I like my case very much over all,
but it is a bit bulky,
and the rubber coating makes it difficult to put in and out of pockets.
It does have the waist clip, but I am a very small person and it pulls my pants down, so I like to put it in my pocket. I also have had the clip that holds the phone come undone on it's own, luckily I noticed when it happened.
I have had my case replaced once as the rubber parts ripped at corners.
I had no problems with Otter box replacing it, even with me being out of the country at the time.
The rubber parts stretch eg the part that gets used the most, that covers where you charge your phone.
But I have dropped my phone and it has been fine, which is what I mainly bought it for, I just find that I am frequently carrying it in my hand, which I did not want to have to do.