Walmart+ is here to help make every day easier. Learn more.
Walmart+ is here to help make every day easier.

Customer reviews & ratings

4.3
Average Rating:(4.3)out of 5 stars
5135 ratings
71%Recommended(698 of 976)
5 stars
3074
4 stars
1129
3 stars
424
2 stars
185
1 star
323
5 stars
3074
4 stars
1129
3 stars
424
2 stars
185
1 star
323
Most helpful positive review
1 customers found this helpful
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars
Will buy again when i run low
I got most of my make up today i jave not wore make up in couple of years or so. But going start wearing it again . I still waiting on my eye shadows and the bag i order make up and a bag as a birthday gift to myself i turned 30 yesterday and cantbwiat to do my hair and make up amd photos. Cery glad all my make up was i tact nothing was broken thankfully amd they can never keep in stock at my local store they always runni g out and the. T takes momths torestock ot so very glad it all was delivered amd i do not trust the towers in the walmarts to semd out poswer make up wothout being broke .
Most helpful negative review
5 customers found this helpful
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars
Okay Eyeliner
I was really looking forward to getting this Eyeliner and trying it out. The looks of it is really nice and Skinny. Great size when space is limited when you have a lot of other items to carry. When I opened the cap and saw the tip of the liner, I wished it was thinner. I like a more narrow line around the eyes. After numerous attempts at a narrow line, I gave up. I then tried putting on a more defining line and the Eyeliner worked better. It took me several attempts to get it to look good, but I did it. Also I did notice a few black flakes that had flaked off from the Gel Pencil line just below my lower lashes. I was using a 15X mirror, everything is more visible with that power but wanted to inspect the Gel Pencil line and see how it looked up close. So if you're into a real defining line around your eyes, this would be a great product for you
Most helpful positive review
1 customers found this helpful
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars
Will buy again when i run low
I got most of my make up today i jave not wore make up in couple of years or so. But going start wearing it again . I still waiting on my eye shadows and the bag i order make up and a bag as a birthday gift to myself i turned 30 yesterday and cantbwiat to do my hair and make up amd photos. Cery glad all my make up was i tact nothing was broken thankfully amd they can never keep in stock at my local store they always runni g out and the. T takes momths torestock ot so very glad it all was delivered amd i do not trust the towers in the walmarts to semd out poswer make up wothout being broke .
Most helpful negative review
5 customers found this helpful
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars
Okay Eyeliner
I was really looking forward to getting this Eyeliner and trying it out. The looks of it is really nice and Skinny. Great size when space is limited when you have a lot of other items to carry. When I opened the cap and saw the tip of the liner, I wished it was thinner. I like a more narrow line around the eyes. After numerous attempts at a narrow line, I gave up. I then tried putting on a more defining line and the Eyeliner worked better. It took me several attempts to get it to look good, but I did it. Also I did notice a few black flakes that had flaked off from the Gel Pencil line just below my lower lashes. I was using a 15X mirror, everything is more visible with that power but wanted to inspect the Gel Pencil line and see how it looked up close. So if you're into a real defining line around your eyes, this would be a great product for you
Lash Sensational, for a full fan effect! Lashes go supple, separated and fully fanned. Now infused with conditioning Rose Hip Oil and mineral pigments, this cult-favorite mascara delivers thick lashes that never feel weighed down. Maybelline’s exclusive fanning mascara brush with ten layers of bristles reveals layers of lashes, adding the look of length and volume without clumping. The fresh liquid formula captures lashes from root to tip for fanned-out volume. Now available in a new washable shade: Midnight Black. Ophthalmologist tested. Suitable for contact lens wearers.Packaging May Vary
5135 reviews
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Will buy again when i run low

Verified purchase

I got most of my make up today i jave not wore make up in couple of years or so. But going start wearing it again . I still waiting on my eye shadows and the bag i order make up and a bag as a birthday gift to myself i turned 30 yesterday and cantbwiat to do my hair and make up amd photos. Cery glad all my make up was i tact nothing was broken thankfully amd they can never keep in stock at my local store they always runni g out and the. T takes momths torestock ot so very glad it all was delivered amd i do not trust the towers in the walmarts to semd out poswer make up wothout being broke .

