Walmart+ helps you save more time & money this holiday. Learn more.
Walmart+ helps you save more time & money this holiday.

Customer reviews & ratings

3.4
Average Rating:(3.4)out of 5 stars
65 ratings
62%Recommended(31 of 50)
5 stars
31
4 stars
9
3 stars
2
2 stars
2
1 star
21
5 stars
31
4 stars
9
3 stars
2
2 stars
2
1 star
21
Most helpful positive review
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars
Good but dried up with
Good but NOT the best. Compared to other drugstore mascaras it's pretty dang good but it didn't dry up quite quick!
Most helpful negative review
1 customers found this helpful
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars
Pain is beauty
I loved how my eyelashes looked long and thick and I usually love covergirl mascara products, but this mascara caused my eyes to feel painful, watery, and suffer from an adverse reaction. Do not reccomend at all for people with sensitive skin/eyes.
Most helpful positive review
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars
Good but dried up with
Good but NOT the best. Compared to other drugstore mascaras it's pretty dang good but it didn't dry up quite quick!
Most helpful negative review
1 customers found this helpful
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars
Pain is beauty
I loved how my eyelashes looked long and thick and I usually love covergirl mascara products, but this mascara caused my eyes to feel painful, watery, and suffer from an adverse reaction. Do not reccomend at all for people with sensitive skin/eyes.
Covergirl Exhibitionist Mascara
65 reviews
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

As Good as "Tartist Lash Paint" without the Price!

I got this in the mail and I was skeptical about the claims on the box but upon using it, it does indeed look so similar to my Tarte mascara but at a fraction of the price! Definitely my new go-to!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

one of the best ever!

i rarely write reviews but this mascara deserves one! it's great! no clumps, no flakes, no sticky stiff feeling. the brush is really nice too! i am extremely picky because my eyes are sensitive and this one has been great so far! :)

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Love Exhibitionist Mascara!

I just found this mascara a couple of weeks ago, and I LOVE it! It applies so smoothly, with no glops or clumps. It gives me length, volume, and beautiful separation. I use it over the Lash Blast Amplify primer, and it stays put. No flakes or smudges, but comes off easily.with my cream cleanser. Way to go CoverGirl! You're my fave!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

have to tip my hat to covergirl. i picked this up today for the great price and have to say I'm not disappointed. I normally use L'Oreal Lash paradise, have been very happy with their product, wears great, doesn't flake, smudge lasts through a long day. But I think I will be replacing it with this. It went on smooth, no clumping on the first stroke. Made my short asian lashes look long and wispy. It did not have any harsh chemical smell to it like covergirl primer nor did it irritate my eyes,

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

LOVE IT!

I absolutely LOVE this mascara! I have never seen a mascara work so well. Granted, I have NOT tried them ALL, but I DO know that I do NOT like the plastic wands because it seems like forever to get the lashes coated.....I've tried 4 different mascaras over the years with plastic wands and hated them all........will NEVER buy a plastic wand mascara EVER again!

I have tried this Exhibitionist mascara in the "very black" shade and what I love about it is that is goes on VERY easy and does NOT flake or smudge.....and because it does not take long to get the lashes coated, it is a great mascara when one is in a hurry. Although when I first saw how fat the wand was, I feared that it would make a big old mess trying to get my lower lashes coated...........not only was it NOT a mess AT ALL, but it is the "BEST" mascara I have EVER tried for getting the lower lashes EASILY, quickly, and fully coated. While it is not a dry mascara, it is in no way too wet either..........it's just right. I have only applied 2 quick coats and have not had the time to really work with it to try to achieve a longer look to my lashes, I'll just say my lashes are short and 2 quick coats were sufficient.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Finally found the Perfect Mascara!!

Im a fan of Katy Perry and I saw how she modeled beautifully with those lashes using the mascara and I decided to give it a shot. Little did I know that it will turn into the best mascara I have ever used. I have tried all the expensive brands and drugstore makeup but this one works so well. I usually take about 5 minutes with each eye (with two layers) and it honesty looks so long and bold. I get compliments often on my eyelashes and people are stunned when I tell them its covergirl. My friends now say my eyelashes are my unique "signature" about myself. This will always be my all-time favorite!! Covergirl, please don't take this mascara away.. I LOVE this!!! Thank you!!! <33

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Good but dried up with

Verified purchase

Good but NOT the best. Compared to other drugstore mascaras it's pretty dang good but it didn't dry up quite quick!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Pretty nice

This mascara works pretty well and removes very easily. I use two coats for an average, have nothing to do, everyday look and use three for a more dramatic and prettier lash. Do be careful because it can start to clump. In the beginning, there was no flaking and no smudges! I didn't purchase waterproof so I was very impressed with the wear, especially because just about every mascara and eyeliner smudge on me. It is a wetter formula which means it will transfer until set. During the day if I sneeze or my eyes water at all it immediately runs. Still not a deal breaker but a bit annoying. I would not trust it to wear at work during allergy season. For most days I can get over it because it can give me nice looking lashes with a couple of coats and does not smudge unless wet. It also holds a curl all day. However, I have had it just over a month and it is starting to dry out which can be nice if it is too wet but not in this case! It now, absolutely flakes! Itty bitty almost powder flakes, to visible, get in your eye, irritating flakes! All over every day now there are flakes. It is not too bad for the first few hours but by midday, I can see them under my eyes and upper cheek, and by evening they sometimes start to get into my eyes. I do think it can hold it's own to some of the pricier mascaras and I would repurchase but definitely not for $9-10.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Great Mascara, Blue one SMELLS TERRIBLE

