Customer reviews

Customer Reviews | 46 reviews | 3.5 out of 5

3.5 stars

46 reviews | 3.5 out of 5

3.5 stars

46 reviews | 3.5 out of 5

Would recommend to a friend
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
1-20 of 45 total reviews
Would recommend to a friend



1-20 of 45 total reviews
1-20 of 45 reviews
Quick thick dark line, can't find in stores

Customer review by Rcastillo

5.0 stars 3/4/2016 by Rcastillo
by Rcastillo

Produces a thick dark line in one stroke. Crayon type glides on smoothly & no smudging. My eyes look amazing in all my pictures with very little effort. Can't find in stores anymore so currently searching other brands with similar product.

#1 best A+++

Customer review by PrincessKathryn

5.0 stars 1/21/2016 by PrincessKathryn
by PrincessKathryn

by far my favorite liner, ever. stays on looks beautiful. so incredibly sad I cant find it in stores anymore. I have he black, brown, blue, and purple.

Nice color - nice smudger

Customer review by ejk725

3.0 stars 7/17/2013 by ejk725
by ejk725
Walmart associate

I like the smudger on the other end, but the pencil is a little thick so it was kind of hard for me to use on my small eyes. The color was great, it lasted a good amount of time, but the best part was the convenience of the smudge brush on the other end.

Was this review helpful? (1) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
Was this review helpful?
San Francisco, CA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
Walmart associate
Lovethis pencil!

Customer review by MCVaz

5.0 stars 10/27/2015 by MCVaz
by MCVaz

Master smoky pencil makes a dramatic eye so easy to do. Or I can use it for a regular daytime look. Versatile and easy to use! I love it! But why is it already out of the stores? Can't find it anywhere. Had to replenish my supply online. :(

Could Be Happier with This

Customer review by Fall-Lover

2.0 stars 10/23/2013 by Fall-Lover
by Fall-Lover

I really like this new product. What I'm not happy with is the way the container was made. As has been mentioned, the second time I went to use it a huge chunk of the pencil fell out and into the bathroom sink. Happened again the next time I used it. PLUS, the smudger end stays in the cap when I try to pull the cap off. I have to put it back on, and then very carefully work the cap off to be sure the smudger stays where it's supposed too.......Way too much to deal with. I bought the dark green color and if I am very careful in applying it, I am very pleased with the outcome. I can see where it could become too much, real quick.

Best eyeliner ever!

Customer review by Gabby Goose

5.0 stars 8/25/2015 by Gabby Goose
by Gabby Goose

Only eyeliner that stays on the inner lids and has a true smoky effect! Can't use anything else! I live by the black and the brown! Getting hard to find ;(

Gabby Goose
Mixed emotions, I both love and hate it...

Customer review by BellaDonnaGypsyWitch

2.0 stars 9/15/2015 by BellaDonnaGypsyWitch
by BellaDonnaGypsyWitch

I picked up four of the emerald ones when they were on sale because the packaging picture looked so pretty. I put it on and it looks way darker, so that was a disappointment from the start, then after a while my eyes and head started to hurt. I tried it again on a different day and still the same, so maybe I'm allergic? I will say that it is really long lasting and doesn't budge though!

Was this review helpful? (0) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
Was this review helpful?
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
In love

Customer review by Andigirl333

5.0 stars 7/29/2015 by Andigirl333
by Andigirl333

I Love this product. I wear it everyday. I get a lot of compliments on my make up do to this eyeliner. I am upset that you discontinued my favourite colour. Scorching Brown 625. I will have to find another product similar. I will miss this eyeliner

So easy to use, great outcome!

Customer review by AmyinSF

5.0 stars 7/11/2013 by AmyinSF
by AmyinSF
Walmart associate

If you are into a smokey eye this is a really awesome product. It's crazy easy to use and goes on smoothly and effortlessly. The head of the pencil is super thick allowing a lot of coverage. The other side has the smudger thing which is easy to use to get the perfect smokey look. The only complaint I have it that it takes a lot of eye makeup remove to get it off at the end of the day but that is to be expected when you wear heavy eye makeup. I also tried using the tip of the pencil to make a more natural line and it was a little hard but do- able. Great product for the price, I would try it out if a smokey eye is your preference.