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Amazing

I didn't have high hopes for the eyeliner, but it surprised me. The eye liner stays on all day, and I have to wash my face extremely well at night to get it all off. It applies really easily, and smoothly. The top part of the applicator is black, and sometimes it's hard to tell how much of the eyeliner you're working with. It's not the easiest eyeliner applicator to work either, sometimes it's a little difficult to twist the applicator to get more eyeliner. I wish this would have come with the smudge applicator at the end like Cover Girl does, just because I use it so much. I would purchase this on my own.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Best Volume and length mascara!

I love this mascara! It is by far my favorite. I have tried some that leave clumps and/or that are too thin but not this mascara. This mascara can do it all. It can give you length and volume or you can just brush them once or twice for less volume or length. I love that this mascara does not clump unless if you over do it by overlapping layers. Other than that, it can make your lashes look like false lashes. I get asked several time what lashes do I wear and I tell them they are mine. Therefore, I highly recommend this brand and product.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Love this mascara

Verified purchase

I have used this mascara for years. Have tried many others on the market but nothing compares to this one. It seems as if every time I find something I really like, and they can't keep it on the shelves proving that it is popular, the maker decides to discontinue it. I just hope Maybelline continues making this brand.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Great Water Proof Mascara

Verified purchase

Great water proof mascara! It gives you plenty of length and separation to your lashes. You can cry in this mascara and not have to worry about it running! I learned from experience! Looking for a good waterproof mascara? Then this one is for you! I love it.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Not bad...

I wanted to try a different type of eyeliner, one that would be easier to apply and had staying power. This Maybelline Precise Skinny Eyeliner hits the mark on both. I normally use a kohl type of eyeliner pencil but get frustrated at how temperamental those types of liners can be when trying to get a more precise around my eyes. I use this product every day and am improving with my technique with each application.

The Pros: Makes a nice, smooth line. Lasts all day without smudging or flaking. No sharpening needed, which is always a bonus.

The Cons: VERY skinny barrel which can make the pencil a little difficult to hold. The tip breaks off very easily which can be frustrating when midway through the process of making your line. Products runs out rather quickly with moderate use.

The bottom line: A good product if you are wanting a more precise, skinnier line. It becomes easier to apply with practice and it glides on smoothly. Overall, a great product that is worth trying.

*I have attached 2 photos to show the difference in the thickness of the lines as compared to a normal sized eyeliner pencil and to show the size of the product itself*

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Still looking for that perfect eyeliner?

While I like the color & how this eyeliner truly "glides" on, I'm not sure how long this product will last. There is no way to visibly see how much you are using &/or how much is left. It is in a plastic stick type applicator so there is no way to tell when you're running low. Both my daughter & I used this product & both liked the way it applied & how it looked once applied. I would recommend this type of liner but would also recommend purchasing 2 - Because I wouldn't want to run out!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

It's Okay

I received this product the other day and I wanted to write a review once I'd used it for at least 24 hours. The gel part is a bit incorrect, its more like a crayon type solution that is adjustable as you use the product. I think it would be okay for after hours partying but its not a 24 hour stay on product.

Would I purchase it again ? Yes, I would, because I like the adjustable twist that allows you to use more liner opposed to the older ones where you have to sharpen them. I wasn't able to upload a photo of myself so I used another photo of someone who used the same product yet with similar results. Hope this helps.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars

Okay Eyeliner

I was really looking forward to getting this Eyeliner and trying it out. The looks of it is really nice and Skinny. Great size when space is limited when you have a lot of other items to carry. When I opened the cap and saw the tip of the liner, I wished it was thinner. I like a more narrow line around the eyes. After numerous attempts at a narrow line, I gave up. I then tried putting on a more defining line and the Eyeliner worked better. It took me several attempts to get it to look good, but I did it. Also I did notice a few black flakes that had flaked off from the Gel Pencil line just below my lower lashes. I was using a 15X mirror, everything is more visible with that power but wanted to inspect the Gel Pencil line and see how it looked up close. So if you're into a real defining line around your eyes, this would be a great product for you

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Unhappy

Verified purchase

HORRIBLE!! It comes out in all clumps. Not happy at all! Will be writing to Maybelline.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Unusable

I bought 2 Colossal mascaras but neither has the inner liner that removes the excess product from the wand causing them to be completely unusable

