This fireplace is very impressive. Even more beautiful in person than it is online!! The only thing I would like to be different is if the side bookcases could be attached somehow, rather than separate pieces. It would just make it a little more streamlined. Otherwise, I LOVE IT!! I have always wanted a fireplace, and this definitely is a great subsitute. I give it a a 'good' rating for quality, only because I like solid wood furniture, and this is a lot of composite. Unfortunaetly, solid wood pieces are hard to come by these days.