So I'm not generally a fan of covergirl mascaras because they don't give enough impact...but this one is great! The wand is great, no clumping, and it thickens, lengthens, and adds loads of volume. My only complaint is that the blue one smells so foul! It's like I'm putting death on my eyelashes and it's a huge deterrent! Covergirl, please fix this, I don't understand how it made it to the market with the terrible smell!! Other than that, I look forward to purchasing the black one because I love how it looks. This would be a 4 stars if it weren't for the smell and will be a 5 stars if it doesn't smudge!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Pain is beauty

I loved how my eyelashes looked long and thick and I usually love covergirl mascara products, but this mascara caused my eyes to feel painful, watery, and suffer from an adverse reaction. Do not reccomend at all for people with sensitive skin/eyes.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

My New Everyday Mascara

I am very picky when it comes to mascaras because I don't have a lot of lashes to begin with.This is my new favorite mascara! It separates, lifts, lengthens, and volumizes my lashes. It also holds the curl of my super stubbornly straight lashes. It's also cruetly-free! I love it! Thank you Covergirl!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Waterproof exhibitionist mascara

Waterproof exhibitionist mascara. I bought this product just before my vacation to use in the water. It leaked after every use, destroying my cosmetic bag and everything else in it! Got all over my hands, and consequently, some of my clothing, after, unknowingly, brushing my clothing after use! This stuff does not wag out!! I have used cover girl products in the past with no problems, but this was ridiculous! Will steer away from these products in the future .

Helpful?
We are sorry to hear that this product didn't become your go-to! We always want our consumers to be happy with our products. We would love to find you a product that fits your needs better. Just give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 or send us an email through our Contact Us page so we can chat. We want to make this right with you! Thank you for your feedback and we hope to hear from you!
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Globby mess

I like several Cover Girl products, but this isn't one of them, nor is the mascara primer. I threw them both away. The mascara brush is poorly designed. The product is a globby mess on the brush. The primer is also messy and clumpy and does not evenly distribute on the brush.

Helpful?
We are sorry to hear that this product wasn't your perfect fit. We never want to hear this. Mascara should be easy to apply and clump free! Please give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 or send us an email through our Contact Us page. We would love the chance to remedy this experience with you and fit you with the best mascara for your needs. Thank you for your feedback and we hope you will reach out soon.
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Remarkable mascara at drugstore prices!

I adore Tarte's very pricey Maneater mascara, but I'm not a wealthy woman, so I shopped for a reasonably prices alternative, and here it is! Almost as good as Maneater but I'd call it even better since it's less than half the price! Keep it around a long, long time please!

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Ohh baby!!

I tried covergirl exhibitionist mascara 2 days ago and it really stood out to ME. I have decent length lashes, flat near the tear duct until 3/4 of my eye then the very spazzy curled lashes at the outer corner of my eye. The way I apply mascara is on my lash roots first (I never stroke up and through). Gently shaking the brush side to side (minimally as if it was vibrating). I let it sit for roughly 15-30 seconds to allow it to thicken and stay in place. Finally I go in again after dipping my mascara wand in the tube. Beginning at the root of the lash stroke it all the way through coating them completely in mascara. This will give your lashes a fuller look. If u have time repeat the first step 2x. ++It's vegan

-Shadyy L

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Don't buy

I thought it would be fun to get a colored mascara since all you could see is my eyes with these masks on. Turns out I thought ring. The formula of this mascara is not good. It took 4 coats to see a hint of blue. It also don't do anything as far as length or definition. So just save your money for a better colored mascara.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Clinique convert.

This mascara is great. I do warm it up before use. I usually use clump crusher. But this is better for a fuller look. I'm not sure about the other reviews. But I think it's great.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Horrible

This is the worse clumpiest mess I have ever used. Look at that picture and explain to me how that will not make a clumpy mess.

Helpful?
We would like to learn more about your experience. Please call us at 1-800-426-8374. We are here for you Monday through Friday from 9 am to 6 pm Eastern Time. We look forward to your call!
Average Rating:(1.0)out of 5 stars

Clumps on eyelids

Every time I use the mascara, the end of the brush near the wand leaves large smudges on the eyelid or under eye. You have to wipe it off almost completely to not have this happen.

Helpful?
We are sorry to hear that you are having some smudging issues with this mascara. We never want to hear this and would love to gather more information about your experience to see how we can help. Give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 or send us an email through our contact us page. We want to do what we can to rectify this situation and find you the best product for your needs if this doesn't hit the mark. Thank you for your feedback and we hope to hear from you soon.
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

The best!!!

This is the best drug store mascara out there. Love it. It's dramatic. Makes my lashes look like falsies and doesn't come off under eyes. I am a mascara snob and usually stick to high end. But this is just as good as any of my pricey faves. Highly recommend.

Helpful?
Electrode, App-reviews-app, Comp-b7f9b84c-c156-4212-9318-525355c996ee, DC-eus2-prod-a2, ENV-prod-a, PROF-PROD, VER-22.4.3, SHA-f7d5d773c4aed1253b9c82c04fa4514d41e2f133, CID-