it's customers and give them what they want? It appears that no cosmetic company is carrying a gray shade of brow pencil. I've looked with bare essential, l'oreal, Cover Girl, Clinique, any many more. Hey Maybelline, how about being different from your competitors and give your customers what they want - CHARCOAL GRAY brow pencils.