I really like this new product. What I'm not happy with is the way the container was made. As has been mentioned, the second time I went to use it a huge chunk of the pencil fell out and into the bathroom sink. Happened again the next time I used it. PLUS, the smudger end stays in the cap when I try to pull the cap off. I have to put it back on, and then very carefully work the cap off to be sure the smudger stays where it's supposed too.......Way too much to deal with. I bought the dark green color and if I am very careful in applying it, I am very pleased with the outcome. I can see where it could become too much, real quick.