Was this review helpful? (0) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
Was this review helpful?
San Francisco
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Once per week
Walmart associate

Customer review by Lulusmommy

5.0 stars 7/6/2015 by Lulusmommy
by Lulusmommy

I stumbled upon this product at Dollar Tree this past week. I have only tried it as a liner, but so far, I am super happy I picked these up. I got Blue Blaze and the Purple one. I wish DT carried more colors :( LOVING THESE THOUGH :)


Customer review by sandras

1.0 stars 7/25/2013 by sandras
by sandras

I just used it once, the next time, I took the cap off and the pencil had gotten stuck inside the cap and I can no longer use the product. Not that I really would anyway because it was like trying to draw on eyeliner with an actual crayon and did not blend into a smokey look. This was the biggest waste of my money. I doubt I will buy any Maybelline product again. Even if they sent me this stuff for free, I would toss it.

Awesome but defective. Need to revise, Maybelline

Customer review by brigetteshaffer

3.0 stars 4/15/2015 by brigetteshaffer
by brigetteshaffer

Found this item 1 month ago. Excited 2 use "smoky" for my brown eyes. Wanted something EZ 2 use besides my usual dark eye powder & liquid liner. EZ 2 apply. Looked GREAT! Next day, opened it & found it smashed inside. Need 2 revise this Maybelline!

The best and easiest eye shadow ever

Customer review by Mrs. Earl

5.0 stars 1/29/2015 by Mrs. Earl
by Mrs. Earl

I have only used this for a year but love it. It is a wide soft application and last all day. when I am in a hurry I just use this and not my mascara. I wish I had found this many years ago. It is the perfect color and not pitch black. Love it!!

Mrs. Earl

Customer review by mp23jp

5.0 stars 7/22/2013 by mp23jp
by mp23jp

Smoky eyes have nevr been this easy and the staying power is amazing. My eyes tend to water and I can go all day without having to fix once. I don't usually leave reviews on products, but this product worked so well I wanted to make sure to let others know. I bought the charcoal and plan on going back and buying all the others. Thank you.


Customer review by Noelle1114

1.0 stars 8/5/2013 by Noelle1114
by Noelle1114

I have brown eyes and botght the smoking charcoal. The color was more green and while the pencil initial went on smooth, the blending smudge did absolutely nothing. I feel like this product is just a chuncky pencil that after first use is pointless. I find this product to be a huge waste of money and a disappointment.


Customer review by Tameka

1.0 stars 12/18/2014 by Tameka
by Tameka

I bought this and had high expectations of it, and in the end; it was too clumpy and kept smudging. I was angry I wasted money on this product, please fix it. I'm still fuming from having to scrub it off my eyes.

Dramatic eyes

Customer review by saleetah

4.0 stars 7/11/2013 by saleetah
by saleetah
Walmart associate
 Rated by Mom

This eyeliner is intended to give you a dramatic look. The liner is a thick, smooth and creamy pencil that does not need to be sharpened. It's so soft that it easily molds and contours to either give you a finer or thicker look. The built in sponge on the other side of the pencil makes it easy to smudge and give off a dramatic look. What I didn't like is that when you twist the pencil to apply, you have to remember to twist it back down otherwise the cap will not go on and the pencil will get squished.

Was this review helpful? (0) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
Was this review helpful?
San Mateo, CA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Age:35 - 44
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
Walmart associate
 Rated by Mom
love the product make it better

Customer review by mkd

2.0 stars 7/16/2014 by mkd
by mkd

best smoke eyes i had in the scorching brown with blonde only problem is the pencil falls out of the tube and i have to keep putting it back in.....right from the start it was falling out....not sure if this is defective product.

Like The Colors!

Customer review by _lovelymercy

4.0 stars 1/28/2015 by _lovelymercy
by _lovelymercy

Great colors! I have the color blue blaze and smoldering violet, there pretty colors and very creamy! Last for a pretty long time :)


Customer review by WHITLEY

4.0 stars 11/7/2013 by WHITLEY

I decided to try this pencil when I couldn't find my regular product at my local Kroger. I'm actually very happy that I was not able to find what I was looking for. I am HUGE fan of smoky eyes and this pencil gave me just what I needed. 2 thumbs up!

1-20 of 45 total reviews
1-20 of 45 reviews