I use to love this moisturizer, but I will no longer be buying it. It use to have a great texture and worked well under make up, now not so much. The consistency is too watery, like a sunscreen that was left in the sun too long. I even put it in the fridge hoping that would thicken it up somewhat, and it just made it cold. I understand they had to change the formula to meet new FDA standards, but I wish they would have found a way to keep it's light, yet creamy texture, but no dice. I have been buying from the company for two years and have loved their products, but they continually change their products formula, and I have yet to like the results. I have stopped using their shampoo, conditioner, body wash, and now this. I hope they never change their Yes to Cucumbers Milk Cleanser. I want to support this company because of their approach to the environment, nature, and ethics, but if its products continue to fail I will take all of my purchases elsewhere.