Helpful?
Hi there! Thank you for sharing your experience with our Maybelline Volum' Express The Colossal Mascara. We are very sorry to hear and see about this experience you had with this mascara tube. Please call us at 800-944-0730 and provide the reference number 08119510. We look forward to hearing from you!
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

very disappointed

This product does not work first time using this eyeliner i have always used gel eyeliner so I thought it would be nice and easy-to-use a gel pencil in stead of having to have the gel and brush to apply.. But that is not the case I use the eyeliner twice and had to sharpen the pencil and it broke apart had to use my old regular pencil eyeliner that I have had for years.... I was very disappointed because I love my maybelline matte makeup and eye shadows

Helpful?
Hi there! Thanks for using our Maybelline TattooStudio Waterproof Eyeliner. We are sorry to hear that you didn't have the best experience with this liner, and we know this can be very frustrating. We appreciate your feedback, and we will be passing it along to our team. We recommend that you try our Tattoostudio Waterproof, Long Wearing, Eyeliner Pencil. Effortlessly defines the lash line with a pigment-rich finish that lasts from day-to-night - it's waterproof with no smudging, no fading, and is sebum resistant for 36 hours. We hope you check it out! [[ASIN:B07GX832KD Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof, Long Wearing, Eyeliner Pencil Makeup, Deep Onyx, 0.04 Ounce]]
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Beautiful lashes without the clumps

Verified purchase

This was my first time trying the Maybelline The Falsies Waterproof Mascara, and I am very pleased with it. It makes your lashes look fuller without clumping and making them fall out. It looked very good.. Although this mascara is called The Falsies, I felt it made my almost invisible lashes look very natural rather than like I was wearing false eyelashes, but for me, that's a great thing. I really like this macara.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Great

Verified purchase

Good value and does a decent job. I love expensive mascara but wanted a cheap waterproof one for my kid's swim classes where I have to be in the pool with them. I even wore this to the gym with no issues, heavy workout mama! Definitely recommend and it does give the lashes a good lift!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars
Verified purchase

My favorite mascara!! It's truly waterproof. I have to use eye makeup solvent to remove it. It lengthens my lashes the way I need it to. It also doesn't clump.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Not waterproof

By the time I get ready to wash my face at night this mascara has run down my face and looks terrible and embarrassing! I need an actual waterproof and transfer proof mascara and this one is not it. Terrible!

Helpful?
Hey there, thanks for reaching out. Consumer feedback is very important to us and helps us improve all our products. We understand how frustrating it can be when a product does not meet an expectation and we will be forwarding your feedback along to our product development team. In the meantime, if you would be willing to try a new product, we have a suggestion that may help. Our Facestudio Master Fix Setting Spray is Maybelline’s lightweight, translucent, and oil-free mist that boosts the wear of makeup to prevent melting and color fading. We hope you will use our products with great satisfaction in the future.
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

I totally recommend falsies mascara By maybeline

Verified purchase

This mascara does exactly what it says I have thin light colored eyelashes and I was asked if I was wearing false eyelashes when I put it on. I put on a full coat rolling the brush out toward the edges I let it dry wow I coated the other eye and just as the 1st eye lash Began to feel tacky but not quite dry I put on a second coat the results were astounding

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Great product

Verified purchase

Not many eyeliner pencils do a good job of lining the waterline. I just wanted something that would go on smoothly without a struggle. This does it. Very rarely it doesn't go on as smoothly as it usually does, and if that's happens I just use a tiny bit of powder on the waterline first and it goes on perfectly.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Best mascara i have had

Generally love this mascara and i always get compliments on my eyelashes. Have been using it for over a year and dont think il ever use another one.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars

Its good, waterproof, and stays all day because I have the black one too BUT need better packaging to deliver the materials. My pencil already broke the tip when it delivers, disappointment and wasting a good tip to use

Helpful?
Hi there, thank you for sharing your experience with our Maybelline TattooStudio Waterproof Eyeliner. We are glad to hear that you enjoyed using this product but the packaging did not meet your expectations. We want to assure you that you are being heard. Consumer feedback is so important to us as it helps us when making decisions about our products, such as this. We will be forwarding this along to the appropriate department. Despite the plastic-coated appearance of the Eyeliner, it can be sharpened with a cosmetic sharpener. We hope this information helps! XOXO
Electrode, App-reviews-app, Comp-afd05e14-e22e-4696-b0dd-62e0d4f806d0, DC-eus2-prod-a2, ENV-prod-a, PROF-PROD, VER-22.4.3, SHA-f7d5d773c4aed1253b9c82c04fa4514d41e2f133, CID-