I figured a waterproof mascara would be a wise purchase with summer here as well as that I work out just about everyday. Unfortunately I came to find that not only does this mascara run, it some how runs even more so than my non-waterproof mascara that I had been using (miss manga). Despite the fact that this mascara ends up all over my eyelids and under eye area, I cannot seem to remove it with any sort of substance-makeup remover, oil, etc. On top of all of this, I feel as though it does not do anything at all for my eyelashes; it doesn't lengthen, or thicken them, however I will say, it holds a curl. Really disappointed in the product.